Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
BOOK Review 115 710. Thomas Merton: Prophecy and Renewal – Acts of the International Symposium, Rome, June 12-15, 2018 edited by Bernard Sawicki, O.S.B., Studia Anselmiana 182 (Rome: Pontificio Ateneo S. Anselmo, 2020. Pp. 422. Cloth. €39.95. ISBN 978-3-83068001 -7). In commemoration of the fiftieth anniversary of the death of Thomas Merton, Sant'Anselmo, the Benedictine academy in Rome, sponsored over the course of four days in June 2018 a major conference on Merton's life, work and influence. The proceedings of this symposium have now been published as a handsomely produced volume in the venerable Studia Anselmiana series. Twenty-six presentations by speakers from eleven countries are included; most are in English, with four in Italian and one in German. All but one of the essays include abstracts in English, though the single exception (both the abstract and the text in Italian) provides an abstract in another language. Following a series of five brief welcoming greetings (including one from Vatican Secretary of State Cardinal Pietro Parolin, on behalf of Pope Francis) the proceedings are arranged according to the dual theme of the conference. Bookended by plenary addresses by two distinguished scholars, Merton Center Director Paul M. Pearson's "Thomas Merton – Poet, Monk, Prophet" and Australian Cistercian author Michael Casey's "Thomas Merton and Monastic Renewal," the presentations are arranged in two major groups, each with three subsections: "Merton and Prophecy – Tradition" (3 lectures), "Vision" (4 lectures) and "Performance" (8 lectures); and "Merton and Renewal – Church" (4 lectures), "Monasticism" (2 lectures) and "Society" (3 lectures). This provides a helpful organizational focus, though of course one that is not to be applied too rigidly, as many of the articles could fit into more than one category. The essays vary considerably in length, the majority of them evidently close to the version presented at the conference, but a few of them expanded considerably (not always to the advantage of the final product). This volume exemplifies both the advantages and disadvantages of a proceedings collection. On the one hand, its comprehensiveness allows the reader an experience of vicarious participation in the conference, an opportunity to encounter on the page the whole range of themes and approaches provided by the presenters. Among the topics discussed are Merton's art, his immersion in the natural world, his influence on Protestants, the controversial details surrounding his 116 ABR 72:1 – MARCH 2021 death, his attitude toward hesychastic spirituality, his role as exemplar of "the new mysticism," his identity as "man of the Church," his role in monastic and ecclesial renewal, and the question of his "celebrity" status. Merton's connections, direct and indirect, literary or personal, with a wide variety of figures, including Joan Baez, John Cassian, Jean Leclercq, Thich Nhat Hanh, Boris Pasternak, Edith Stein (St. Teresa Benedicta of the Cross) and "urban shaman" Gabrielle Roth, are explored. Both veteran and newly emerging Mertonians are included among the participants. In addition to the two plenary speakers, such well-known and widely published Merton scholars as Peter Ellis, Fiona Gardner, Jonathan Montaldo and Cristóbal SerranPag án are represented, along with a pair of Benedictine authors of well-received recent studies, Ephrem Arcement and Jaechan Anselmo Park, as well as other monastic commentators who are able to consider from an "insider's" perspective Merton's own commitment to a life governed by the Benedictine Rule. (Perhaps surprisingly, only Casey is a Cistercian, though the predominant involvement of the "Black Benedictines" of course reflects the institutional affiliation of Sant'Anselmo.) There is a welcome opportunity to sample Merton's influence beyond the Anglophone world, in Brazil, Germany, Holland and of course Italy, represented particularly by Maurizio Renzini and Mario Zaninelli, both key figures in the Associazione Thomas Merton, the Italian affiliate of the International Thomas Merton Society. Clearly there is much to admire, appreciate and ponder in this extensive collection. On the other hand, the very comprehensiveness of such a volume almost inevitably guarantees a considerable disparity in the quality and value of the included essays. Once the initial conference proposals had been accepted, apparently there was little or no attempt at "quality control"—whatever text was submitted for inclusion in the...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Patrick F. O’Connell (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: