Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Communication is something I am quite passionate about. A problem I saw overwhelmingly in many organizations, educational and professional, was the lack of effective and efficient communication. I noticed that communication between team members and departments was substantially lacking. Projects have been delayed or halted due to lack of effective and precise communication. Individuals were reactionary to requests asked of them and there was no substantial “buy-in” to an outlined goal or project. The purpose of my action research was to create better communication through team building, team development and formation utilizing technology. I began by asking what would happen if teams and organizations began to have clearer and more focused communication through the use of technological advancements, would their end goals and results be better achieved?Research into current literature showed effective, precise, and open communication was shown to be essential in getting goals accomplished and cooperative team formation in virtual environments. The utilization of the available technology in 2012 was crucial in keeping up to date with the moral compass of organizations, particularly in the terms of ethical and professional development of staff (Coleman & Wilkins, 2009). As Marsick and Meyer (2003) stated, the world has become smaller due to globalization and advancements in technology and communications, trainers and executives needed to be proactive and effectively communicate professional standards in line with organizational values, ethics, and goals while effectively training individuals. The development and diversity of organizational work, created a need to train staff in a professional manner for greater knowledge and understanding (Marsick & Meyer, 2003).As trainers and educators were more exposed to digital technology to effectively facilitate communication within a group, enhanced production, understanding, and collaboration took place. The use of technology in development and communication enhanced creativity, brainstorming, and collaboration regardless of time, space, or location. The use of technology, such as computers, Smart Boards, iPads, video screens, collaboration applications, interactive multimedia applications, and hardware, assisted in explaining and training in the code of ethics and morality, and spoke to the mission and vision of a company (Marsick & Meyer, 2003). Ethical behaviors, attitudes, and communication on ethical commitments enhanced corporate performance as participants embraced the corporate ethical identity that was established and incorporated into their training and professional development (Kleyn, Abratt, Chipp, & Goldman, 2012; Marsick & Meyer, 2003).Nichols, Nichols, and Nichols (2007) questioned whether ethics could be learned and further discovered that as students attended school, and as their instructors took responsibility to provide a dedication to achieve a set of high ethical standards, students became more cognizant of what was expected of them (Marsick & Meyers, 2003).Marsick and Meyer (2003) outlined examples in the development and training of organizations and individuals, which included learner centered training, reflective practice and joint learning, which were experiential learning in content. McArdle and Ackland (2007) added that these were influential in cross-cultural training to help individuals comprehend how diverse cultures were based on gestures, body language, personal space, and customs, which provided better understanding and collaboration. In addition, the use of this training helped forestall unintended offense and joined the lines between adult learning and organizational change (Marsick & Meyer, 2003). The use of one or more training mechanisms was recommended to help achieve this learning process and give success to those in cross-cultural organizations (McArdle & Ackland, 2007).The professional development and training of professionals in an ever mobile and volatile world of business and education, technology was a crucial tool to help explain and exemplify expectations of the organization, team, or individual. (Davis, Preston, & Sahin, 2009). Based on an individual's cultural and religious background and their knowledge base, corporations then defined, created, and implemented training programs with an emphasis on the code of ethics for the corporation, and meeting the vision and goals of the organization (Burroughs, Dahl, Moreau, Chattopadhyay, & Gorn, 2011).Effective, precise, and open communication was shown to be essential in getting goals accomplished and cooperative team formation (Armstrong, 2009; Robbins, 2012). To enhance interpersonal communication, the learning style of interpersonal communication was utilized to provide better collaboration and interactivity (Armstrong, 2009). According to Robbins (2012), effective communication has taken place when people realize they are all different in the way the world is perceived. In the utilization of this understanding, this guides enhanced communication with others (Robbins, 2012). People with interpersonal learning styles learned best when they were permitted to use their soft skills, the ability to socialize and interact with others, as part of their learning process (Jackson, 2009). Interpersonal learning styles enhanced stimulation by dialogue, with the use of intuition, in regards to another participant's opinions, feelings, and preferences that created a synergy of ideas and processes (Logsdon, 2012). Burns (2009) noted that interpersonal learners were adept at resolving issues and had the ability to read people from their personal stance, in as such the learning theory of humanism facilitated the building of communication within organizations and groups (Schultz & Schultz, 2005).Gardner (as cited by Logsdon, 2012) developed a theory of multiple intelligences, which includes interpersonal intelligence as one of the eight intelligences discussed. According to Armstrong (2009) interpersonal intelligence people are primarily social, able to observe and note the differences in the moods, motivations, intentions, and feelings of others within their group, which leads them to be effective communicators. People who hold this as a prominent intelligence also have leadership tendencies and are often adept at motivating others and keeping projects on task and organized and commonly are referred to as “people people” (Armstrong, 2009). Similarly, Tonarely (2012) stated traits often seen with these individuals are viewed as skilled in understanding and interacting with people and able to effect change. Individuals displaying these traits create positive relationships and are reasonable in resolving conflicts within a dynamic (Tonarely, 2012). Personality traits have an impact on learning as well.Humanism is a personality theory developed by Maslow that embraces and focuses on human interests and values (Schultz & Schultz, 2005). This learning process is a more holistic approach that uses foundational learning skills and attitudes to achieve success in all areas of study, and the students find their confidence and abilities increased (Villares, 2011).Organized in the areas of goal setting, sharing success, and progress monitoring, as well as creation of a nonthreatening, caring environment with support and encouragement, while managing anxiety under pressure; memory and a healthy optimism help these students progress through the stages of development such as physiological, safety, and belongingness outlined in Maslow's theories (Villares, 2011). Working through these stages of physiological, safety, and belongingness, students start to emerge into the higher stages of esteem and self-actualization (Schultz & Schultz, 2005). The use of humanistic learning theory embraces the need of students to achieve their potential; and in turn it creates and enhances the desire to learn and achieve more (Jackson, 2009). In team development and communication building, the humanistic approach has been shown to be appropriate in creating and developing team development, formation, and communication (Jackson, 2009; Schultz & Shultz, 2005).With the use of social media, individuals facilitate different environments and it helps to give voice to those participants who may not have engaged otherwise, providing a more collaborative effort and better communication (Burroughs et al., 2011; Marsick & Meyer, 2003). Social media also provides a sounding board for discussion for learners to build better camaraderie and collaboration in projects and goals (Meyer & Marsick, 2003). As Kelm (2011) noted, many organizations have a presence on social media outlets in which they are actively engaged with their followers to elicit communication, thoughts, and ideas on how the organization has performed and it has enhanced policies or created new products (Dyrud, 2011; Kelm, 2011).Built on the individual and collective progress, the blending of social media and business communication for greater understanding in the development process creates more effective communication and teamwork (Kelm, 2011). Burroughs et al. (2011) noted that, in a creative role, brainstorming within a team can produce innovative ideas; however, with the incorporation of social media outlets, the availability and collaborative environment multiplies and performs in a way that would not be possible in face-to-face interaction. The facilitation of social media creates an environment open and accessible to all team members regardless of time, space, or location (Burroughs et al., 2011).Professional development and business communication is enhanced through the use of technology. As trainers and educators are more exposed to digital technology in which there are effective ways to facilitate communication within a group, enhance production, understand, and collaborate. Helping in this track is the use of interpersonal skills and learning styles, which enhance the group or organizations communication and facilitation of needs. In addition, social media, used in communication, helps individuals and groups stay adhered to the mission, goals, values, and ethics of an organization. The use of technology in professional development and business communication enhances creativity, brainstorming, and collaboration regardless of time, space, or location. In developing my action research, I utilized the aforementioned theories and ideas with the use of digital collaboration.My target audience was an eighth-grade advisory class in Nampa, Idaho. I reside in Fort Myers, Florida. There were 21 students in the class. There were ten males and eleven females. Sixteen students were somewhat active participants in the action research project, which broke down evenly to eight males and eight females.Upon the planning of my action research project, it became apparent the target audience I originally intended to use in Fort Myers was not large enough for this project. Upon discussion with a classmate, Jennifer Tuttle, and guidance from our instructor, Roxanne DeLeon, we embarked on a truly digital collaboration with me utilizing Jennifer Tuttle's 8th grade advisory class in Nampa, ID. Jennifer Tuttle became an assistant in helping to set up technology in Nampa, ID and arranged times for me to teach her class.Implementation began by developing a group on Google Hangouts under the name “Digital Collaborators,” in which I was able to communicate online in real-time with the students utilizing the internet, smart boards, and webcams. An Edmodo account was created under “Digital Collaborators” in order to give the pre- and postassessments. Invitations were sent to each student's e-mail account to have them join me in Cacoo, Asana, Edmodo, and Google Hangouts.I then began assigning tasks, assignments, and quizzes through Edmodo. Groups were created in Edmodo with a leader who had been randomly assigned by Jennifer Tuttle. The assignments initially given for Cycle One were an Audio/Video Release Form, to read the rubric, join Edmodo, and join Digital Collaborators on Cacoo and Google Hangouts. The students were then asked to take their Cacoo pretest (created in Edmodo) and presurvey (created in Google Docs). They were to also watch a video tutorial of Cacoo after taking their pretest and presurvey.Upon completion of those tasks, we then met in a Google Hangout and began to discuss expectations and collaborate together as facilitator and students within their groups.Evaluation and assessment tools included field notes, video, pre- and post-test in Cacoo, presurvey, and reflection/progress notes from the students.On the pretest, an average score of 89% was submitted with all 21 participants.In the presurvey, most students indicated they were proficient in MS Word, MS Excel, Edmodo, Google Hangouts and MS PowerPoint. However 70% felt they were proficient in Cacoo and 0% in Asana.Based on the data collected in the presurvey, participants felt that working in groups was beneficial to team development because they were able to help one another and generate new ideas. Most liked working in groups although they preferred to work alone under self-guided direction. Some of the comments made during an interview were:On the posttest, 16 participants submitted a quiz on Edmodo, which garnered an average of 86%. The test results proved that while not all participants engaged in the posttest, those who did retained the knowledge they had in working within the application and in groups.During implementation participants were scattered and a delay in the initial setup for collaboration delayed the implementation of Cycle 1. Students were suspended from school and could not participate. A pleasant surprise with the students who did participate was their familiarity in using Cacoo and Google Hangouts. Their enthusiasm and surprise on how the software helped them was a blessing.Having most of the technology issues resolved, we moved forward with Cycle Two. Students took their pretest and reviewed the tutorial on Asana. As spring break falls differently in Idaho than in Florida, we adjusted the time schedule to allow time to collect data and finish Cycle Two.This cycle was relevant as it began the process for digital collaboration in a distance environment. Many obstacles encountered were addressed and made it easier to transition through the second cycle.Cycle Two began with a teacher-led video discussion through Google Hangouts on our next steps in our project. I explained how we were going to continue with the teams we developed in Cycle One. The students had to watch the Asana Tutorial and take the prequiz on Asana. Students broke into their four teams and began to use Asana to create tasks and goals. The students were not as willing to participate and utilize Asana as they were in Cycle One with Cacoo. I then posted on Edmodo for the students to reflect what they were experiencing with Asana. When students posed a question, there was a video answer posted to Edmodo to help them along.The groups met and brainstormed what tasks each student would take on to create the web pages as their final project. Tasks assigned to students included what they would need to do in order to create the digital citizen website in Google Sites. These included writing the copy, naming their website, and finding images.They then began to work on the web pages and checking off completed tasks in Asana. Students were then given a posttest and postsurvey to see if their mindsets had changed or remained the same on working collaboratively in a digital environment since the implementation of Cycle One. Students were also given an informal survey to check for levels of participation and overall opinion of the project.The main collection method for Cycle Two's data was through tests, surveys, and reflection posts with the students through Edmodo.A comparison of the pre- and postsurvey encompassing Cacoo and Asana showed there was a 3% increase in the number of students who preferred face-to-face interaction in having collaboration. Upon further comparison, there was an 8% decrease in students who said they would prefer a written agenda. Furthermore, there was a 9% increase that a student would prefer to work alone on projects. There also was a 27% decrease in students who felt that working in Asana helped them work more efficiently. Upon further investigation, students reflected they found Asana difficult to work in and hard to keep others on task.The data gathered during this cycle has indicated that, while directly teaching lessons about digital communication and collaboration can help foster team building and effective communication, more time and teacher-student interaction needs to take place in order to facilitate a team environment.The pre- and posttests showed where learning had been achieved through the use of Asana. Many students felt that the program confused them, which led me to reevaluate whether the program was too advanced for this group. Evaluation is needed in any future use of the program to help facilitate learning.Distance learning in this age group proved to be trying. Understanding the student body and having the time to answer the questions needed is crucial in an immediate response situation.We ran into several unexpected technical errors during Cycle Two. Asana was not allowing the students into the program. Not knowing if it was an Asana issue or a local network issue, I had to rely on communication with Jennifer Tuttle, the teacher onsite in Nampa, ID. I re-sent the link to the students and they finally were able to sign back in.Additional surprises were the unexpected delays caused by the school district in closing the school, adding out-of-classroom activities, and the numerous suspensions and absences from the student body.The overall reaction of the students was interesting. For Cycle Two I had them complete a survey about how meaningful they felt their overall experience was from Cycle One to Cycle Two and 56% agreed or strongly agreed it was a meaningful experience while 17% felt neutral and only 12% disagreed or strongly disagreed that it was meaningful. I did not find the students as actively engaged in Cycle Two as they were in Cycle One, so this greatly surprised me.However, when the students were asked how well they thought they participated in their teams 0% felt they did not participate, 17% were neutral about their participation, 44% said they participated and 39% felt they strongly participated. Through surveys and reflections it was determined the students did learn about being a digital collaborator.The data gathered during these cycles indicated that while directly teaching lessons about digital communication and collaboration can help foster team building and effective communication, more time is needed and more and teacher-student interaction needs to take place in order to facilitate a team environment. Evaluation is needed in any future use of the program to help facilitate learning. Distance learning in this age group proved to be trying. Understanding the student body and having the time to answer the questions needed is crucial in an immediate response situation.As Marsick and Meyer (2003) suggested, the use of technology, such as computers, smart Boards, iPads, video screens, collaboration applications, interactive multimedia applications, and hardware, assisted in explaining and training. Armstrong (2009) and Robbins (2012) noted that effective, precise and open communication is essential in getting goals accomplished and cooperative team formation. I believe through my cycles, this was shown to be true. By utilizing Edmodo, Cacoo, Asana and Google Hangouts, as well as e-mail and video responses, students felt their collaboration and communication improved and increased in a way to meet their goals.In the future, I would like to take my findings and this project into a local school where I could have some physical and “face-to-face” interaction with the students or perhaps use this project to an older set of students, high school and beyond, in a truly online, distant environment. I found that students of this age needed more direction and guidance than I could give in an only online format without the use of telephone or instant messaging. The time difference was also an issue. The eighth-grade advisory class in Nampa, ID was a “nongraded” class so motivation was low. As a nonprotected academic time, any that could have was hard to with the multiple that I the action research project was a success and a board for creating online
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Angeli K. Chin (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 7 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: