Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
108 ABR 71:1 – MARCH 2020 BOOK REVIEWS 685. On Thomas Merton by Mary Gordon (Boulder, CO: Shambhala, 2018. Pp. 147. Cloth, $22.95. ISBN 978-1-61180-337-2). The genesis of novelist Mary Gordon's widely reviewed new book was somewhat accidental. She was invited to give a presentation at the 2015 Merton centennial celebration held at Columbia University, his alma mater, "probably because I was the only literary person on the Columbia campus known to be a practicing Catholic" (3). Though she had read little of Merton, particularly in recent years, she accepted, and her lecture led in turn to a book proposal that she likewise accepted, without quite knowing why, except that she believed she could provide a perspective largely missing in commentary on Merton—a writer's appraisal of a fellow writer. The result is both fascinating and somewhat frustrating. On Thomas Merton is a slim book and in some ways a narrow one as well. Its four chapters focus successively on Merton's early correspondence with Evelyn Waugh and later contacts with Czeslaw Milosz as indicative of his strong and weak points as a writer; on the "phenomenon" (41) of his best-selling autobiography The Seven Storey Mountain; on his pre-monastic, posthumously published novel My Argument with the Gestapo (1969); and on the seven volumes of Merton's journals, which she read now for the first time and clearly found a revelation, "not like reading a book but having another life" (87). She is broadly dismissive of much of the rest of Merton's massive oeuvre, but there is little evidence of sustained engagement with works not discussed here. This is not a book to look to for a comprehensive, balanced overview of the totality of Merton's writing. What it does provide are the perceptive, somewhat idiosyncratic observations of a professional author who is also an astute and sensitive reader. In her opening chapter, "Writer to Writer: But What Kind?" she explores the contacts between Merton and fellow writers Waugh and Milosz, both literary craftsmen of exceptional distinction marked by discipline and concern for style, compared to whom Merton's considerably more casual approach to composition might seem somewhat slack. Gordon attributes a good deal of this to the "pressure" (30) on Merton from his monastic superiors to keep producing and publishing at a rapid pace, partly for the practical generation of needed funds and partly for the spiritual influence he could wield. BOOK REVIEW 109 The second chapter, on the autobiography, shows Gordon to be very receptive to and appreciative of Merton's exceptionally vivid concrete descriptions, of which she quotes numerous examples, and very allergic to the frequent passages of what she considers pious rhetoric. She is apparently uninterested, or at least uninterested in discussing, the actual process of Merton's conversion and entrance into monastic life—virtually none of the key events that drew him to Catholicism and to Gethsemani are even mentioned. Her focus is on how the autobiography "presents us with the best and worst of Thomas Merton as a writer," passages marked by a "pious, closed, almost inhuman voice" contrasting with those displaying "his love of language" and "his power of close observation," which she considers to be "his greatest gift" (42-43). The most unusual chapter is the third, on My Argument with the Gestapo, which she actually appears to prefer to The Seven Storey Mountain. Again it is "Merton's strengths as a master of description and sensual apprehension" (65), his "ability to evoke a place, a moment, an atmosphere with a few swift strokes" which she considers his "greatest gift as a writer" (68), that attract Gordon's attention. The chapter concludes with a discussion of passages where the narrator reflects on the nature and purpose of writing, above all the climactic evocation of William Blake, "filling paper with words, so that the words flew about the room for the angels to read, and after that, what if the paper was lost or destroyed? That is the only reason for wanting to write, Blake's reason" (84). This, comments Gordon, is "the ideal of all real writers" (84), one that in her judgment...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Patrick F. O’Connell (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: