Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The crit is the most common feedback and assessment method used in architecture and many other art and design programmes. Whilst considerable research has been conducted on the crit, little attention has been paid to students’ perceptions of the process or to understanding how and what they learn from it. This is truly a missed opportunity, given that it has been identified as the greatest source of student dissatisfaction. The aim of this research project was to understand students’ opinions of the primary method used to assess them and to identify ways in which the process could be adapted to maximise their learning. Focus groups were held with students from each level of the undergraduate architecture course at Liverpool John Moores University.Despite recognising some positive qualities of the crit, focus group participants associated many more negative issues with it. These issues are discussed in detail, with reference to contemporary pedagogic theory and best practice in assessment and feedback, to the extent that the crit’s fitness for purpose is questioned. Alternative formats to the traditional crit are then evaluated within the framework of existing research and in conclusion, a radical re-evaluation of the traditional crit is proposed with the recommendation that alternative methods are adopted alongside (if not in place of) it.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Charlie Smith (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: