Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
What is our insomnia but the mad obstinacy of our mind in manufacturing thoughts and trains of reasoning, syllogisms and definitions of its own, refusing to abdicate in favor of that divine stupidity of closed eyes, or wise folly of dreams? The man who cannot sleep … refuses more or less consciously to entrust himself to the flow of things (Yourcenar, 1954). Marguerite Yourcenar’s poetic description of insomnia in Memoirs of Hadrian (Yourcenar, 1954) could be an excellent introduction to Schmidt et al.’s (2010) paper ‘Linking impulsivity to dysfunction thought control and insomnia: a structural equation model’ in this issue of Journal of Sleep Research, or even to the entire issue, which includes seven papers on insomnia and disrupted sleep. Schmidt et al. investigated how strategies of thought control at bedtime are associated with insomnia. Investigating 391 students who completed questionnaires on impulsivity, use of thought-control strategies at bedtime and on the severity of insomnia, they reported that specific personality traits may incline individuals with dysfunctional thought-control strategies to unwanted mental activity at night. Using structural equation-modelling analyses, they reported that two facets of impulsivity, urgency and lack of perseverance, were associated with more frequent use of aggressive suppression and worry at bedtime, and that this association was related to the severity of insomnia. Although the correlational nature of the study does not allow conclusions about causality and as much as impulsivity may affect sleep, the reverse is also possible by which insomnia may affect impulsivity; these results add more insight to the phenomenon by which the ‘mad obstinacy of our mind in manufacturing thoughts’ at bedtime competes with sleep. Harrow and Espie (2010), however, reported that increased cognitive arousal at bedtime does not alter time perception in insomniacs. Thus, time estimation, at bedtime and during the day, of 26 participants meeting the criteria of primary insomnia was similar to that of 26 good sleepers, despite evidence supporting increased cognitive arousal at bedtime in insomnia. A different question that is rarely considered in the insomnia literature was addressed in a pilot study by Perlis et al. (2010), who investigated the temporal patterning of the night-to-night variability in the severity of insomnia. They reported that the severity of insomnia in 10 participants with untreated primary insomnia varies in such a manner that insomniacs experienced good sleep during 29–55% of the nights, and that nearly 90% of the instances of ‘better than average’ sleep tend to occur following 1–3 nights of poor sleep. If replicated in a larger study, these findings may have important clinical implications. Notwithstanding, in two of the above studies, participants were recruited from student populations using a variety of self-administered questionnaires to assess insomnia. Insomnia-related questionnaires are the subject of two papers in this issue (Ellis et al., 2010; Yen et al., 2010). The eight-item Athens Insomnia Scale (AIS-8) was developed to assess the severity of insomnia in adults based on the International Classification of Diseases – version 10 diagnostic criteria. Yen et al.’s (2010) study examined the factor structure of the AIS-8 in adolescents. Analysing data obtained from 8319 adolescents, they found that insomnia is a prevalent problem among the adolescent population and that the AIS-8 is composed of two factors: ‘insomnia symptoms’ and ‘subjective sleep and daytime distress’. Interestingly, they found gender differences only in insomnia symptoms, whereas the severity of depression was associated with both factors. Ellis et al. (2010) raised a word of caution about the manner in which questionnaires are used in studies involving insomniacs. Investigating 118 psychology students, they demonstrated that, in poor sleepers, presentation of the Dysfunctional Beliefs and Attitudes about Sleep Scale and the Insomnia Severity Index before the presentation of the Insomnia Ambiguity Task influenced the results significantly by increasing the number of insomnia congruent responses, in comparison with the reverse order of presentations. Investigators should be mindful of these findings when designing questionnaire-based studies to investigate insomnia, as the order in which questionnaires are presented may confound the results. The present issue also includes two epidemiological studies. Boyle et al. (2010) reported one of the few population-based studies that examined the prevalence of insomnia in adults with intellectual disabilities. They reported that the 4-week period prevalence of insomnia in 1032 adults with intellectual disabilities was 9.2%. Mental ill-health, use of psychotropic medications and problem behaviours were associated closely with insomnia. The second paper describes the experience of general practitioners with the assessment and treatment of insomnia based on a national survey of general practitioners in Norway (Silvertsen et al., 2010). The authors report that the prevalence of insomnia among patients in general practice was 11.2%, almost two-thirds of which were believed to be caused by a medical condition. Disappointingly, general practitioners rarely referred patients to polysomnographic recordings and only 8% relied on sleep diaries or questionnaires for the assessment of insomnia. Most general practitioners relied on anamnestic information (91%) and blood tests (40%). Although the collection of papers in the present issue confirms what has been known for many years, that insomnia is a prevalent sleep disorder affecting people of different ages, their results also show that there are still many questions about insomnia that need answers before effective assessment procedures and treatment interventions can be implemented successfully.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Peretz Lavie (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: