Key result
Light to moderate alcohol intake is linked to lower cardiovascular mortality compared with nondrinkers.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Alcohol is used throughout the world and it has long been known that heavy alcohol consumption is hazardous to various body organs including the cardiovascular system. In several countries it is also a major social problem, and alcohol is the second leading cause of preventable deaths after smoking in most industrialized countries [1]. However, there is now also substantial evidence that the intake of light to moderate amounts of alcohol is associated with reduced morbidity and mortality from several cardiovascular conditions, particularly coronary heart disease (CHD) [2]. The interpretation of these beneficial effects has been vigorously discussed and it has been suggested that the effects on cardiovascular disorders might not be due to alcohol per se but to other so called confounding factors [3]. The topic has been extensively covered during the last decades and in 1997, the National Institute of Health published a huge monograph on alcohol and the cardiovascular system [4]. In order to examine the scientific evidence relating to the effects of a low to moderate intake of alcohol a group of experts in the field gathered in April 1998 in San Diego, California. The present article summarizes the conclusions agreed upon at that meeting. It is well established that heavy alcohol consumption exerts deleterious effects on the human body with increased risk to most organs, but primarily to the liver, central nervous and cardiovascular systems [5]. However, light to moderate intake of alcohol does not seem to have these untoward effects and the evidence now suggests that individuals consuming up to and including 2 drinks per day have a reduced risk of some major cardiovascular events [6-9]. However, it is still under debate whether this ‘protective’ effect is due to alcohol per se or is in some way, or to some extent, due to the characteristics of those who drink lightly or moderately. The purpose of the present workshop was to review the scientific data accumulated on alcohol consumption and cardiovascular effects and to try to evaluate whether alcohol in itself could be responsible for the beneficial effects noted in those individuals consuming low to moderate amounts. It was decided to look in particular at data for low to moderate drinkers, which was defined as individuals consuming 1–2 (3) drinks/day (≈10–20 (30) g of ethanol), and not to discuss the effects of heavier drinking ( Fig. 1). Risk reduction from low to moderate intake of alcohol – the ‘J-curve’. In the present document we will only discuss the effect of 1–2 units of alcohol per day on different cardiovascular events, and disregard effects of larger quantities. The definition of a ‘drink’ varies considerably from country to country, but it is usually agreed to be a can/glass of beer (250–350 cc), a glass of wine (150 cc) or a tot/measure (30–50 cc) of spirits. Thus, a ‘drink’ may contain anywhere between 10 and 15 g of alcohol and it is important that all alcohol studies should be explicit about the methods used to estimate intake in grams of alcohol per unit time (day, week, months). The group is aware that several studies have shown that three drinks/per day or more may also be associated with beneficial effects [2, 10, 11], for example a reduction in risk of CHD events [12, 13], but the risk of multiple adverse effects are increased at this level of intake. It was therefore decided to disregard these findings and focus on the effects of light or moderate drinking as defined above. Several factors have to be taken into consideration when the results of the different epidemiological studies on the effect of alcohol on cardiovascular events are evaluated. Some of the more important factors are discussed here. Reference group. It is essential to choose an appropriate reference (baseline) group. In most earlier studies, and even in some recent reports, the nondrinkers forming the reference group includes ex-drinkers [9, 10], a group which may include people of increased risk of major cardiovascular events and total mortality compared with regular light or moderate drinkers, and their risks may even exceed those of heavy drinkers [11]. The use of a reference group containing a significant proportion of ex-drinkers will considerably exaggerate the apparent benefits of light or moderate drinking. However, in most of the recent studies the ex-drinkers are analysed separately [2, 12, 13]. Life long teetotallers would appear to be a more appropriate group, but their proportion in any study sample varies considerably and is often very small. For this reason, and because life long teetotallers in some studies have shown increased risk of total mortality [12, 14], it has been proposed that the large and relatively stable group of occasional, i.e. nonregular drinkers, could be used as the reference group [11]. However, the use of life long teetotallers or occasional drinkers would appear to provide the most appropriate, and least biased reference category. Changes in drinking habits (Table 1). Available data show that there is a continuing tendency for alcohol intake to be reduced with increasing age [15]. In particular heavy and moderate drinkers show the largest reductions in intake over time, moving towards lighter drinking and nondrinking. This process is affected to a considerable extent by the accumulation of ill health and regular medication. This has to be taken into account when subjects are followed up for prolonged periods but are classified by their alcohol intake at one particular point in time. The trend towards reduction of intake or giving up drinking is associated with higher rates of new diagnoses than in those remaining stable in their alcohol intake, and also with higher rates of both cardiovascular and noncardiovascular mortality [16]. Thus the increased cardiovascular risk and other mortality in exdrinkers, and those who have considerably reduced their alcohol intake, may be explained by the reasons for their having given up drinking. Most prospective studies in cardiovascular disease start in middle age, with subjects aged 40–60 years or more, by which time many will have passed through their period of heavy drinking in their earlier decades. Consequently, many individuals may have reduced their intake or given up drinking, often for health reasons, but not necessarily for alcohol-related illness. The use of nondrinkers as a baseline, and the failure or inability to adequately take into account the characteristics of subjects in the different alcohol intake categories, may exaggerate the risk of cardiovascular events and all cause mortality in nondrinkers and the benefits of light drinking. Only a very small group of subjects increased their alcohol intake with age, but this is unlikely to affect the interpretations of relative risks made in this report. Confounding factors. It has been argued that the effects of light/moderate alcohol intake on the cardiovascular system are not entirely due to the direct effects of alcohol, but are at least in part due to confounding factors associated with alcohol consumption, e.g. social class, smoking, physical activity, personality type. As exemplified in the Copenhagen City Heart Study ( Table 2) there are differences in various life style characteristics and cardiovascular risk factors with relation to the amount of alcohol consumed. This is particularly apparent in the extreme groups of nondrinkers and excessive consumers [17]. In many studies in recent years attempts have been made to adjust for these factors, or to take them into account by stratification [9, 11, 17-21]. In the present overview, we have tried to keep this consideration in mind and to build our statements mainly on those studies which include adjustments for these factors in their analyses. However, few studies provide information on the characteristics of the subjects in the alcohol intake categories used. This makes it difficult to assess the likelihood of these associated characteristics having affected the outcome of the analysis. Thus, when it is seen that both exdrinkers and lifelong teetotallers have characteristics which are likely to increase their risk of cardiovascular events or total mortality in comparison with light regular drinkers, then the ability of statistical analysis to adequately take account of the differences between alcohol intake groups could be difficult. Such differences in characteristics between nondrinkers and light to moderate drinkers might contribute to an enhanced difference in cardiovascular risks between the two groups. However, when such confounding factors have been specifically adjusted for in the analyses, it has not resulted in a marked reduction in or elimination of benefits found from low to moderate alcohol intake on CHD risk [9, 11, 17-21]. Other inherent problems. Several other problems also have to be taken into account when the effects of alcohol on humans are considered. Some of these are listed here: Because neither drinkers, nor nondrinkers, are likely to agree to being randomised to drinking or abstinence for periods of years, and because of a variety of other problems (social, ethical and logistic), it is highly unlikely that any interventional study on the long-term effects of alcohol consumption will ever be seriously contemplated, let alone undertaken. We therefore have to rely on information from well designed prospective epidemiological observational studies in representative populations. It has been postulated that inaccurate data on alcohol use will be given by some individuals, and most probably there will be an underestimation, especially in heavy drinkers. However, as we in this paper are only dealing with light to moderate drinkers this will most probably not influence the conclusions drawn [21-23]. The drinking process is very dynamic and, as has been stated earlier, there is a change in alcohol intake (or stated alcohol intake) over time ( Table 1), and this needs to be kept in mind when evaluating the results of different studies [15, 16]. The majority of heavy and moderate drinkers will reduce their intake when growing older. There are also occasional drinkers who will become nondrinkers, and many light drinkers will reduce the intake to occasional or nondrinkers. Very few individuals will increase their intake of alcohol during the years in the age groups we are dealing with here. Consequently, the changes in drinking habits with time would most probably increase the apparent strength of a protective association between lighter drinking and a reduction in cardiovascular events. Another problem is the lack of standardization of the amount of type of alcohol consumed Fortunately, however, a standard ‘unit’ of beer, wine and distilled spirits contains approximately the same amount of alcohol (10–15 g) [24]. The diagnoses of different cardiovascular disorders can sometimes be rather difficult. The symptoms of angina pectoris for example, are subjective, and to reach a diagnosis with accuracy is time consuming and often requires expensive investigations. In addition, many studies have combined all cardiovascular conditions to obtain sufficiently large numbers in the different groups. This might result in a cancellation of positive or negative associations. Heavy drinking has clear harmful effects on the cardiovascular system which is not the case with light to moderate drinking [4, 5, 24]. Mortality. Almost all large-scale studies consistently show that lighter drinkers far better than nondrinkers, and that heavy drinkers are subjected to more cardiovascular deaths than lighter drinkers [2-10]. This is the well-known J-shaped curve [21, 24]. Some of the ‘cardiovascular’ deaths related to heavy drinkers are most probably not due to atherosclerotic coronary disease, but to other causes, e.g. cardiomyopathy, hypertension or haemorrhagic stroke [23, 25]. This fact has certainly influenced the difference between light and heavy drinkers found in some studies [24, 26] In almost all studies performed on adult populations (30–80 years) there is an overall reduction in cardiovascular deaths from 10 to 50% in individuals consuming ≤2 units per day, compared to nondrinkers. The most apparent effects can be seen in subjects with one or more risk factors for cardiovascular diseases [26, 27]. Coronary heart disease (CHD). There is strong evidence supporting the hypothesis that small to moderate amounts of alcohol protects against CHD. In some of the largest prospective cohort studies alcohol lowers CHD mortality substantially, usually compared with nondrinkers [2-8, 10, 11, 17, 24-28]. The lowest risk seems to be amongst subjects reporting an average intake of 1–4 drinks daily. This effect can also be seen in women, and in the Nurses’ Health Study of women consuming 3–9 units per week there was a 40% reduction of CHD in comparison to nondrinkers [29, 30]. Stroke. Several epidemiological studies have suggested that light to moderate drinking may be protective against ischemic stroke and that abstainers are at increased risk [31-35]. However, there may be a risk of overestimating the beneficial effects because of inaccurate comparison groups in some studies [32]. Peripheral arterial disease. The role of alcohol in peripheral vascular disease has received far less attention than the effects of alcohol on other cardiovascular diseases. In one study, the odds of intermittent claudication for a one standard deviation increase in alcohol intake was 1.0, suggesting that alcohol had no influence on the disease [36]. However, in the Edinburgh Artery Study (Scotland), a cross sectional analysis of alcohol intake and relationship with ankle brachial pressure index, a greater alcohol intake in males was related to a higher index, i.e. less severe peripheral arterial disease. In this study the protective effect was more related to wine consumption than to beer or spirits [37]. Also in a large study on approximately. 22 000 US male physicians the results showed that alcohol consumption (regardless of type of alcohol) decreased the risk of peripheral arterial disease in apparently healthy men [38]. Sex. Most of the studies have been performed in men and it can be concluded that the most apparent beneficial effects of light to moderate drinking are found in men over the age of 40 years. In the relatively few studies performed in women on alcohol consumption and cardiovascular disease [20, 29-31], it has been found that women who consume ≤2 drinks a day also benefit. This is particularly noted in postmenopausal women over the age of 50 [30, 31]. Age. There is no hard evidence for a reduction in cardiovascular mortality in light to moderate drinkers at an age below 40 years, neither for men nor for women. However, given the very low incidence of cardiovascular disease in young people, it would be very difficult to detect a real protective effect of alcohol in this population, except in very large studies. There is also some evidence that there is a minor increase in the risk of breast cancer in younger women consuming even small amounts of alcohol on a regular basis [39, 40]. Based upon ecological studies on the correlation between wine intake per capita in different countries, and incidence of cardiovascular diseases, it has been postulated that wine has a more beneficial effect than beer or spirits. St Leger et al. [41], Renaud et al. [6], and later Criqui et al. [18] found inverse relations between incidence rates of cardiovascular disease and wine consumption in different countries, but no such relation for the other types of beverages. A number of clinical and experimental studies support the hypothesis that there may be additional beneficial factors present in wine, but not in beer and spirits [41-47]. Several prospective cohort studies of the effects of alcohol on cardiovascular disease morbidity and mortality have addressed the question of different effects of the different beverages types. The conclusions have been diverse, but some studies specifically addressing this question, including studies able to distinguish between the effects of the different types of alcohol and beverages, have concluded that there may be an additional beneficial effect of wine [17, 44-47]. In one study it was concluded that beer drinking men and wine drinking women were at a lower risk of hospitalization than others [45]. However, Rimm et al. concluded that since an even number of studies found beer, wine, and spirits to be equally protective, the differences may be due to specific cohort effects, and that ethanol in itself could be responsible for the reduced risk of CHD [7]. A large part, but not all, of the greater benefit for CHD and total mortality seen in wine drinkers can be attributed to their advantageous life style characteristics, suggesting that these factors are largely responsible for the apparent benefits of being a wine drinker [46, 47]. Consequently, in view of the literature available today it must be concluded that there is no strong evidence for a better protective effect on cardiovascular events of wine than of other type of liqueurs, but that confounding factors such as diet and life-style factors may play a role [45-47]. Protective effects. The protective effect of low to moderate consumption of alcohol on cardiovascular diseases could mainly be the result of the following factors: Blood lipids: The protective association observed between moderate alcohol consumption and risk of CHD is likely to be mediated primarily through the effects of alcohol on blood lipids [48-50] and on haemostasis [51-53]. It has furthermore been estimated that the protective effect could be explained by the favourable effects of alcohol on high density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL) and particularly its subfractions HDL2 and HDL3[48, 49]. The effects on HDL may account for about 50% of the beneficial effect found [50]. The effects of moderate alcohol consumption are, however, small on other lipids and lipoprotein levels such as LDL cholesterol, triglycerides, and lipoprotein(a), although marked effects have been noted in high consumers (reductions in LDL cholesterol and Lp(a) and increase of triglycerides) [48]. Coagulation system: Moderate alcohol consumption is known to acutely inhibit platelet aggregation, particularly after a fatty meal, and influences the coagulation system by reducing the circulating level of plasma fibrinogen [51]. There is both prospective cohort study evidence that platelet activity influences CHD risk and randomized trial evidence that aspirin, which like alcohol decreases the secondary aggregation of platelets, reduces CHD risk [52]. Moreover, the alcohol induced increase in activity is of the effects and it is therefore likely that the effects on haemostasis the protective effect of drinking on CHD risk This is also by several studies suggesting that there is also an protective effect of alcohol on the risk of CHD and effects on vascular data that moderate alcohol consumption may effects although the and its to is not Alcohol consumption may also affect vascular and vascular by with effects of small amounts of alcohol vascular higher amounts may is to both the and the long-term effects on the intake of low to moderate amounts of alcohol seems to with lower and lower of may account for part of the beneficial effects on cardiovascular events is still However, it has been proposed that low to moderate levels of alcohol consumption may reduce and and in people moderate drinking has been to and effects. The adverse effects of a regular light to moderate intake of alcohol are and related in of increased risks for various to related adverse effects the following should be blood The blood pressure is not affected intake is light to moderate There may be a increase in incidence of cancer and breast cancer [39, Alcohol There is a risk of regular to moderate drinkers alcohol but in the age groups we are and women years) this risk seems to be [15, with The risk of between and alcohol has also to be in mind as a large proportion of the most likely to benefit from light alcohol intake are on regular In consideration of the data in this article it is our that the following can be There are specific groups of individuals in the benefits of light to moderate drinking of alcohol for cardiovascular diseases appear to the negative effects of most likely to benefit are those at higher risk of cardiovascular diseases, such as middle aged men and postmenopausal women, especially those with cardiovascular risk factors. It is whether the benefit of different types of alcohol and beverages wine, and is in to the risk of cardiovascular diseases. In light of the evidence it is not to established light to moderate drinkers at average risk for disease to from drinking. There is about the data which that even low levels of alcohol intake are associated with increased risk of breast cancer and There is still about the of the association between drinking and the overall benefits because of study and the of which alcohol intake is the most appropriate to use as a baseline, i.e. nondrinkers in lifelong teetotallers or occasional the problem of adequately into account the characteristics of subjects in the various alcohol intake the failure to take into account the of alcohol intake over and the problems with adjustments for the confounding influence of life style factors and factors. However, for some social factors has been in the this has not resulted in an nor a marked of apparent benefit of alcohol intake and CHD Based on the data available today we that the following statements can be There are no scientific reasons to to increase alcohol consumption in the to individuals on alcohol consumption should be on the of risks and benefits to that particular heavy drinkers should be to reduce their Most light to moderate drinkers no specific should not be to start drinking. There is no overall evidence that there is any difference in protective effects between beer, wine or spirits on cardiovascular events. In although we the benefits associated with light to moderate drinking in groups individuals with risk factors for cardiovascular the major to be taken in the of established cardiovascular disease the well-known risk factors such as smoking, physical and 15
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fagrell et al. (1999) conducted a review in Cardiovascular diseases (including coronary heart disease, stroke, and peripheral arterial disease). Light to moderate alcohol consumption (1-2 drinks/day; 10-30 g ethanol) vs. Nondrinkers (including lifelong teetotallers, occasional drinkers, or ex-drinkers) was evaluated on Cardiovascular mortality and coronary heart disease events (10% to 50% relative risk reduction). Light to moderate alcohol intake (≤2 drinks/day) is associated with a 10% to 50% reduction in cardiovascular deaths compared with nondrinkers in adults aged 30–80 years.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: