Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Conrad SchirokauerApril 29, 1929–September 19, 2018 Robert Hymes Around 1990 I had the privilege to experience perhaps the most intense period of prolonged collaborative collegiality I have known. This was the year and some months that Conrad Schirokauer and I spent meeting at least weekly at the Hungarian Pastry Shop, on Amsterdam Avenue near the Columbia campus, to work together on what became our edited volume Ordering the World: Approaches to State and Society in Sung Dynasty China (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1993). Conrad had been a respected senior colleague for me for a long time before that; we had already collaborated in organizing the 1986 Song Statecraft Conference out of which the volume grew, and with the papers rewritten by their authors, we were working on editing them into final form and co-writing the volume introduction. The work was a joy: in many hours of face-to-face conversation over coffee, hot chocolate, and excellent pastry each week for more than a year we (slowly—we were both slow workers) made the progress we needed to make on the volume; but perhaps more importantly for me, I came to understand how much one could learn from Conrad, and about how many things. Conrad was both a first-rate scholar and a deeply learned man. He was also a wise and kind man. One might expect an obituary for a field journal to concentrate only on its subject's scholarship, his contribution to the field—though in a way this seems strange, since a field journal's readership very probably already knows the scholarship and its author's place in the field better than [End Page v] any other audience would. I write this obituary not only as Conrad's colleague but as his friend, and I mean here to convey the personal side of Conrad as much as his scholarly side. In any case, in writing "scholarship, his contribution to the field" above, I have already committed a conceptual slippage that I think we in the academy commit too often, since I hope to make clear that in Conrad's case the "contribution to the field" went well beyond what we sometimes too narrowly mean by "scholarship." Let me tell a couple of very small stories and a bigger one that have stayed with me through the years in my picture of who Conrad Schirokauer was. I first met Conrad briefly in Kyoto during my year and a half of dissertation research in Kyoto, probably in 1977, at a party at I forget which other American graduate student's house, and while he seemed a very nice man and I already knew and liked a little of his work, the meeting was too brief for me to get much sense of him. A fuller clue of his personal qualities first came via an episode in which I didn't even encounter him directly but only heard about his role. My advisor Robert Hartwell, as will not be startling news to this audience, was a very difficult man, and while he produced a solid series of Ph.D. students, others came to irresolvable conflicts with him at one stage or another and peeled off, or he shed them—depending on point of view—with remarkable frequency over the years. One such student, well ahead of me in the Hartwellian assembly line and already some chapters into the dissertation, had come to this breaking point, and startled me by reaching out to Conrad for rescue: he would—the plan went—step in as dissertation-advisor-from-a-distance, Hartwell would leave the committee, and the dissertation would go forward with an outside advisor. What startled me more was that in all this Hartwell, quite uncharacteristically, had nothing at all bad to say about Conrad: Conrad was somebody he respected, and honestly, he didn't respect that many colleagues. In the event the arrangement didn't work out and the dissertation was never completed, but what I learned from it was that Conrad was kind enough to be willing to step in as an advisor mid-dissertation for a student from another university, in a sticky situation in...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Robert Hymes (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: