Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In an accompanying article, Josephsen et al. (1999) describe the interesting observation that a monoclonal antibody (MAb) originally generated against purified porcine vimentin (V9) reacts with a novel epitope on an unrelated protein, an epitope that is generated only after glutaraldehyde fixation. These authors point out that such a well-characterized reaction, even though it was not the original target of the MAb generated, can be a useful reagent when used in the proper setting. They suggest that this is “nonspecific” but “selective.” To me, the semantic arguments about what “specific” and “nonspecific” mean are less interesting. I would argue that such reactions are highly “specific” as well as “selective” but, more importantly, that they are “useful.” This novel article highlights an important issue, however. Immunocytochemical methods are incredibly selective and sensitive. They enable us to detect avid reactions using the spectacularly “specific” properties of antibody molecules. The more these methods are used, the more we all must appreciate the power of these selective reactions and the resulting obligation to exercise care in their control and interpretation. I have personally had the experience of generating MAbs to complex mixtures of antigens, i.e., whole cells. This is a humbling experience because of the incredible diversity of high-avidity antibodies one can find. In the thousands of clones we isolated, I do not remember actually finding duplicates; that is, every new clone that showed reaction with something in a cell was unique. Sometimes these clones reacted with different parts of the same molecular species, such as complex elaborate carbohydrates, but each clone generated an antibody that recognized a different portion of such a molecule, i.e., a different epitope. Fixation Preservation of structure for immunocytochemistry using chemical fixatives is well-recognized to create problems. The major challenge with fixation has often been the subsequent lack of reaction of antigens with antibodies. In spite of a widespread interpretative dogma in the literature, most of these problems were not due to chemical alteration of antigen epitopes. They were more commonly a problem of inaccessibility (Willingham and Yamada 1979). This concept has finally gained some acceptance because of the success of antigen retrieval techniques demonstrating that the reactive epitopes were always there in the cells, but they were just inaccessible (Shi et al. 1995). Such a result is reported in the article by Josephsen et al. in their observation that high (2.5%) concentrations of glutaraldehyde resulted in no reaction in their cells, presumably because of inaccessibility of the epitope. In contrast, the generation of novel epitopes due to fixation is less common but is not without precedent. Unexpected crossreactions to other antigens are even more common.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mark C. Willingham (1999) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: