Why the study?
ESC NSTE-ACS guidelines warranted a more conservative approach to hsTnt testing, but its impact on early rule-out frequency and prolonged observation was unclear.
Does the implementation of more conservative ESC guidelines for hsTnt testing impact the frequency of early rule-out and prolonged observation in patients with acute chest pain?
Does the implementation of more conservative ESC guidelines for hsTnt testing impact the frequency of early rule-out and prolonged observation in patients with acute chest pain?
Implementation of the more conservative 2015 ESC guidelines for hsTnt testing led to a decrease in early rule-out and an increase in prolonged observation and invasive procedures.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
More conservative ESC guidelines reduced early rule-out eligibility; leaves open effects on safety and ED workflow in suspected ACS.
OBJECTIVE: Early diagnosis or rule-out of acute coronary syndrome (ACS) is a key competence of emergency medicine. Changes in the NSTE-ACS guidelines of the European Society of Cardiology (ESC) in 2015 and 2020 both warranted a henceforth more conservative approach regarding high-sensitivity troponin t (hsTnt) testing. We aimed to assess the impact of more conservative guidelines on the frequency of early rule-out and prolonged observation with repeated hsTnt testing at a high-volume tertiary care emergency department. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We conducted a pre- and post-changeover analysis 3 months before and 3 months after transition from less (hsTnt cut-off 30 ng/L, 3-hour rule-out) to more conservative (hsTnt cut-off 14 ng/L, 1-hour rule-out) guidelines in 2015, comparing proportions of patients requiring repeated testing. RESULTS: We included 5442 cases of symptoms suspicious of acute cardiac origin (3451 before, 1991 after, 2370 (44%) female, age 55 (SD 19) years). The proportion of patients fulfilling early-rule out criteria decreased from 68% (2348 patients) before to 60% (1195 patients) with the 2015 guidelines (P < .01). Those requiring repeated testing significantly (P < .01) increased from 22% (743 patients) to 25% (494 patients). Positive results in repeated testing significantly (P = .02) decreased from 43% (320 patients) to 37% (181 patients). Invasive diagnostics were performed in 91 patients (2.6%) before and in 75 patients (3.8%) after (P = .02) the guideline revision. CONCLUSION: The implementation of the more conservative 2015 ESC guidelines led to a minor rise in prolonged observations because of an increase in negative repeated testing and to an increase in invasive procedures.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kienbacher et al. (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: