Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
T HE INADEQUACY of statistics has long prevented the measurement and explanation of variations in criminal behavior as between the several national groups in the United States. The Department of Justice's constantly improving, if still inadequate, Uniform Crime Reports cannot, of course, give the national origin of the often unknown suspects, and most police authorities do not report the information needed for those arrested. For years the Bureau of the Census has given some attention to nativity and national origin in reporting commitments of felons to state and Federal penal institutions, but at least until recently these reports have been inadequate for our purpose. Apart from their incompleteness, commitment statistics are known to be very poor indices of criminal behavior. Crime may conceivably increase during a period of decreasing commitments and vice versa. This, as is well known, is because commitments are affected by changes in laws, in the efficiency of law enforcement and in the disposition of cases after conviction. It seems probable, however, that commitment rates are more valid as bases for comparisons between national groups than for comparisons between rates at different periods of time or between different geographical areas. This is because it is arguable that, except where national groups are highly concentrated in one area, or where prejudice against them exists, differences in local efficiency and policy would probably affect nationalities equally. The reader may judge as to the degree of concentration of these groups from data given below. The factor of prejudice might indeed be important, but the National Commission on Law Observance and Enforcement, alert for such prejudice, found that it did not affect seriously the administration of justice, except perhaps in the case of the Mexicans.' Yet if any reader feels such comparisons as are presented below are for these reasons invalid, the writer would not
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Donald R. Taft (1936) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: