Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Previous articleNext article FreeEditorial Holy matter and the semantics of image-makingAnnette Hoffmann and Jessica N. RichardsonAnnette Hoffmann Search for more articles by this author and Jessica N. Richardson Search for more articles by this author PDFPDF PLUSFull Text Add to favoritesDownload CitationTrack CitationsPermissionsReprints Share onFacebookTwitterLinked InRedditEmailQR Code SectionsMoreTradition maintains that in the ninth or tenth century, or as late as 1462, pirates attacked a monastery dedicated to St. Michael in Mantamados on the island of Lesbos, massacring all the monks except one, the novice Gabriel, who had hidden on the church’s roof. When the pirates discovered him, St. Michael appeared and raised his sword, causing them to flee. The novice Gabriel is said to have collected soil, soaked in the blood of his slain companions, and shaped it into the image of St. Michael, a work believed to be the icon still venerated today on Lesbos (figs. 1–2).1 In this legend, earth steeped in the martyrs’ blood becomes a working material for art.Figure 1. Icon of the Archangel Michael, 14th century (?) with later additions. Earth, blood, wax, and mastic (?). Monastery of the Taxiarchis, Mantamados, Isle of Lesbos (Greece). Photo: Pelagus Creative Web; reproduced with the kind permission of Father Stavros of the Monastery of the Taxiarchis.Gabriel’s act of mixing blood and earth, on the one hand, evokes legends of Holy Blood relics in the Western Christian tradition, according to which Longinus, following the Crucifixion, collected earth from Golgotha soaked with Jesus’s blood, or else himself mixed the blood and earth, preserving it in a casket.2 Like Longinus, Gabriel of Mantamados prepared a kind of blood relic, endowing it, however, with an image, a face. On the other hand, the spontaneous creation of a tangible image of St. Michael, motivated by pious gratitude for personal rescue, recalls other accounts of the Archangel’s apparitions, which often accompanied the creation of his image.3 Yet, the Mantamados legend creates a special relation between matter (blood and earth) and effigy (icon), complicating modern ontological notions of relic and image. For the icon of St. Michael is not an image into which relics have been inserted, nor is it a figural or painted reliquary made to contain relics.4 Rather, it is an image itself formed—or believed to have been formed—from materials treated as a relic, blood, and earth sanctified through the act of martyrdom.The legend of Mantamados deviates remarkably from earlier accounts of the apparitions of the Archangel in that it implicates the creative process by forging a bond between image/effigy and holy matter. Significantly, the image and its substance do not have an indexical relationship, as, for example, when Jesus’s sweat and blood came in contact with a cloth and reproduced his face upon it, rendering “matter and form … inseparable.”5 The icon represents an angel, not the martyred monks. In this respect, it reflects the personal experience of the monk Gabriel, who bound together within this work two events: the slaughter of his brethren (through the icon’s material, the blood-soaked earth) and his vision of the angel (through its form).The figure of Mantamados encapsulates a complex set of relations between image and matter that, while extraordinary, is not an isolated phenomenon. Such entanglements are manifested across diverse periods and religious cultures. While the literature on materials and image-making, and indeed on materiality more broadly in the context of art history, anthropology, archaeology, religious studies, material culture studies, and the history of science is vast, a specific lacuna exists.6 Notions of the holy and the sacred as they relate to the materials of image-making have yet to be addressed categorically as a topic of inquiry. These relationships are at the core of the group of articles in this volume of Res dedicated to images fashioned from holy matter.Within the Greek legend of Mantamados, blood is not only bound to a specific event and site of Christian martyrdom, but also carries a multiplicity of meanings linked to Christ’s suffering and sacrifice on the cross.7 Blood, moreover, has the potential to hold significance beyond Christianity, with symbolic links, expressed in different religions and spiritual practices, to life, death, salvation, and resurrection, or, conversely, to pollution.8 One might think of the role of blood in the Hebrew Bible and in ancient Israel,9 or the Chinese Buddhist practice of writing in blood.10 Finbarr Barry Flood has recently drawn attention to the traces of blood found in Byzantine, Islamic, and Western medieval manuscripts, as well as the mixing of the blood of a modern Indian cricket star with pulp to create paper used to publish his autobiography. Through these cases, Flood underlines the potential of blood to mediate presence: “the bodies and paraphernalia of spiritual exemplars are, like the materials with which they come in contact, understood as being imbued with an aura of sacrality that is both a mark of personal sanctity and a sign of divine grace.”11 Within the realm of art and image-making, blood has also featured as a medium for works by contemporary artists such as Hermann Nitsch, who mobilizes provocative forms of blood art to confront ritual, violence, and sacrifice, and Vincent Castiglia, who paints exclusively in blood.12 The meaningful mingling of substance and form is all the more powerful in effigies fashioned from blood, as the icon from Mantamados is believed to be. In a nonreligious setting, this is exemplified by Marc Quinn’s series of portrait sculptures Self, begun in 1991 and created every five years from his own frozen blood,13 and by Sarah Levy’s controversial 2015 image of Donald Trump made of her menstrual blood.14 Like the Greek monk Gabriel, these contemporary artists harness ideas of blood as matter, which is an integral aspect of the image and provides a significant interpretive tool for its understanding. Furthermore, in its various combinations with other materials, such as earth or paper, blood impacts form, and the artistic process itself interacts with and transforms its meaning.Yet pointing to the use of blood as an artistic medium, collapsing boundaries between orthodox icons and modern art, despite the fascinating questions it might raise, is not the aim of this special issue of Res. Rather, the seven articles draw attention to images that—like the icon of Mantamados—are perceived to have been made of or shaped from matter deemed holy. All of the materials under consideration here—be they blood, earth, stone, water, wax, wood, or leaves—have been used as a medium or support, whether a surface for painting, a substance for modeling, or a material for building.Within the Christian tradition, images fashioned from holy matter are ubiquitous and diverse, testifying to the richness of the topic. The Mantamados icon itself forms a center of devotion and created, together with its legend, a site of pilgrimage. However, images shaped from earth collected at sacred sites have also been distributed to pilgrims as small devotional objects, as a purchased commodity to take home, or for medicinal consumption.15 In addition to apotropaic or pharmacological concerns, such practices call attention to dynamics of circulation and economy. Examples include the sixth-century clay medallions associated with the Byzantine monastery of Qalʿat Simʿan in present-day Syria, each impressed with the image of St. Simeon Stylites;16 the later clay Madonnas from Altötting in Bavaria and Einsiedeln in Switzerland, which are said to contain earth from those sites and show evidence of having been scratched, indicating that abraded particles were then ingested;17 and the so-called benditos from Esquipulas in Guatemala, small clay tablets upon which the image of Christ was impressed.18 All of these objects fashioned from the soil of pilgrimage sites were themselves considered sacred, and some even ingested as holy matter.19 Medallions with images of the Madonna and Child made of earth from the Milk Grotto in Bethlehem, where Mary is said to have lost a drop of her breastmilk, were venerated not only as relics. The faithful dissolved this earth in water and drank it as if it were Mary’s actual milk, thus inciting a miracle of transubstantiation.20 While these cases embody a range of Christian popular beliefs and practices, within Christian theological debates, the Eucharistic host—transubstantiating into the flesh of Christ—has been considered the quintessential image-cum-holy matter, encapsulating the complexity of the theme.21The articles in this volume touch upon many of the issues raised by the above-mentioned devotional objects, including the multiplication and circulation of sacred matter, the consumption of holy liquids, miraculous activity and real presence in matter, and the mediation and distribution of power through matter. They are united by their mutual concern with the intersections between holy matter and image-making, in both praxis and aesthetics. The authors consider the visual strategies used by artists to draw attention to the holiness of the materials they worked with, including accompanying inscriptions and the environment of display. They question what makes a specific material “holy” or “sacred,” and how the holiness of matter was transmitted and communicated in the image-making process, within new settings, or across diverse spiritual traditions. These issues are here examined in relation to Eastern and Western Christian, Islamic, Buddhist, and Native American practices.Concepts of holiness are subject to the theistic or nontheistic nature of different religions. Holiness can be intrinsic to persons, places, objects, or periods of time, and has been ascribed diverse origins: a distant God (perceived as immanent or transcendent in the world), the cosmos, or nature. These beliefs also impact notions of matter—its efficacy, agency, and activation. Moreover, ideas about holy matter across cultures have been shaped by the terms used to describe them and are embedded in language itself. The holiness of matter could be acquired through script as well as ritual speech, as in the case of Christian Transubstantiation through the priest’s words, hoc est corpus meum.22 It thus becomes necessary to question the performative role of language and how communication networks are implicated in interpretations of the holy. This can be further complicated by processes of translation and acculturation, which can themselves impact ideas about image-making.23 Holiness itself is a multilayered phenomenon that has long preoccupied scholars of religious studies and the phenomenology of religion, from Rudolf Otto’s concept of the “numinous” to Mircea Eliade’s idea of the sacred as the “real.”24 Relevant works also include those by Wolfgang Gantke, who offers a method-critical discussion of the term “holiness” positioned at the intersection between classical phenomenology of religion and historical and empirically oriented religious studies and, most recently, Johann Figl, who sheds light on the dynamics of inclusion and exclusion in ideas of holiness, which construct dichotomies of sacred and profane, pure and impure, health and illness, and salvation and damnation.25Equally significant is how notions about the material world and matter are manifested in image-making practices and the aesthetics of images.26 Scholarship on materiality across disciplines has drawn attention to how a given material might inform the making of art and artifacts,27 as well as how the culturally determined properties ascribed to specific materials, such as economic or topographic, might contribute to their meanings, and how the significance and interpretation of these properties could change over time.28 We might point, for example, to an “ecology of the image” as conceived by David Morgan, who considers “the system of relations that organizes the material disposition of an image” and analyzes “its engagement with human and non-human actors”;29 to Caroline Walker Bynum’s work on Christian materiality as it relates to Western medieval images;30 or to the flurry of studies in recent decades that individuate such issues in relation to medieval and early modern art and artifacts from different disciplinary perspectives.31Tim Ingold considers materials’ inherent properties, histories, and mutability, and argues that materials continue to be alive even after they are selected and combined together to create an object.32 Indeed the “agency” and “vibrancy” of matter have generated lively scholarly debates that often (though not always) implicate images.33 Bynum, in her examination of medieval concepts of matter, shows how their very definitions express ideas of change, fertility, generation, and decay. Isidore of Seville (560–636), for example, in his Etymologiae, highlighted the linguistic relationship between the Latin materia and mater (mother) in his section on woodworkers: “All wood, moreover, is called ‘material’ (materia, also meaning ‘timber’) because something can be made from it; the term will be materia whether you apply it to a door or to a statue. For material is always necessary for the production of an object, just as we say that the elements are the materia of things, because we see that it is from them that actual things are made. It is called material (materia) as if the word were ‘mother’ (mater).”34 Bynum discusses how the ideas intimated by Isidore and elaborated by later authors could be extended to images sculpted from wood, but also how they proved paradoxical.The negation of wood’s living properties and the separation of its material qualities from the images created from it are exemplified in a prayer written by the sculptor Lando di Pietro on parchment and dated 1337, found inside his carved wooden crucifix for the Osservanza church in Siena. It asserts that “one should venerate Him [Christ] and not this wood,” meaning the wooden image, which was carved, according to the same text, “in the likeness of Jesus Christ Crucified.”35 The distinction drawn between the subject of representation and the material object was not new and, in fact, lies at the core of the long-disputed nature of Christian image theory and ideas of sacred real presence.36 However, images can also “sanctify the material used to create them,” as Gerhard Wolf has argued.37 A case in point is found in the sixth- or seventh-century hagiographic text relating how a sick woman scraped plaster off the wall containing images of Saints Cosmas and Damian, mixed it with water, drank it, and was healed.38 The literature on Christian image theory is rich and need not be rehearsed here. It is sufficient to point out that Christian practice often reveals a different story, and that within these debates, the materials themselves—their ascribed properties and the beliefs surrounding them—have long been in the shadow.As Bynum and others have recently argued, the notion of wood as living matter and its regenerative traits could inform the experience of objects fashioned from it (or even representing it).39 Within the Christian tradition one specific object, above all others, encapsulates these ideas: the cross of the Crucifixion, made according to medieval traditions from different types of wood.40 The wood of the cross was said not only to have come from the Tree of Life in Paradise, but was also repurposed, circulating both before and after it was used to make the instrument of Christ’s Passion.41 Countless legends have been connected to relics of the cross. One of these relics is even said to have contained an image: the foundation legend of the monastery of Fröndenberg relates that the founder’s father brought from the maritime regions an image of the Mother of God made from a beam of Christ’s cross.42Other cases involving wood shed light on how matter could embody a rupture between religious cultures that in turn was tamed through the creation of a new object. In Willibald’s mid-eighth-century vita of St. Boniface—a leading figure in the English Christian mission in the Germanic parts of the Frankish Empire—we read of a tree sacred to the Hessians “in the place called Gaesmere,” known by its pagan name as the Oak of Jupiter. In an effort to quell this idolatry, Boniface felled this gigantic tree, upon which “by the gracious dispensation of the Most High, it was also burst into and of in relates that this the who before had on the and that from this prepared Boniface a wooden dedicated to St. In this legend, we more a of the sacred properties of a specific tree, from its are to then the material for a new Christian Notions of making and to express the of at the of and wood have been ascribed sacred properties in many cultures. Like the by the process of from sacred tree, to the material of wood and to is to the articles in this of which from the at the in in reflects upon the in which materials understood as or holy were used to make how these materials might further through the process of artistic and how meaning might be or through the between image and sacred which can be or or these studies a and and consider a range of including carved or objects, and They questions that center on of materiality as they relate to culturally imbued of holiness ascribed to the materials of image-making, to image and to artistic N. Richardson a in in the century, when the of with the of new through their In the wooden used for these images had been by the bodies of the on their and were associated with their the and to the hidden and its histories, Richardson attention to the relationship between and the object as such and its material in the making of the image. The dynamics between material, image, and holy are in the very of the and its in its or in the representation itself. traces these ideas to the properties of wood as a and to its to Christ’s suffering on the wooden cross of the sacred qualities to wood are also to examination of the of materials from the in after its to create new objects for the In the case of a made for from the wooden the holiness of the was embedded in the wood and its sacred moreover, its into a of spiritual and such as the of the in relation to the more objects in the with and how its form could be connected to the by the also on a of the but in that was with materials of the following its this reveals how holiness could be from the environment of the to a made object, one that the to experience a pilgrimage by of a material to a place could not of circulating images to the living properties of their sacred is at the core of of painted images and inscriptions on tree which came from the ancient tree which the in between the and these and images with the surface of the its and its living substance with the and his that the tree and its to to change, and to as a specific of relic in which is by of of the of their support, these objects the same time, the of writing and on these of about that are intrinsic to Buddhist devotional concepts of sacred matter in relation to image-making practices are also at the core of which on an early image of a the of a for Buddhist monks. In this image, the distinction between representation and an between the and the and, between the and the of the by of these in the process of the the sculptor its the relics of the bodies inside actual its form, and its image. devotional practices, and further contribute to the creation of this holy matter and its in case by a human figure carved out of an earlier a a of holy that is with a in the of the that through the of the into the image of the the sacrality of the material was into a new religious article by on processes out through the making of images and the materials from which they are on a crucifix carved out of the and religious practices to creation legends in the context of For the the sacred significance of was through its use in the in Yet, as it, the is not a how the sacred potential of the said to from the blood and bodies of the stone, from the sacred carries an that is transmitted to the sculpted object. blood a phenomenon that if only in this in the notions of material are thus with Christian ideas of holiness and with Eucharistic of the blood and of In the visual between the Christ and the with ritual such as and the use of in the of the sacred through the author out the processes by which the through its material, was within an to the Eastern Christian tradition, on the relationship through the case of a icon of of in that, to the image of Mantamados, was fashioned from holy that for Byzantine icons and relics were one and the The between the holy icon and its material was through a specific artistic in and materials made holy by being mixed with of relics. this practice to have been to the creation of icons that were venerated and considered This icon and relics and a practice that within the more context of the creation of holy matter in This out in the of relics into the of in to create a holy and, a holy the distinction between icons in which relics have been and icons fashioned from holy matter, how the an between icon and article by the process of what it to make an image. The article at its the very notion of and if and how it can be fashioned from matter. the to form to holy water at in the Holy a on sites from these were to change or the of their and they have been and like In to be for however, they had to be for their analyzes the strategies worked out to and holy that could not be with such as the place of Christ’s in the The relationship between holy substance and image is thus when the within its to such an also in the of the at the star of the was said to be still on the surface of the water in a which the century was by a the of them to for apparitions and as an of an from sacred that are not bound and that their its own of the of to the substance and image with which this blood, earth, and the making of the Mantamados The in which this holy substance is implicated in the image-making process call attention to a concern of all of the The articles show that beyond a given sacred properties, the creative process itself has the potential to meanings or new could be and through the artistic the between matter and this might be in the Mantamados the of the face are the of its and its yet worked which the process of This to the spontaneous creative act made by a motivated by pious one that is with the legend of its the and the of a given image could on the sacrality of its very it blood, wood, or the legends surrounding its Icon of the Archangel Michael Monastery of the Taxiarchis, Mantamados, Isle of Lesbos (Greece). Photo: Pelagus Creative Web; reproduced with the kind permission of Father Stavros of the Monastery of the the articles here on materiality and image-making while of They into how aesthetics and beliefs in the holy or sacred of materials and how they contribute to the use and of devotional and ritual the such intersections might be by and they ontological notions of image and subject and object. It is moreover, that they will new and further to the of art and the power of materials, and visual and material culture across different disciplines and are to and Gerhard Wolf for their support, and The of the legend are it was written only in the and The known of the icon
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hoffmann et al. (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: