Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The year 2011 marks the end of the first 50 years of brief intervention effectiveness trials for heavy drinkers. The first trial was undertaken by Morris Chafetz and colleagues at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston and published in 1962 [1]. This was the culmination of a series of studies begun in the late 1950s which investigated the adequacy of existing emergency care for those who were known at that time as alcoholics. It appeared in the same year as D.L. Davies' paradigm-shifting study undertaken in London at the Maudsley Hospital of apparently unproblematic drinking among former alcoholics [2]. The connection with the D.L. Davies study was not simply coincidental. Their publication in the same year reflected broader developments in thinking about heavy drinking and alcohol problems which were to have major implications for the subsequent development of brief intervention study, as well as for alcohol research more broadly. Throughout that decade and the next one the disease concept of alcoholism was robustly challenged to prepare the way for a new science of drinking problems that was fundamentally behavioural in nature [3]. It was one such behavioural conception that underpinned the approach that was developed by Chafetz and colleagues, even though they were addressing the needs of men with very severe alcohol problems [1]. Brief interventions only made sense if drinking problems were understood as behaviour over which control could be exercised [4]. Contemporary challenges in brief intervention research reflect the ambitious nature of the underlying aspirations to pragmatically seize opportunities to prevent and reduce alcohol harms among heavy drinkers wherever and however they arise [5]. There are thus strong echoes of the past in today's research agendas. Despite a research literature stretching back 50 years, effectiveness trials continue to be needed as there are many important uncertainties remaining about the size of effects that may be expected. The literature has been strongly grounded in primary care [6] and has developed disappointingly slowly in other health settings and hardly at all in non-health settings other than universities [7]. The effects of setting, as well as those of practitioners, have not been studied in systematic reviews. The impact of very brief or ‘minimal’ interventions in the form of conversations of less than 5 min also largely remain to be evaluated [8]. The effects of brief interventions in different drinking groups is a further area for research. Most importantly, there is considerable uncertainty about the effectiveness of brief interventions among heavier drinkers and those with more severe dependence which it will be important to investigate [9]. Computers and the Internet have changed the world we live in, and so too the possibilities for brief interventions [10,11]. As well as these unanswered questions bearing on the substantive effects of brief interventions, attention to more methodologically orientated issues is needed. Methods for process studies of the contents of brief interventions are developed only in relation to motivational interviewing [12]. There are problems in the design and conduct of behaviour change trials more broadly that have been most extensively studied in the brief intervention field, such as assessment reactivity [13], and other aspects of the design of non-intervention control conditions [14]. The validity of self-reported data on drinking behaviour in the specific context of brief intervention trials also warrants dedicated study [15]. Whether and how targeting alcohol should be integrated with other behaviours is still unclear, as are many issues to do with routine implementation and the part to be played by brief interventions within larger scale multi-component programs to combat alcohol harms at the population level [7]. Innovations in research methods, or innovative applications of existing methods, will be useful in meeting these challenges. The core ideas of brief interventions remain unchanged. The targeting of heavy drinkers for the reduction of consumption and the amelioration of problems will continue to be attractive because the majority of the population burden of alcohol-related problems is generated by those with few or no obvious problems rather than the smaller number of those with severe dependence or other problems [16]. It is fitting that the brief interventions research community returned to Boston for the recent eighth annual meeting of INEBRIA (International Network on Brief interventions for Alcohol Problems). The vibrancy of the meeting reflected the energy being invested in innovative thinking and evidence generation. The annual meeting was attended by more than 200 participants who discussed reformulating the aims and objectives of the network, and considered including drugs other than alcohol. As well as standard scientific oral presentation sessions and symposia, workshops were designed to assist early career researchers. The current rapid escalation in publication of brief intervention research studies (enter ‘brief intervention’ as a search term in any database and examine the time trends) was well reflected in the meeting. The next meeting will be in Barcelona in September 2012 (see http://www.inebria.net/Du14/html/en/Du14/index.html for further details). We need better brief intervention research to more successfully meet the needs of heavy drinkers and others who may benefit from simple encouragement of, and support for, changing their behaviour. Interesting times lie ahead in brief interventions effectiveness research in the effort to translate greater understanding of the complexities discovered in the first 50 years into real benefits for populations in the next 50 years. There is much potential to be fulfilled.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jim McCambridge (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: