Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Richard R. Beeman.The Varieties of Political Experience in Eighteenth-Century America. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2004. 376 pp. Notes and index. $39.95. Richard R. Beeman's The Varieties of Political Experience in Eighteenth-Century America is an ambitious effort to re-think the development of democratic political practices during the eighteenth century. Beeman orients his narrative around the trope of pluralism. Pluralism, for Beeman, works on two levels. First, he argues that one cannot tell a common story of colonial political practices during the eighteenth century. In fact, he writes, "diversity may be the only generalization that we can make about eighteenth-century American political culture" (pp. 1-2). Second, Beeman argues that ethnic, religious, economic, and political diversity was vital to moving American politics in a democratic direction, first in the western backcountry and the cities and then—during and after the American Revolution—throughout the new nation. The colonial period of American history has long suffered under the shadow of the American Revolution. What is American about the period of North American history before the United States was formed? What role should the United States's pre-national past play in its national history? For Americans during the nineteenth century, the colonial past was vital to national identity. They believed that colonists had crossed the Atlantic and planted the seeds of freedom that blossomed into democracy after the American Revolution. Similar themes were developed by Alexis de Tocqueville in Democracy in America (1835) and Louis Hartz in The Liberal Tradition in America (1955). Tocqueville and Hartz both argued that America was born free, that it was a liberal society from the first settlements. The spirited anti-establishmentarianism of the Puritans combined with easy access to land made America a more egalitarian and a more democratic society than its European parents. As Tocqueville put it, the colonies "seemed destined to encourage the growth of liberty." [End Page 478] Perhaps nothing contradicts the claim that colonial society was egalitarian more than black slavery and the settlers' cruelty to Native Americans. But these contradictions do not undermine Tocqueville's (who was sensitive to the condition of blacks and Indians) and Hartz's arguments. After all, Tocqueville and Hartz were concerned with the white settlers inside English polities. Starting in the 1960s and 1970s, however, social and cultural historians argued that even among white settlers colonial North America was not particularly egalitarian and certainly not democratic. These scholars emphasized the early modern condition of colonial America. Like England and Europe, colonial Americans lived in a traditional, organic, hierarchical society.1 Many scholars celebrated this past for its communitarian and non-capitalist character, using the differences between colonial America and today's Americaas a source of inspiration and critique. The world we have lost, we learned, was anything but liberal. In the 1970s, a new conception of colonial politics emerged that emphasized the centrality of "republican" or Whig ideas to colonial politics. Republicanism strengthened the link between early modern Europe and colonial America. For example, J. G. A. Pocock's The Machiavellian Moment (1975) follows the progression of republican ideas from fifteenth-century Florence to the American Revolution, and John M. Murrin, in his influential essay "The Great Inversion," argues that the American Revolution and its aftermath can best be understood within the context of English events and ideas.2 It was the Glorious Revolution that set the paradigm for the American Revolution, not any unique colonial egalitarianism. Colonial Americans took hold of a strand of European thought that entered English politics during the upheavals of the seventeenth century. Republicanism was both a political and an ethical system. At its root, republicans argued that all political authority is derived from the people, challenging the argument that their god had ordained the King as his vice-regent. But republicanism, housed in a classical idiom, also had a normative dimension. Republicans believed that the purpose of government...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Johann N. Neem (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: