Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Governments and non-government organizations worldwide have renewed their focus on mental health, recognizing the burden that mental ill-health places on patients, families, employers and economies. The annual costs of mental illness to economies have been estimated at £74–99 billion for the UK [1], more than €450 billion for the European Union [2] and around $2.5 trillion globally [3]. Additionally, sickness absence and early retirement due to mental ill-health have increased in Europe [2]. Consequently, workplace mental health promotion has become a strategic focus area. The renewed interest has prompted recent reviews of the evidence base in relation to common mental disorders and work [4] and of the promotion of mental health and well-being in the workplace [5]. Employers should promote safe and supportive working conditions and they should pay attention to work organization improvements; however, in practice, they may find this difficult. In part this is due to the way mental ill-health is still perceived as an individual problem and the stigma associated with it. However, it is also due to a pervasive lack of development of appropriate competencies in the key actors who face these issues in the workplace (e.g. leaders, managers, human resource professionals [6]) and lack of access to competent occupational health services, especially for those working in small and medium-sized enterprises. Mental ill-health can be the result of exposure to ‘unhealthy’ working conditions, poor work organization and psychosocial risks. However, mental ill-health might also not be caused by work but be made worse by work. Mental ill-health has many determinants and a multi-faceted action framework is needed to address it appropriately both within and outside the workplace. While an appropriate health and safety legal framework is important and sets minimum standards for employers to adhere to, other ‘softer’ actions are equally important and include mental health promotion guidance development and intervention implementation in the workplace. While in recent years more evidence is accumulating on organizational-level interventions, aiming to develop good working conditions and a healthy work environment, this is still mixed and difficult to evaluate. Such interventions aim at prevention but often suffer from design and implementation issues in light of rapidly changing work environments and organizational restructuring. On the other hand, employee-targeted stress interventions can be effective especially for those who have high control over their work and there is moderate evidence for promoting physical activity in the workforce [4]. Employers often resort to providing reactive support, e.g. employee assistance programmes or various training programmes. There have been few well-designed evaluation studies of mindfulness-based interventions and resilience training in occupational settings [4]. There is limited evidence that mental health first aid training improves participants’ knowledge, skills and attitudes but no evidence regarding clinical outcomes [7]. As a result, it is not possible to develop evidence-based guidelines for any of these training programmes. For employees who are off work sick, early assessment is important including enquiry about work-relatedness and identification of other barriers and facilitators to return to work. There are few high-quality studies of return-to-work interventions for employees who have mental health problems. Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), for example, can improve symptoms but it is only effective in helping employees return to work when it focuses on work relevant solutions and particularly when implemented as part of a multi-domain intervention including making any necessary workplace modifications such as modified duties or working hours [8]. For every individual to be provided with a working environment that is safe and does not harm their physical or mental health is an essential part of an employer’s as well as the state’s responsibility. However, even though health, safety and well-being are at the core of workplace and societal functioning and development, the current state of the art indicates that approaches that have been used to promote them have not had the anticipated results. This also applies to mental health in the workplace. A new paradigm is needed to capture the complexity of the modern workplace in relation to mental health. First, it is important to consider mega-drivers of change: technology, demography, climate change and globalization. For example, precarious work is on the rise bringing with it higher job insecurity. At the same time, the workforce is becoming older, more feminized and diverse. Promoting mental health means understanding the implications of these changes and adapting our approaches to be more inclusive. This necessitates moving away from silos and mono-disciplinary perspectives, strategically aligning and integrating approaches based on risk management (prevention and protection) with those based on mental health and well-being promotion, whether this concerns knowledge generation, policy or practice. Second, and following on from the above considerations, experts, researchers and practitioners are increasingly ‘specialized’ in certain areas. Such specialized approaches whereby contextual factors are often ignored, not only hinder the application of research findings in organizations, but also lead to duplication of approaches and antagonism between various areas. This issue can also be found in businesses with many specialized departments that are responsible for specific processes (such as occupational health, human resources, finance, marketing, etc.), which often leads to severe organizational inefficiencies and reduced capacities to respond fast and adequately to new circumstances. Third, it is important to consider various sources of data and the available evidence critically in their totality. In doing so, it is important to remember the realities of work environments and the restrictions they impose on evidence generation, especially when it comes to organizational-level interventions and multi-disciplinary and multi-level actions. Better co-ordination among various sectors (e.g. health, labour and social security) is needed to achieve optimal results. Depending on the specific national social security structures, an active involvement of the health policy sector is necessary to efficiently and effectively shape the interfaces that exist between early detection and primary prevention, secondary and tertiary prevention as well as treatment and rehabilitation, including occupational reintegration [2]. Fourth, competency development of key actors is crucial. Training and education on mental health and well-being are not only relevant for those on the shop floor, but also for the development of management competencies. The development of these competencies should be underpinned by the value case (highlighting ethical, social and economic benefits [9]) and not merely an economic or business case. Finally, there is a need for mental health and well-being to be integrated into the planning and control cycle of an enterprise as well as the policy cycle [10]. However, there are no generally accepted sets of leading performance indicators in this area, nor are there performance indicators for measuring the business and policy benefits of mainstreaming mental health and well-being. Such indicators would facilitate the communication between experts, practitioners, management and policy makers, and the integration of mental health and well-being management and promotion into the planning and control cycle of business operations. To promote mental health in the workplace holistically and achieve real progress, there needs to be synergy and integration among various perspectives. These perspectives need to be aligned considering current knowledge and existing needs, developing capabilities and mainstreaming a strategic approach in policy and practice. While there is evidence to support the effectiveness of return-to-work programmes, we still need more, better quality and longer-term studies to build a robust evidence base. We also need evaluation of more holistic programmes (combining various levels of prevention). Finally, a key challenge is lack of access to occupational health services for many organizations employing a significant part of the workforce.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Leka et al. (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: