Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The rise of a ‘new’ empirical bioethics, which aims to ground normative judgments in ‘real-world’ data relating to different ethical problems in the biomedical sciences, has been well-documented in recent years. – 7 Indeed, the journal Clinical Ethics was established as a valuable forum for the dissemination of research that embraced an empirical approach to the exploration of ethical problems in clinical practice. For postgraduates who see themselves as engaging in bioethics research, these developments present both a real opportunity to adopt a broad range of disciplinary perspectives in exploring their chosen topic, and a series of challenges in producing rigorous and respected work that might lead to an established academic career. The breadth of the field called ‘bioethics’ is well-suited to postgraduate research. At this level, researchers have a great degree of freedom to draw on different theoretical and methodological traditions in developing projects that address new problems in different ways. Indeed, one might say that this freedom to explore and experiment with different perspectives is what makes undertaking a PhD so special. However, this process of experimentation is also conducive to producing identity crises. When asked to describe the work that we do, we might respond by saying, for example, that it has a social scientific, a philosophical, a legal and a psychiatric component. When asked how these components integrate, or when called to account on the basis of the quality of our research by supervisors, reviewers or examiners, we have an uneasy sense that everything might unravel around us, our projects amounting to less than the sum of their parts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dunn et al. (2008) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: