This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Eighty years following the initial observation by Schmidt that intraocular pressure (IOP) increases following ingestion of water1 there is a resurgence of interest in the role of the water-drinking test (WDT) in the investigation of glaucoma. Why? The impetus behind these studies has been two-fold. First, there is a school of thought that suggests that IOP spikes and diurnal IOP variation are important in the progression of glaucoma. Second, there is an increased understanding that a single IOP measurement in the clinic does not necessarily reflect what is happening to an individual's IOP through the course of the day. The importance of IOP peaks and diurnal variation to the development of visual field damage in glaucoma has been reported by several investigators.2,3 Higher peaks of IOP have been noted to affect both the extent and rate of glaucomatous damage.2,4–8 Indeed, a recent Consensus statement has suggested that further research is necessary to explore the role of such fluctuations of IOP in the progression rate of glaucoma.9 If IOP fluctuation and spikes are considered important to glaucoma progression then identifying such IOP variations may lead to modifications in our management. For example, it is well-recognized that some patients continue to show evidence of progression despite seemingly well-controlled IOP.10–12 This is often attributed to IOP-independent mechanisms that lead to continued retinal ganglion cell death. However, an alternative hypothesis might be that apparently controlled IOP (as measured in single point clinic determinations) may not reflect the varied range of IOP to which the eye is exposed.13,14 Investigators have employed several strategies to identify such variations in IOP. Twenty-four hour IOP measurements have demonstrated that IOP does indeed show significant fluctuation – even in ‘well-controlled’ glaucoma patients. However, there are some obvious inherent limitations in 24-hour IOP monitoring: it is not routinely practical, it is time consuming and it is conducted in an artificial setting modifying the total patient environment as well as adherence with therapy compared to their average day. Obviously, at home IOP monitoring has also been trialled but these devices have not shown adequate reliability.15 Modified diurnal IOP measurements during outpatient/office visits are useful, but have been shown to fail to identify significant spikes in IOP.13 This is where the WDT comes in. It has been suggested that the IOP elevation associated with drinking one litre (some investigators prefer 10 mL/kg of body weight) of water within a period of five to fifteen minutes may be a useful technique for identifying patients who may be experiencing diurnal spikes of IOP and hence, may be at a risk for glaucomatous progression. Initially, the WDT was investigated as a possible screening test for glaucoma. However, studies demonstrated that while glaucoma patients have an increase in IOP, the WDT had inadequate sensitivity and specificity.16,17 Investigators have also demonstrated that the response of patients to the WDT may be correlated with the severity of glaucoma and that a patients’ response to the WDT may be predictive of visual field progression.18,19 A more recent line of investigation has been in relation to whether the WDT may be used as a surrogate for detecting patients who have IOP spikes not identified during clinic hours.20,21 The pilot study by Kumar et al. elegantly adds to the body of literature which supports that the WDT may have a place as a practical investigation of IOP amongst glaucoma patients and deserves further investigation.22 Other studies have also demonstrated that the response of IOP during WDT reflects the diurnal pattern of IOP. Konstas et al. identified that those with advanced glaucoma who had undergone trabeculectomy had a 24-hour range of IOP of 2.3 +/− 0.8, while corresponding patients managed with maximal medical treatment had a range of 4.8 +/− 2.3.23 A recent study by our research group that compared the response to the WDT amongst a similar cohort of patients reported comparable results: those who had undergone successful trabeculectomy with mitomycin-C had an IOP range of 2.2 mmHg +/− 1.3 mmHgto while their medically controlled counterparts had a statistically greater range of 5.6mmHg +/− 1.9 mmHg.24 Interestingly, 37% of patients in the medically treated group had spikes greater than 18 mmHg during 24-hour diurnal IOP testing, while none of the corresponding surgical patients exhibited such a spike. Importantly, 43% of the medically managed patients showed a spike greater than 18mmHg following WDT compared with no such IOP elevations in the trabeculectomy group. What is the mechanism of the WDT? Several mechanisms have been postulated to explain the IOP fluctuation that occurs in response to the WDT. Changes in IOP are produced by either factors that influence aqueous influx or alter its outflow or both. Theories have focused on changes in blood osmolarity or alterations in episcleral venous pressure. It has been suggested that drinking water, or any hypotonic fluid, results in an influx of water into body tissues including the eye as a consequence of changes in blood–ocular osmotic pressure gradient.25 However, several studies have found no variation in haematocrit, total plasma osmolality, or plasma colloid osmotic pressure 26,27 suggesting that neither vitreous hydration nor increased aqueous production can entirely explain the changes in IOP. Brubaker theorized that the WDT is an indirect tool to measure outflow facility28 as explained by the Goldman equation where Fa is aqueous flow, Fu is uveoscleral outflow, and trabecular outflow = trabecular outflow facility (C) and outflow pressure (IOP − Pev), with Pev being the episcleral venous pressure. The ingestion of one litre of water results in changes in the episcleral venous pressure29 as a consequence of the increase in central venous pressure and peripheral venous pressure. An increased episcleral venous pressure may result in increased IOP not only because of the decreased pressure head for aqueous outflow but also may be initially related to engorgement of the choroidal vasculature. It is possible that this increased episcleral venous pressure after WDT increases outflow resistance and the trabecular outflow. Therefore, the variation in IOP associated with the WDT is thought to be a result of individual outflow facility. The low facility of outflow in the glaucomatous eye may explain, at least in part, the larger IOP fluctuation. A similar theory is proposed to explain the well-documented increase in IOP that occurs in the recumbent or inverted head posture positions.30,31 It is also thought to partly explain the observation that supine IOP measurements estimate peak nocturnal IOP better than sitting measurements.32 However, other possible mechanisms may contribute to the response to the water-drinking test. Several studies have established that water drinking induces a profound autonomic pressor response in patients with autonomic failure and a modest response in the elderly, but not in healthy controls. However, healthy controls did show an increase in peripheral vascular resistance following water drinking. Consequently, it has been used therapeutically to treat the syncope associated with autonomic failure or orthostatic stress often associated with blood donation.33 Water drinking has also been shown to increase blood pressure in older normal control subjects but has no effect on younger patients. Interestingly, plasma volume, plasma renin activity, and plasma vasopressin concentration do not change with water drinking.34 None the less, it has been shown that sympathetic activity occurs as a result of water drinking and plasma noradrenalin levels increase after water drinking by a magnitude at least as great as that elicited by smoking two unfiltered cigarettes (97 pg/mL increase)35 or ingesting 250 mg of caffeine (102 pg/mL increase).36 This may contribute to the increase in IOP seen in glaucoma patients if such patients have a component of autonomic dysfunction, as has been proposed by some. Abnormal autoregulatory mechanisms in choroidal vasculature may result in alterations in choroidal volume in eyes with glaucoma similar to mechanisms proposed by Quigley37 as a mechanism for aqueous misdirection. Interestingly, Spaeth and Vacharat noted that atropine 1% attenuates the IOP spike seen in glaucoma patients in response to water drinking.38 Additional research involving the response to water drinking in patients with angle closure may shed further light on this possible mechanism. At a time when investigations for glaucoma seem to be increasingly ‘hi-tech’ dependent, the re-emergence of the humble WDT may provide the clinician with an opportunity to extrapolate useful, simply acquired, and hitherto often overlooked, information regarding the status of individual's IOP diurnal fluctuation.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Helen V. Danesh‐Meyer (2008) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: