Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Much of the ongoing health care debate has been conducted by the second and third parties in our three-party reimbursement system: the providers and the payers. In this issue of the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, Danis and colleagues broaden the debate by asking consumers what they want.1 This report is timely as Congress once again takes up the issue of the anticipated fiscal crisis facing the Medicare program. There is a paucity of empirical data on the role of consumer choice in controlling healthcare costs. Proposals to increase out-of-pocket payments or to reduce benefits have not been popular but also have not been well tested. The authors addressed this by presenting patients with a hypothetical menu of benefits similar to those that are already included in either the Medicare benefit package or standard co-insurance packages. The benefits were assigned costs based on estimates from current Medicare and co-insurance payments. One hundred eighteen Medicare enrollees attending a general internal medicine outpatient clinic were interviewed regarding choice of benefits. They were also given a dollar limit of $3500, approximating the annual current expenditure per Medicare enrollee. Benefit choices included 12 covered services such as hospital care, dental care, prescription medications, and long-term care. Examination of the ranking and frequency of the choices made, reveals significant variation between individuals in the packages chosen. Of note, there was no single benefit service, not even hospitalization, that was chosen by all participants. This finding is particularly striking as many Medicare enrollees are moving into managed care programs where flexibility in choice of benefits is certainly less than ever. Nevertheless, the vast majority of individuals (about 90%) included hospitalization as well as outpatient care and prescription drugs in their hypothetical benefit package. See also p 688 The finding of the high ranking of a prescription benefit plan is no surprise. Many Medigap policies have included a prescription benefit for quite some time and it has been a popular benefit for those who can afford it. In fact, the wide availability of Medigap coverage for prescription medications was a factor that was not taken into account in the passage of the Medicare Catastrophic Act of 1989. This act resulted in higher Medicare premiums and extended prescription coverage to those without it. This proved extremely unpopular to those who were already covered for prescriptions because they would be paying higher premiums for Medicare to cover those without gap coverage, with no additional benefits to them. This perception in part, caused the rapid repeal of this measure. Managed care programs have recognized this and usually include a prescription benefit for Medicare enrollees, without a specific charge or higher premium. Another important finding in this report was the low ranking of long-term care, hospice care, and mental health care. Only 9% of study participants ranked long term-care at all. Though such choices may not appear to be actuarially sound, they are really not unreasonable when the costs and rationale offered are examined. For most participants, the cost for each choice was weighed relative to the expected need; thus, most were attempting to obtain maximum dollar value from their selections. This is not an unreasonable basis for insurance decisions. Looking at the relative costs given for the hospital benefit ($2300), outpatient care ($150), and a prescription plan ($400) compared with the cost for long-term care insurance ($1900), long-term care insurance may appear to be, and often is, an unaffordable luxury. In fact, in order to stay below the total limit of $3500 in the study, hospitalization and long-term care were mutually exclusive. In addition, the expectation for needing long-term care was assessed and reported as low. This may seem surprising because the lifetime risk of ever being in a nursing home is as high as 40%.2 However, the risk of a long, permanent stay is much lower, such that 13% of older people account for 90% of the expenditures.3 It may be that older healthcare consumers recognize, perhaps from their own experience, that the risk of a permanent, extended stay is really not that high. Long-term care also had particularly negative connotations for many of the study participants, ranging from hoping not to need it to vehemently opposing it. Though this may reflect strong feelings against the possibility of becoming disabled, it may also reflect that organization and quality of such care is not what people want. Need for hospice care was also perceived as being low. The majority of older adults (80%) die in hospitals. Many may also get hospice type service via home care nursing or during a terminal stay in a nursing home. Clearly terminal care has multiple sources of coverage. Perhaps these Medicare beneficiaries were aware that they can already get hospice care for the price paid for acute care and home care. In fact, much of home care that is provided appears to meet primarily long-term care needs.4 Thus, such choices illustrate the redundancies in the current system of care. The Medicare program has been a driving force in maintaining a system of health care centered around care. With guaranteed payment for all persons older than age 65, acute care hospitalization became the focus for all important care, including consultation and diagnostic evaluation, as well as for acute medical illness and surgery. Until this opportunity for reimbursement was limited, there was relatively little use of alternative care settings to provide these services. Reductions in hospitalization in the 1980s, with prospective payment, shifted some care out of the hospital to home care and nursing home settings already insured by the Medicare program. These programs are still not subject to prospective payment and have been growing dramatically. Hospital care, however, continues to be viewed as the center of care, particularly high tech care, and is designed for acute care needs rather than for the chronic care needs of many older people. The structure of the benefits offered in this study maintains this paradigm. Are the costs given to the study participants reasonable? Though prices were based on current expenditures, it is important to keep in mind that Medicare has never covered any type of health care in full. Thus, attempts to price Medicare, co-insurance, and managed care have been confounded by the shifting payment streams that adjust themselves to respond to healthcare legislation so that the prices for Medicare also reflect the coverage available from private carriers as well Medicaid in other age groups. While the average Medicare outlay used for this study may have approximated $3500 per beneficiary, it does not reflect the funding from private sources. For example, the long-term care insurance market is mostly private and, thus, is probably priced too high in proportion to the average expenditure for Medicare overall. The average premium used in this study for long-term care was $1900. In fact, the actual cost per person may not be that high ($12,000 per lifetime or $500–$750 per year).3 Thus, the costs used in this study are biased against long-term care. It is not clear whether the menu of benefits offered in the study would be administered within the Medicare program as it currently exists. If it were, there would be opportunity for use of multiple policies. About 90% of Medicare beneficiaries also have some other form of coverage.5 It would seem likely that if covered benefits within Medicare were decreased, either by choice or by necessity, that private policies would spring up. Such policies would likely be priced so as to be accessible only to those with other resources, which would be disadvantageous to lower income adults. How likely is it that choice of benefits would control costs? In this study, 90% of the participants chose hospitalization as a benefit. The definition and purpose of these benefits was only generally described to the study participants. Though ICU care was pulled out as a separate benefit from hospitalization, hospital care is still extremely variable, and the cost of such care has a significant impact on total healthcare expenditure because the number of potential recipients of such care, and the indications for intervention, continue to increase. For example, in a recent editorial regarding implantable defibrillators for non-sustained ventricular tachycardia, the authors estimated that the potential for extrapolation of this technology could increase costs exponentially.6 They estimated that of the 1.3 million patients who annually survive a myocardial infarction, 16,000 patients might meet criteria for implantable defibrillators at a cost of over $1 billion dollars. Common conditions such as coronary artery disease account for a large proportion of hospital days and expensive technologies that are increasingly applied for very common problems. Control of the application of expensive procedures for very common problems in an increasing number of older people would seem likely to have a greater impact on cost than would decreasing the use of hospitalization per se. We have already seen that when adjusting for disease severity, age itself is rarely a contraindication to any procedure. The increasing number of older people alone is a major factor in increasing health care costs.7 Rationing services by limiting a category as broad as hospitalization is unlikely to have an impact on costs unless decisions are also made about the extent to which expensive procedures are applied to older adults. In asking for reasons for foregoing benefit choices, the authors may have been able to get at general values for care. However, the descriptions were less extensive than in a real insurance policy. For example, ICU care was defined as life support and appears to have been misconstrued by many participants as futile care at the end of life. Expensive, high technology treatments that result in return to prior function would probably be more accepted because much ICU care is post-surgical and life-supporting and thus may be quite appropriate. Though understanding the underlying values and expected outcomes of care was not the primary goal of this analysis, the choices offered were also not made in the context of specific outcomes. Allowing individuals choice of coverage needs to be tested in more detail than could be done here and must be based on sound data regarding outcome in terms of function and independence. These choices are quite complex, and information needed to make these decisions is lacking. Asking older individuals to make them in advance is even more challenging, especially as most studies show that while age itself is a poor predictor of outcome, it is still often the best that we can do. More information must be given about the range of services included, and the potential outcomes as well as the cost. More research is needed on the outcomes of specific choices made, not only in terms of survival but in terms of quality of life. The debate must shift from whether we can or can't to whether we should. This will require broadening the debate further to include a discussion of what are appropriate goals of health care for older adults.8 If choices are to be made they must be more explicit and goal-directed to have major impact on cost and quality of life. Managed care is already addressing some of the preferences seen in this study, but with little choice in individual benefit selection. The methods used here appear to become focused on the situation and are less abstract than the general voicing of values. The design also takes the discussion somewhat out of the context of the specific payment program. However, the authors still use the construct of services set up by the fee-for-service industry and adopted by the Medicare program. The gaps and overlaps between home and institutional care and various types of coverage, especially Medicare and Medicaid, are not explicitly evaluated in this paper. The movement of Medicare recipients to managed care is as close as Medicare has come to true healthcare reform. Removing these funding stream barriers may allow for more creative choices that may increase the opportunity to reduce costs and may reduce the redundancies as well as the gaps in the system. Nevertheless, we must be more creative than simply keeping or discarding certain benefits of the type that have been perpetuated by the Medicare reimbursement structure. If choices are to be made, the right choices need to be offered.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Anne B. Newman (1997) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: