Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Are you looking for an exciting book in Geology? Every textbook tells that nothing in Earth history has been more puzzling than that great wave of extinctions that swept the Earth round about 250 million years ago, ending the Paleozoic Era; yet there has been no adequate treatment that gathers the growing information in a modern chronology, and examines it in a modern frame of questions. Erwin is at home with the fossils and the stratigraphy, explores the geophysical and geochemical aspects, and develops the history of ideas. Beginning with Cuvier and with the almost clairvoyant views of John Phillips (1840, 1860) on life history, he brings us up to the modern controversies concerning the nature and cause of biotic crises in general and that of the Permian extinctions in particular. He sketches for us the stratigraphy and fossil distributions of the more important marine sequences in which the boundary is defined, and compares the record of terrestrial life as well. Biogeography and concerns with climate are discussed in the platetectonic frame, and much is made of the history of delta 13C and of cerium abundance. Evidence for bolide impact is lacking, but biotas were stressed by a variety of factors including marine regression, warming of climate, broad spread of deserts, basalt floods etc. The crisis was not so abrupt as the less intense one at the end of Cretaceous time; in the marine realm this leaves reasonable disagreements as to where the boundary should be drawn; on land the replacement of floras was broadly time-transgressive. Erwin concludes that the crisis was due not to any one factor but to the juxtaposition of various and presumably unrelated causes of biotic stress. While reestablishment of biotic diversity occurred over some tens of millions of years, the crisis had lasting effects on life by eliminating some of the many Bauplan types that had existed, directing evolution into fewer main channels. Illustrations are clear and well-chosen, but technical proofreading was poor: fusulinids, Ladinian etc. are mangled upon occasion, the Sakmarian appears twice in Fig 5.5. But the prose flows beautifully and clearly. Erwin has read and understood a wide range of subject matter and has thought about it, and I for one am very grateful to him tor having shared this with us in such an attractive manner, a very fitting addition to Columbia University Press' Critical Moments in Paleobiology and Earth History Series.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fischer et al. (1993) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: