In patients with meniscal tears, partial meniscectomy outcomes vary by tear type and location, with medial 1/3 and horizontal tears showing poorer healing.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Partial meniscectomy yields variable short-term outcomes by tear type; leaves open patient selection criteria pending controlled trials.
BACKGROUND described as “functionless remnants of leg muscle origin” by Bland Sutton, 1897, the menisci are now considered crucial of the knee. They are a pair of semilunar fibro cartilaginous structures well recognized to contribute to the of normal knee function, facilitating joint stability by deepening the tibial articulation for convex femoral surface, of articular cartilage by load distribution and shock absorption, improving mobility and joint lubrication with smooth friction gliding surface and resilient to compression. AND METHODS analysis of data in patients who underwent surgery for meniscal tear in single centre by a single surgeon. prospective series consisted of 20 (18 male, 2 female) patients. No patient loss occurred during follow-up in this series. average age at the time of meniscal repair was 36 years (range, 15-60 years). The average follow-up period was 6 months. (35%) meniscal tears were rated acute (injury-to-surgery interval <2 months), and 13 (65%) tears were rated chronic (injury-to surgery interval >2 months). There were 10 (50%) isolated meniscal tears, and 10 (50%) tears were combined with ACL reconstruction. In total 20 patients (36 menisci repaired) most of the tears occurred in white-white zone. 1. The tears in medial 1/3 of the meniscus heal poorly. 2. The interval between the onset of symptoms and the timing of surgery has no difference in the outcome of surgery. 3. The gender of the patient has no effect on the outcome of the surgery. 4. The bucket handle tear is more symptomatic and has better out come after the surgery than other types of tears. 5. Horizontal tears have very bad prognosis of healing and poor outcome. 6. Radial, parrot beak tears have better out come with partial meniscectomy. 7. Partial meniscectomy is an option in medial 1/3rd or white-white zone, and in late presenting cases, and in low demand .
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Narendra et al. (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: