Simulation-based training is an effective method to familiarize cardiac ICU providers with the specialized CALS-S algorithm, which prioritizes early defibrillation over immediate chest compressions in postcardiac surgery arrest.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Simulation training for special-circumstance arrests may enhance preparedness; leaves open impact on outcomes.
The advanced cardiac life support (ACLS) algorithm addresses resuscitation in the general population. Certain patient populations present specific situations that are best managed by algorithms that differ from standard resuscitation guidelines. These guidelines are targeted at the most common causes of arrest and may lead to better outcomes. This has been addressed by the European Resuscitation Council with development of arrest guidelines in specific circumstances.1 For example, a protocol for management of traumatic cardiac arrest has been developed, which is aimed at immediate identification of the most likely causes (eg, hypovolemia secondary to hemorrhage, respiratory failure, and tension pneumothorax) with less emphasis on the standard ACLS algorithm.2,3 The goal of these modified guidelines is to optimize chances of successful resuscitation by rapid identification and management of specific causes of arrest in contrast to routine management by use of our generic ACLS algorithms. There are other acute arrest scenarios in which alternatives to standard ACLS can improve chances of survival and outcome. Some of these include arrest during pregnancy, hypothermia, and drowning.1 Providers of advanced life support are familiar and trained in standard ACLS, but it is likely that most are unfamiliar with situation-specific arrest algorithms. Understanding and practice of algorithms that are pertinent to providers' clinical practice can lead to improved outcomes and survival in patients for whom they provide emergent care. Specific guidelines for postcardiac surgery patients were developed by The European Association of Cardiothoracic Surgery and integrated into the European Resuscitation Council guidelines (Fig. 1). These guidelines have now been endorsed by the Society for Thoracic Surgery. Patients undergoing cardiac surgery represent a unique population whose peri arrest management must be tailored toward their circumstances. This patient group has a high incidence (0.7%–2.9%) of cardiac arrest after the surgical procedure.4–9 Survival to discharge in cardiac surgical patients who have experienced early postoperative cardiac arrest is 60% to 69%, compared with a range of 0% to 79% in all intensive care unit (ICU) patients.4,10 The higher rate of survival in cardiac surgical patients is likely related to the limited causes of arrest soon after surgery, which includes tamponade, hypovolemia, myocardial ischemia, tension pneumothorax, or pacing failure. This narrow differential for cause of arrest alters the initial management and can improve survival in comparison with result of arrest in all ICU patients. Ventricular fibrillation is the initial arrest rhythm, noted in 25% to 50% of cardiac arrests in cardiac surgical ICUs.1,11 Furthermore, poststernotomy patients have new suture lines that are at risk of major bleeding and morbidity with chest compressions, which can lead to cardiac tamponade or ventricular rupture. In the combination of primary ventricular fibrillation along with the risk of significant harm of chest compressions, the European Resuscitation Council recommends specific arrest management1 that prioritizes defibrillation in place of immediate chest compressions (Table 1). This differs from standard ACLS, which recommends immediate chest compressions, which should be continued between defibrillations.FIGURE 1: The CALS-S algorithm.TABLE 1: Comparison of Standard ACLS with CALS-SThis specific protocol for postcardiac surgery management of cardiac arrest has been recently instituted in multiple cardiac surgical ICUs in the United States. Recognition that these patients need a deviation from the standard algorithm is critical toward optimizing outcomes of patients in cardiac surgical ICUs. The purpose of this report is to describe the creation and implementation of simulation designed to address the use of a resuscitation algorithm that differs substantially from standard approaches. LEARNING OBJECTIVES During this simulation session, the learner should demonstrate an understanding of the postcardiac surgery arrest algorithm. By the end of the session, the learner will be able to the following: Identify a deteriorating patient in the postcardiac surgery ICU. Use the resources available to call for emergent management in a near cardiac arrest scenario. Implement the protocol of cardiac advanced life support-surgical (CALS-S) for a cardiac surgery patient and verbalize differences from ACLS in other patient populations. Discuss how to work effectively as a team with delineation of individual roles and use of closed loop communication. Discuss how team interaction affects management in cardiac surgical patient arrest. PREPARATION Location and Additional Information One of the facilitators reviews the specific cardiac arrest algorithm for postcardiac surgery patients (CALS-S) with participants; an explanation of why it varies from ACLS is covered. Each participant receives a card with the CALS-S algorithm and is told where it can be found in each patient's room (Fig. 1). The scenario occurs in the cardiac surgery ICU in a patient room with an intubated and mechanically ventilated patient who has recently been admitted from the operating room after coronary artery bypass grafting. The primary nurse is recruited as a learner and takes the role of the nurse assigned to the patient. Typically, the nurse learner is a new staff (<1 year) or orienting to the cardiac surgical ICU. The primary nurse is given the case stem as well as the patient data and background before initiation of the simulation. Items 3 through 8 in the equipment list hereafter are available on the cart for use specifically with simulations in this ICU. Other Equipment High-fidelity mannequin connected by cable to portable ICU monitor, computer to move through scenario Cardiac monitor with hemodynamic waveforms—pulmonary artery pressures, right atrial pressure, arterial line pressure, heart rate, end-tidal carbon dioxide, and pulse oximetry Introducer with pulmonary artery catheter Arterial line Endotracheal tube in a patient connected to a mechanical ventilator Medication infusions on infusion pumps—epinephrine, sodium nitroprusside, insulin, lactated Ringers solution, propofol infusion Defibrillator with cardiac arrest cart Foley catheter with urometer Chest tubes Temporary epicardial pacing wires attached to a pacing box Peripheral intravenous catheters Support Files Laboratory values on arrival in ICU and during initial phase of cardiac arrest Time Duration Set-up: 20 minutes Simulation: 10–15 minutes Debrief: 10–15 minutes Case Stem A 60-year-old male patient arrives in the ICU after a coronary artery bypass grafting ×2 and mitral valve repair. This patient had an uneventful course in the operating room and is listed as rapid recovery status. His cardiac rhythm is normal sinus with intermittent premature ventricular contractions (PVCs). Additional Instructor Information Despite the administration of 40 mEq of intravenous potassium for the low potassium, the PVCs become more frequent. As she calls to notify the nurse practitioner, the patient continues to deteriorate to ventricular fibrillation. Cardiac arrest code is initiated. After 3 defibrillations of 200 J and 300 mg intravenous amiodarone, cardiopulmonary resuscitation is initiated for 2 minutes before the fourth defibrillation results in return to spontaneous circulation (Table 2).TABLE 2: Simulator Programming NotesPATIENT DATA, BACKGROUND, AND BASELINE STATE Allergies: No known medication allergies Medical History Coronary artery disease, mitral regurgitation with congestive heart failure, hypertension, hyperlipidemia Obesity: Body mass index 32 m/kg2 Obstructive sleep apnea (uses a continuous positive airway pressure machine at night) Type 2 diabetes mellitus for 10 years Nicotine dependence Current Medications Metoprolol 100 mg twice daily Lipitor 40 mg daily Insulin: Aspart premix (70/30) 6 U twice daily Physical Examination Weight: 100 kg, height: 175 cm, BSA: 2.25 Neuro: Pupils bilateral −2 mm and reactive, Richmond Agitation Sedation Scale R −4 Cardiac: Cardiac output 4.5 L/min, cardiac index 2.2 L/min/m2, external atrial and ventricular wires connected/off, sinus rhythm, heart rate 96 beats per minute with PVCs, ejection fraction 30% (per transesophageal echocardiogram after cardiopulmonary bypass) Respiratory: Lungs bilaterally clear, mediastinal chest tubes × 2, and left pleural chest tube Ventilator settings: Synchronized intermittent mandatory ventilation: respiratory rate 16, positive end-expiratory pressure 8 cm H2O, pressure support 5 cm H2O, tidal volume 495 mL GI/GU: Abdomen soft, nondistended, urine output > 100 mL/H Skin: Sternotomy, warm to touch Access: Left radial arterial line, double-lumen introducer in right internal jugular vein/pulmonary artery catheter, peripheral intravenous catheters × 2 (14 gauge) Fluids: Epinephrine infusion 0.03 μg/kg/min, sodium nitroprusside infusion 0.5 μg/kg/min, insulin infusion 2 U/H, lactated Ringers 20 mL/H Vital signs: Heart rate 96 beats per minute, blood pressure 109/55 (73) mm Hg, right atrial pressure 10, pulmonary artery pressures 25/15, oxygen saturation 100% Postoperative Laboratory Results Postoperative tests: Participants given written report Electrocardiogram: Normal sinus rhythm with occasional PVCs Chest x-ray: Interval sternotomy, mitral annuloplasty, pulmonary artery catheter in right pulmonary artery, endotracheal tube 4 cm above carina, no focal infiltrates, pleural fluid, or pneumothorax Other postoperative laboratory results are presented in Table 3.TABLE 3: Postoperative Laboratory ResultsEmergent bedside laboratory results during arrest are presented in Table 4.TABLE 4: Emergent Bedside Laboratory Results During ArrestCase Implementation Participants/Learners These simulations involve critical care nurses, critical care fellows, and critical care attending physicians, nurse practitioners, pharmacists, charge nurses, respiratory therapists, and phlebotomy technicians. The teams vary in size depending on availability of critical care fellows. The optimal team size is 6 to 8 individuals. This scenario highlights the differences in management of arrhythmia in the postcardiac surgery population from the management of the same arrhythmia in the standard arrest situation. DEBRIEFING Debriefings occurred in cardiac surgery ICU patient room immediately after scenario. Confidentiality was discussed. Participants were asked to share their thoughts and feelings about the scenario and participation. Next, a few minutes were spent reviewing the cardiac surgery advanced life support algorithm and differences from standard ACLS. Participants were asked to reflect on the differences between standard ACLS and what they had just practiced with the CALS-S algorithm. Learners expressed the challenges of use of a patient-specific algorithm when all trainings are focused on standard ACLS. This was commonly described by participants, and thus, the need for differences in the algorithm was reviewed. Participants were encouraged to recall complications possible with initiation of standard ACLS in this patient population. The purpose of CALS-S was discussed further. All learners participated in discussing goals including avoidance complications seen with standard ACLS, role in optimization of outcome with minimization of harm by defibrillation early, and initiation of compressions later. The last few minutes of debriefing were spent discussing team dynamics. Initially, the participants were asked to reflect on how well they worked together. Participants were encouraged to discuss team leadership roles, individual role identification, and closed loop communication. Participants were also asked to fill out electronic anonymous surveys. DISCUSSION Training Evaluations Overall, the simulations were well received. Orienting nurses as well as orienting nurse practitioners and critical care fellows expressed that their comfort with the cardiac surgery algorithms was enhanced. Our initial surveys were sent electronically, and our initial response rate was approximately 30%. In the future, surveys will be delivered by hand with an anonymous response to improve our response rate. Lessons Learned A busy cardiac ICU limits time available for education and training. Use of in situ simulation to remind team members of specific emergency management in their patients and allow hands-on experience was well received by ICU staff. Continued use of scenarios to educate newer staff and rotating team members may be useful to maintain recognition of the differences of cardiac surgery arrest algorithms. Some participants did express difficulty in practice of an alternative cardiac arrest algorithm. Debriefing sessions were used to discuss these feelings and ensure that participants understood all the goals of CALS-S. Many participants expressed a desire to repeat the simulation again. Limitations on resources and the availability of staff due to the almost full occupancy of our ICU have kept us from providing repeat sessions. There have been simulations when all expected participants were unable to leave their clinical duties, and the scenario unfolds in a nonstandard manner. Initially, surveys were completed by approximately 25% to 30% of participants when sent electronically the day after a simulation. This has limited our ability to obtain more useful feedback for future scenarios. Currently, we are moving to paper surveys that can be placed anonymously in a box in the ICU to increase responses. Because more specific cardiac arrest algorithms are becoming used in clinical practice, it is important that team members know when and how to employ these. In situ simulation allows us to provide this for our cardiac surgery ICU team to improve understanding and utility in emergent settings in poststernotomy cardiac surgery patients. Our experience with use of in situ simulation as a tool to teach and practice an alternative cardiac life support algorithm has given us a better understanding of the importance of hands-on experience. Our learners were able to solidify their knowledge of why and how the CALS-S algorithm is a better alternative for postcardiac surgery patients. Because more patient-specific resuscitation protocols are developed and implemented, in situ simulation is a useful method of enhancing understanding and providing opportunities to experience these varied algorithms. Debriefing provides time to discuss differences from standard cardiac arrest protocols and solidify understanding of the benefits of varying practice. In situ scenarios can provide an opportunity to practice and understand new patient-specific resuscitation approaches.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gali et al. (2016) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: