Why the study?
Does the electric axis on conventional electrocardiograms correlate with the anatomic orientation of the heart determined by biplane angiocardiography in patients?
Does the electric axis on conventional electrocardiograms correlate with the anatomic orientation of the heart determined by biplane angiocardiography in patients?
The concept of 'electrical positions' of the heart does not correlate with true anatomic orientation and should be replaced by direct 3D description of the mean electromotive force.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Questions reliance on electrical positions for anatomic inference on ECG; leaves open validation of direct 3D electromotive force descriptions.
Anatomic orientation of the heart was determined in 53 patients by selective, biplane angiocardiography, and was compared with the mean electric axis and the location of the transition zone from conventional electrocardiograms. No significant correlation could be demonstrated between (a) the anatomic axis and the electric axis in the frontal plane, or (b) between the electric axis and rotation of the heart about its longitudinal axis, or (c) the location of the interventricular septum and the transition zone of the precordial leads. The electric variations are greater than can possibly be explained by known rotations of the heart about any anatomic axis. The degrees of rotation about the heart's longitudinal axis assumed in the concept of "electrical positions" is beyond the range found in normal or hypertrophied hearts. It is concluded that the electric positions of the heart should be abandoned in favor of direct description in three dimensions of the orientation of the mean electromotive force of the heart. Normal limits should be defined in percentiles or standard deviations.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Guntheroth et al. (1961) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: