Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Tip growth is a specialized type of growth utilized by only a few cell types in the plant kingdom. Nevertheless, these cell types perform vital functions for plants. Pollen tubes are necessary for seed plant reproduction, root hairs are vital for nutrient acquisition, and protonemata comprise the entire juvenile moss plant. Tip growth requires exquisite coordination of intracellular cargo delivery and simultaneous weakening of the apical cell wall. This process is precarious, with imbalances resulting in cell rupture or cessation of growth. In this Update, we provide context and highlight recent advances in our understanding of how ions, the cytoskeleton, and properties of the cell wall are interconnected during tip growth across three tip-growing systems: pollen tubes, root hairs, and protonemata. We propose that further mechanistic insights are likely to come from studying the commonalities among these systems, particularly focusing on the molecular basis of the communication between cell wall status and intracellular cargo delivery. Plant cells are surrounded by a cell wall that imposes both physical restrictions to shape as well as a balance to turgor pressure. However, most undifferentiated plant cells are small and uniform. During differentiation, plant cells expand, which occurs when loosening events allow the wall to yield to the existing turgor pressure, discussed further in this issue (Cosgrove, 2018). The momentary decrease in water potential results in an influx of water, causing expansion. As new cell wall material is deposited to account for this expansion, the increase in size becomes irreversible, and thus the cell has grown. Modifications to cell wall viscosity promoting expansion can result from a number of different processes. For example, cell wall-loosening enzymes may be activated in or delivered to specific regions. Alternatively, the secretion of flexible cell wall material could be spatially regulated. One extreme form of cell wall patterning is known as tip growth. In tip-growing cells, the zone of reduced cell wall viscosity is focused at the apex of the growing cell. To grow, the cell must balance the delivery of wall material with the retrieval of excess membrane, as the delivery of excess flexible wall material at the cell tip could result in lysis. Tip growth occurs across plant lineages in cell types such as pollen tubes, root hairs, moss protonemata, and bryophyte and algal rhizoids. Although tip growth mechanisms have been generalized as equivalent in pollen tubes, root hairs, and moss protonemata, it is likely that significant differences exist in order for these cells to carry out their divergent functions. Of the three cell types, pollen tubes are the most specialized and short-lived cell, in that their aim is to deliver the sperm cells to the ovule. By transmitting location information about the ovule from outside the pollen tube to the intracellular growth machinery, pollen tubes grow rapidly toward the female gametophyte and burst upon entry. Root hairs are the site of nutrient and water uptake for the plant. In contrast to pollen tubes, root hairs are longer-lived and must integrate many environmental cues (moisture, nutrient content, soil texture, etc.). Root hairs internalize this suite of information to maximize the efficacy of their growth. In contrast to pollen tubes and root hairs, moss protonemata have a colonization role. They germinate from the spore and race against other plants to acquire moisture, nutrients, and an optimal position for photosynthesis. This tip-growing cell continues to undergo cell divisions as the plant develops, reaching a point in which the entire juvenile plant, persisting on the scale of months, consists entirely of protonemata. Thus, moss protonemata are longer-lived than both pollen tubes and root hairs and integrate substantially more environmental information during their growth and development. Even with such divergent functions, mechanistically describing tip growth in each system promises to illuminate fundamental processes conserved throughout plant evolution as well as derived processes that may have evolved in each cell type. Ultimately, the key to understanding tip growth will require understanding a complex interaction network; the reader is directed to recent reviews that expand upon a variety of facets of tip growth not covered here (Mendrinna and Persson, 2015; Hepler, 2016; Damineli et al., 2017; Michard et al., 2017; Stephan, 2017). In this Update, we speculate that further mechanistic advances will come from identifying deeply conserved tip growth mechanisms that decipher signaling events between the cell wall and the cytoplasm. Thus, we will focus on advances in the understanding of cytoskeletal organization, intracellular ion gradients, and the cell wall itself, all key aspects involved in tip growth signaling. A link between wall status and cytoplasmic activity is critical because, in many ways, tip growth resembles a controlled explosion: the cell wall must weaken exactly enough to allow for expansion but not so much that the cell ruptures. Indeed, there are many conditions under which this balance is lost, resulting in either growth arrest or tip bursting. We have compiled a list of agents and mutants that uncouple various aspects of tip growth with similar results (Table I). While not an exhaustive list, Table I demonstrates the wide-ranging conditions that disrupt the precarious balancing act between intracellular and extracellular events during tip growth. By identifying the molecular targets of agents and cellular deficiencies in mutants leading to growth arrest or tip blowout, it may be possible to understand the molecular regulation of this controlled explosion (see Outstanding Questions). RNAi, RNA interference; N/A, not applicable. RNAi, RNA interference; N/A, not applicable. Within the cell, both the actin and microtubule cytoskeletons contribute to tip growth. As we discuss the structure of these cytoskeletons in tip-growing cells, it is important to recall that each array is decorated with, and regulated by, microtubule- and actin-binding proteins. Thus, their localization (Table II) during tip growth provides insights into the mechanism of cytoskeletal organization and dynamics. MTs, Microtubules; PM, plasma membrane. MTs, Microtubules; PM, plasma membrane. Of the two cytoskeletal elements in plants, the actin cytoskeleton, which is discussed further in this issue (Szymanski and Staiger, 2018), is essential for tip growth in angiosperm pollen tubes, root hairs, and moss protonemata. To understand how actin contributes to cell expansion, it is important to determine the subcellular architecture of the F-actin arrays. However, across these systems, visualizing F-actin has been challenging. For example, in fixed cells, fluorescent phalloidin, a widely used probe for F-actin in many cell types, does not readily stain plant cells (discussed by Olyslaegers and Verbelen, 1998). Furthermore, phalloidin only interacts with a subset of F-actin arrays (Nishida et al., 1987) and stabilizes F-actin (Cooper, 1987). Thus, phalloidin often leads to an increase in bundled F-actin (Vidali et al., 2009a). Additionally, to date, GFP-actin fusions have not been successful in plants. Thus, for live-cell imaging, researchers have used fluorescent actin-binding probes, such as Lifeact (Riedl et al., 2008), talin (Kost et al., 1998), and the actin-binding domain of fimbrin (Sheahan et al., 2004). However, these probes also generate artifacts, particularly when highly expressed (Vidali et al., 2009a; van der Honing et al., 2011). Many of the issues arising from using F-actin probes stem from the fact that the binding of these probes to F-actin differs and often is affected by proteins that may be associated with the actin cytoskeleton (Table II). Thus, depending on the probe used and the relative amount of the probe, different subcellular structures can be observed. For example, in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) pollen tubes, fluorescent phalloidin staining revealed F-actin occupying the whole tip region, while Lifeact-GFP revealed pollen tubes with relatively little actin at the tip (Zhang et al., 2016). In root hairs, Ketelaar et al. (2003) visualized F-actin with antibodies or phalloidin. While both methods produced similar results in general, the details of the actin structure were quite different. In moss protonemata, F-actin imaging with fluorescent phalloidin (Vidali et al., 2009a) and Talin-GFP (Finka et al., 2007; Perroud and Quatrano, 2008), revealed thick apical bundles and a prominent apical accumulation. However, the expression of Lifeact-GFP at noninhibitory levels labeled finer actin filaments and provided more detail in the apical structures (Vidali et al., 2009a). Given the species-specific variation and the inherent challenges of imaging F-actin arrays, one must consider the conclusions made within the context of the visualization method and plant species used. Despite differences in F-actin structures between the probes used and the species of cell type examined (Stephan, 2017), it is nevertheless possible to recognize an emergence of commonalities. For example, most pollen tubes exhibit a fringe of short longitudinally oriented actin microfilaments located at the cell cortex near the cell tip, and long actin bundles are found along the length of the cell (Lovy-Wheeler et al., 2005; Fig. 1A). In growing pollen tubes expressing Lifeact-GFP, the fringe was observed to rapidly remodel and move forward with growth (Rounds et al., 2014). Additionally, when pollen tube growth was inhibited with cyanide, the apical fringe degraded more rapidly than the actin cables in the shank of the tube (Winship et al., 2016). In pollen grains, Vogler et al. (2015) showed an F-actin accumulation 180° from the future germination site. This accumulation translocates to the shank after growth initiates. Using a pollen-specific promoter, Actin3, to drive the expression of Lifeact-GFP, Jásik et al. (2016) reported fine F-actin at the tip and dynamic actin along the shank of germinating pollen tubes. Studies such as these demonstrate that pollen tubes have at least two distinct arrays: an apical array that is very dynamic and a array that to have more bundled cytoskeletal structures and ion Pollen after F-actin a fringe with the and the of the form an that the actin Root after F-actin filaments the with the levels of and As both actin bundles and are found toward the of the cell. tip, after actin is along the entire and fine actin is along the length of the cell. cytoplasmic from the point toward the cell tip, after The apical actin is a highly focused and also the of cytoplasmic F-actin structures in growing root hairs aspects of pollen tube bundles are prominent along the shank of the root but not the tip than a fine actin filaments at the tip As with the apical actin structures in pollen tubes, the fine actin filaments in the apex of root hairs are as are more to than actin cables in the shank et al., In to to the tip, it is that this fine F-actin functions to out of the tip and thus the apical zone Using F-actin as a is of has been observed in pollen tubes and protonemata have two tip-growing cell and are from by growing more and cell grow more than F-actin architecture in tip-growing cells has been in protonemata exhibit an of F-actin at the very apex and fine actin filaments along the length of the cell (Vidali et al., 2009a; Fig. and are but are few and toward the of the cell, with cells more bundled While an apical F-actin occurs in both cell types, their structures depending on the cell type. In apical F-actin the whole apical (Vidali et al., 2009a; Fig. in F-actin as a focused apical (Vidali et al., Fig. the apical F-actin and the fine F-actin are very on the order of (Vidali et al., to the apical actin in root hairs, these structures in moss have been to be involved in et al., 2017). In all three tip-growing cells longitudinally oriented actin cables in their However, apical actin structures Pollen tubes, at least in and a actin while moss a focused of Root hairs, in have an array of fine actin at their all three tip structures are which with the relatively F-actin in the regions. it is the dynamic apical that are essential for tip growth (Vidali et al., et al., 2014). In contrast to the essential of have little on angiosperm pollen tube germination and growth in that are not However, in both root hairs et al., and protonemata et al., likely a in the of with both cell types grow the cells to and two or more et al., et al., Ketelaar et al., et al., 2005; et al., of their to tip microtubule arrays are in pollen tubes as well as root hairs and moss protonemata As to F-actin which on actin-binding imaging the microtubule cytoskeleton is most by using antibodies to in fixed material or fusions of with a fluorescent in As a microtubule imaging is to the that F-actin In pollen tubes, are oriented to the long of the cell. In both and pollen tubes, these long are often with fine which to be F-actin on and Hepler, Additionally, pollen tubes a array of at the between the apical zone and the shank (Lovy-Wheeler et al., 2005; Fig. 1A). In root hairs, microtubule organization on the of growth. root hairs have two of and are observed in both and root hairs are visualized at the very apex is on the method of et al., The of is on growth root hairs have that grow from the have and root hairs have and 2014). are only observed in growing root hairs et al., and from the et al., Fig. In moss protonemata, there are also two of cytoplasmic and In the apical cell, the of cytoplasmic between the and the cell apex is with an apical focus of microtubule et al., 2014). In the microtubule array consists of that et al., 2015; et al., to be for in root hairs and protonemata, one is that spatially specific F-actin (see Outstanding Questions). In of this et al. that two and microtubule organization and growth. The plants exhibit protonemata that not grow but have cytoplasmic However, the apical are that and focus apical in protonemata et al., 2014). in cells, cytoplasmic focus on the location by the apical actin and that may with the apical F-actin is an that to actin during cell in protonemata and Table II). grow and than the particularly when under conditions and 2014). these that an link between actin and is critical for during tip growth. Studies of also a for in tip growth. both and F-actin et al., 2007; et al., In has activity et al., pollen tubes grow et al., of root hairs and protonemata with et al., et al., Furthermore, F-actin arrays are in pollen pollen tubes exhibit fine apical F-actin bundles the to the plasma and to an apical in pollen tubes et al., Table II). is that the location of is by and with the may be depending on the of in root hairs (Table and plants have root hairs the length of plants et al., 2017). To in root hairs, et al. for and physical between and of a small to be a of tip growth in root hairs et al., et al. found that and are in the and that with binding the form of and promoting et al. on to that with the for binding to these and et al., 2007; et al., et al. that functions to and of by the of the many processes and structures involved in tip the cytoskeleton, is not only by proteins but also by the cytoplasmic we highlight ion in and as for these processes 2016; Michard et al., 2017). To that a is particularly prominent in growing pollen tubes, the point to the extreme apex of the pollen to the apical plasma 1A). Root hairs have a To date, in moss protonemata In an on with a fluorescent et al. observed and associated with both the apex and the of apical However, et al. not a as in growing pollen tubes and root In root hairs and pollen tubes, many both on the plasma as well as on are likely to be involved in and the apical have in pollen tubes and and their in the apical as a of of the apical plasma membrane. the in Arabidopsis was in tip plants are et al., 2016; Table I). pollen tubes were to have and have the ovule. Additionally, root hairs of and plants are and have (Zhang et al., 2017). of the a in the in pollen tubes. pollen tubes are and the of are with the type et al., Table I). In to and on pollen that F-actin et al., and et al., a in is to determine of is to the during tip growth (see Outstanding Questions). The may growth by secretion (Winship et al., F-actin structures actin-binding which we focus on actin-binding proteins with are and (Table which are for a key in different actin arrays in root hairs and pollen tubes. While the actin-binding and of both the and the domain et al., are et al., activity is et al., 2004). localization is but it to to filaments along the shank of root hairs der Honing et al., Table II). likely that apical likely not the et al., In of pollen tubes have an apical actin structure et al., is to be a of actin structures et al., to actin in a et al., and and Pollen tubes of mutants have et al., or et al., actin of with in moss that growth is on (Vidali et al., Indeed, plants are than the size of and cells grow (Vidali et al., The is the for actin and and 2007; Table II). which are not known to have will nevertheless be affected by require as a One can that binding activity the structure of the actin array with various cellular of actin et al., Pollen tubes and root hairs also or In growing pollen tubes, there is an a few the tip, with a small at the tip et al., et al., is that an for gradients, to the plasma of the shank and an apical cytoplasmic in pollen tubes et al., 2008), well with the Although are to of the of their to tip growth is intracellular can the of growth et al., 2017). both the and extracellular of root hairs also has revealed et al., While the is not as as in pollen tubes, the is and is with root et al., 1998). The and at the cell apex of pollen tubes and root hairs are not but Indeed, of these how ion mechanistically link to tip growth. on pollen tubes that the in growth et al., et al., By the apical the growth the in secretion of new wall material (Lovy-Wheeler et al., on the extracellular in root hairs that an in the in growth et al., While it is how these the on pollen tubes provides for the that in have a with the process of growth. To the between gradients, and growth in pollen tubes, et al. (2016) inhibited pollen tube growth with (Table and the of the and Although the growth it was that of the and the process of secretion Indeed, the the been (Winship et al., 2016). results provide to the that are involved in tip growth. regulation of tip growth is to the actin In the as found in the the of F-actin in the fringe in pollen tubes F-actin at this Hepler, 2016; Table II). is in pollen tubes, to the of the and to the actin fringe (Lovy-Wheeler et al., of activity the of the actin fringe as it with recent has a new from to and actin in a et al., 2017), that regulation of may be important for actin fringe In contrast to pollen tubes, in moss protonemata is et al., Table II). However, is essential for tip growth and F-actin in protonemata et al., the key that dynamic actin in tip growth. While in pollen tubes to have a of and in root hairs revealed two et al., 2017). The mechanism the in root hairs is not known (see Outstanding Questions). methods to generate different could or For is a for one of that as root hairs have (Zhang et al., 2017). of are not as well pollen tubes with expression of a with levels et al., 2017), a for in the of pollen tubes, is highlight the to the mechanism of in tip-growing (see Outstanding Questions). Plant cell and thus are both and by the cell wall. To understand how to the cell for a wall weakening at the cell tip for tip one must consider cells have found in most plant cells, such as and However, that the and of these from plant cells, with while is at the tip in pollen tubes, root hairs, and protonemata and Hepler, 2005; et al., 2016). For pollen tubes, the that either as deposited or a in the of the wall and In and pollen tubes, are in an with the increase of the increase in growth et al., et al., 2011). have to the that the or of wall material the existing wall and for at the of secretion et al., further results in that is with the as the et al., Thus, secretion growth. is that the of and the apical wall and Hepler, This activity can the of the pollen tube shank cell wall. However, at the tube tip, a be to the weakening of the wall. for this may come from in tube systems, may weaken the existing cell wall et al., 2015; et al., 2014). The that the wall more to in the wall. Additionally, in a the resulting wall be more by However, the activity results in the wall not be of the of results in the of a which the wall and contributes to cell wall loosening and is also possible that there could be a increase in the et al., 2008), which could the is or at the very apex is Nevertheless, it is that the of with leading to apical cell wall also may contribute substantially to cell wall growth. a to pollen tube structure and growth et al., mutants are which may result in from reduced pollen tube growth but also from an increase in pollen tube (Table I). The to the that provides to the growing pollen tube at the tip or is involved in the communication between the wall and the cytoplasm. has been to proteins which have been to growth in different tip-growing cells et al., of to a which may be to the plasma a While involved in growth across plant cell types, their specific functions are et al., To the functions of many have used a that and as well as their cell in pollen tubes et al., et al., and moss protonemata et al., 2005; Table I). the cell in pollen tubes but not revealed that cells wall material in the apical et al., In contrast to other such as or cyanide, which the apical pollen tubes with have only levels at their tip et al., Table I). secretion and the of the that these are likely also have in tip growth. In of and in plants with reduced which is to pollen tube growth et al., Table I). moss protonemata plants have reduced cell length (Table I). In root hairs, are reduced in the Arabidopsis The root of exhibit and et al., and Table I). Given that is of a involved in it likely that is involved in the of than microtubule organization However, at the plasma and in the cell wall may the organization of et al., the of cell expansion et al., While it is that are a in cell wall expansion, the mechanism is could the or of new material into the of the cell wall. Alternatively, that with could as a a significant and et al., 2014). Given that are essential for cell wall it is not how the the wall. the for throughout the wall and with the to weaken the wall Alternatively, the of new into the wall will weaken existing wall et al., the also is for intracellular it may to link wall status to the cytoplasm. In this Update, we have to advances in our understanding of tip growth in pollen tubes, root hairs, and moss protonemata. To a mechanistic understanding of tip growth is to how intracellular events a weakening of the apical cell a for cell expansion. The of must be with the of new wall or tip growth (Table I). As ion in different processes. For example, the of F-actin in the to the of actin-binding proteins (Table the of and et al., 2017; Outstanding Questions). is that dynamic ion and cytoskeletal elements in the the site of expansion it is to understand how the cell wall to the intracellular for expansion (see Outstanding Questions). By to both the and differences across tip-growing systems, we insights into fundamental and derived processes that in a tip-growing plant cell.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bascom et al. (2017) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: