Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
There is no doubt that we are living in a digital age. A quick glance around any household, library or café captures images of texting, browsing, messaging and podcasting. Health care has similarly embraced digital technology, with electronic patient records incorporating images and test results, online ordering of prescriptions and appointments, and freely accessible internet-based health information. Today’s students have grown up with computers, mobile phones and MP3 players. Primary school children may still gather in a circle to hear a story, but they are equally likely to be interacting with a smartboard, or collectively writing their own illustrated stories on the classroom computers. These scenes may seem somewhat irrelevant to clinical teaching; however, they signal a profound shift in the ways in which students and trainees are learning and developing their understanding of the world. Clinical teachers are ‘struggling to teach a population that speaks an entirely new language’.1 This article aims to help clinical teachers make sense of some of the technological changes and learning shifts that often present as a generation gap between teachers and learners. Prensky’s image of ‘digital natives’ powerfully captures the ways in which the current generation of learners have grown up immersed in a digital culture, contrasting this with the image of the ‘digital immigrant’, who is learning to inhabit a new and interesting land, but retains an ‘accent’ from lands of old.1 Some of you may already feel like digital immigrants, being reasonably fluent in the ways of this new world, using the internet on a daily basis for work and leisure, and eagerly seeking out new ways to engage with emerging technologies. Some of you may already enhance your clinical teaching with a range of e-resources, perhaps using simulation tools or digitally based teaching resources. Our recent survey of clinical teachers engaged in a post-graduate certificate (PGCert) in Medical Education programme, revealed that almost 90 per cent go online daily, and see themselves as confident or fairly confident users of the internet. A total of 60 per cent had some prior online learning experience, and just over a third had some experience of e-teaching.2 This level of engagement seems promising; however, many aspects of the digital world are unfamiliar. More than half of our respondents were unaware of (or had never used) a range of mobile technologies or social-networking tools, such as podcasts, blogs, wikis or RSS (Really Simple Syndication) feeds. Perhaps they are digital tourists3 in these foreign lands, learning enough of the language and culture to function whilst there, but happily returning home after brief and infrequent visits. For clinical teaching to make the most of e-learning, the foundations need to be built on sound educational principles.4 Effective e-learning moves from seeing learning simply as the transmission of information to seeing learning as the construction and co-construction of meaning. The internet is not just a mere repository of resources (albeit a rather sophisticated repository), but is also a source of technologies and tools that facilitate communication and collaborative learning between teachers and learners.5 It is suggested that because digital natives’ thought processes and information literacy were formed in the digital environment, they are different from those of digital immigrants whose literacy skills were formed in the print world.1,3 Digital natives thrive on multi-tasking, gaming, multimedia resources and non-linear learning, becoming impatient with the step-wise approaches of traditional teaching methods.1,6 This is not to say that all students are confident users of the wide range of learning technologies available, and there is an increasing literature that highlights the challenges for learners (many of which are similar to those identified by clinical teachers) and for educational organisations.7 Digital natives have high expectations of information and communication technology (ICT), in providing unrestricted access to resources, materials and networks, but are less clear on how Web 2.0 and social networking fits into their learning experience. Importantly, they expect tangible benefits from using ICT, and also expect face-to-face interaction to form a large part of their educational experience.8 Understanding and appreciating these cultural shifts is perhaps the first step for aspiring e-teachers. ‘The challenge for medical educators is … to consider how the latest technology can be used to enhance learning.’9 Not only do clinical teachers need to be confident about the language and educational principles applied to e-learning, but they also need to find out just what is ‘out there’ in this ever-changing culture and territory. Whether you are ready to be immersed in a new culture or simply wish to prepare for an extended vacation, a phrase book (Box 1) and a road map (Fig. 1) are essential. An e-learning road map for clinical teachers Adapted from Salmon, G. (2005: 212).10 Our road map is adapted from Salmon’s strategic framework for e-learning and pedagogical innovation, which has been used extensively to integrate and develop e-learning in higher education settings.10 Use the road map to consider how you might develop more confidence and capabilities in integrating e-learning into your clinical teaching. If you do not plan to be fully immersed in the e-learning culture, then you should start your explorations in quadrants 1 and 3. In quadrant 1, you might aim to use familiar technologies for existing purposes but explore a wider range. Many clinical teachers rely on free-access e-learning resources and tools, rather than a dedicated virtual learning environment (VLE). So, one step might be to identify easily accessible e-resources (journals and tutorials) to support your development as a clinical teacher (i.e. for your own e-learning) or to support the development of your students and trainees. Although you may not have ready access to e-journals via subscription, many journals offer free access to some of their key print resources and e-journal formats. These include the BMJ’s ‘ABC of learning and teaching in medicine’, the Medical Journal of Australia’s ‘Teaching on the run’ series, Medical Education onlineTM and MedEdPORTAL, for a range of free-access resources for medical educators. Use Google or Google ScholarTM to search for more resources and follow up interesting articles. Increasingly, professional bodies and organisations offer a range of e-resources or reusable learning objects (RLOs) on key topics and issues (and which may involve some interaction, e.g. quizzes, short tests or reflective activities), such as the London Deanery Faculty Development website for clinical teachers. If you are keen to move from text to multi-media-based resources, many online resources, mostly focussed on clinical and technical skills, provide opportunities for students and trainees to interact with new ideas and concepts. Online collaboration can help maximise learning opportunities. Communication tools can be asynchronous (such as e-mail and discussion boards) or synchronous (such as messaging). Many tools are available within formal, managed VLEs, but some creative thinking (and sharing ideas with learners) can identify alternatives. Setting up a group e-mailing list for trainees or a tutor group may be a first step. Instant messaging may allow group discussions in real time. Those of you ready to venture into quadrant 3, where you might use existing technologies (such as Web 2.0 tools11) for new purposes may consider creating a closed group within a social networking space, such as Facebook, which offers a wide range of communication opportunities, including discussion boards, bulletin boards and the use of blogs. Venture a little further in and you could consider developing wikis for educational purposes. The prime wiki example is Wikipedia™, an interactive encyclopaedia that is constantly developed and edited by a worldwide population. Think of the learning potential of asking students and trainees to develop a wiki focusing on diagnosis and management of key conditions in your specialty. A quick search of the net will identify a range of free access sites that can host student wikis. Your journey might start in quadrant 3, where you start to think creatively about how existing technologies can be used to enhance further learning, perhaps with a podcast of the week, which might focus on a real case or a management dilemma. Free software (such as Audacity) can be downloaded to record podcasts that students can listen to on standard MP3 players. Another example might be digital story telling. Patient Voices is a wonderful example of the power of narrative, and includes stories from junior doctors that trigger thoughtful consideration about the nature of effective clinical teaching and supervision. Exploring new territory around collaborative learning might seem more risky, but is potentially more rewarding and fun for both learners and teachers. Second LifeTM is a virtual world attracting considerable interest. Many universities now have a Second Life Campus, and are experimenting with virtual tutorials, in which students (represented by their own avatars) come together in this virtual world to discuss and debate real issues. Other virtual worlds are available on the net, such as the University of Leeds' virtual primary care centre where users explore the centre, ‘interact’ with staff and learn more about key patient presentations, by watching video clips and presentations. This article has highlighted some of the ways in which e-learning can be integrated into the resources tool kit of clinical teachers. If you want to learn more, there are a number of sharing tools, valuable guides and resources for both digital tourists and immigrants. These include YouTube’s™ excellent series of video clips explaining e-technologies (such as wikis) in plain English, or the Joint Information Systems Committee (JISC) guides and resources on all aspects of using learning technologies in education. However, as with any trip to foreign lands, the best teachers are the natives. E-learning provides a wonderful opportunity to engage collaboratively with students and trainees. You can readily trade your context and content expertise with their digital expertise, and jointly end up with a more valuable experience in the process. Happy travelling! BMJ ‘ABC of teaching and learning in Medicine’: http://www.bmj.com Medical Journal of Australia ‘Teaching on the run’ series: http://www.umdnj.edu/meg/cte_in-house/MJA_teaching_on_run_tips.htm Medical Education online: http://www.med-ed-online.org MedEdPortal: http://www.aamc.org/mededportal Google Scholar: http://scholar.google.co.uk London Deanery faculty development e-learning modules: http://www.faculty.londondeanery.ac.uk/e-learning St George’s Hospital Medical School clinical skills online project: http://www.elu.sgul.ac.uk/cso/ New England Journal of medicine clinical videos: http://content.nejm.org/misc/videos.shtml?ssource=recentVideos Simulated patients: http://www.simulatedpatients.co.uk Facebook: http://www.new.facebook.com/home.php Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page Audacity, free open-source software for recording and editing sounds: http://audacity.sourceforge.net Patient Voices: http://www.patientvoices.org.uk DiPex: http://www.dipex.org/ Second Life: http://secondlife.com University of Leeds virtual clinical learning zones: http://healthcare.leeds.ac.uk/pages/learning/learning.htm YouTube: http://www.youtube.com http://www.jisc.ac.uk/ (All accessed 29 September 2008.)
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Morris et al. (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: