Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Ostrowski's Poe Selection Jeffrey A. Savoye Carl Ostrowski, ed. Collected Tales, Poems, and Other Writings of Edgar Allan Poe. New York: Bloomsbury Academic, 2021. 405 + viii pp. $157.50 hardcover, $126 ebook. Carl Ostrowski is a professor of English at Middle Tennessee State University. He is perhaps best known for his Books, Maps and Politics: A Cultural History of the Library of Congress, 1782–1861 [Amherst: Univ. of Massachusetts Press, 2004], for which he won an Eliza Atkins Gleason Book Award in 2007. His connection to Poe as a specific subject is not deeply established, although readers of this journal may recognize him from his 2019 article "'Mere Formula––Nothing More': The Poetics of Profanity in 'Never Bet the Devil Your Head,'" Poe Studies 52 [2019]: 113–32. He has now produced an ambitious one-volume edition apparently aimed at bringing Poe to modern readers who are not already well acquainted with his writings. What are teachers and scholars to make of yet another selected collection? Poe's literary legacy rests easily on a sturdy foundation of a handful of his best-known tales and poems. Researchers have spent much effort exhuming many of his lesser-known writings and struggling to pick out which of the unsigned reviews and minor magazine fare are his or those of some other hand. Few readers, however, will stray far from the musty floorboards of "The Tell-Tale Heart," the gloomy tarn and ruins of "The Fall of the House of Usher," or Fortunato's claustrophobic tomb of "The Cask of Amontillado." Like the narrator of "The Raven," they will be content to contemplate the lost Lenore, to savor the delicious melancholy of the mournful refrain of "nevermore," and to listen to the tintinnabulation of "The Bells." With perhaps a modicum of admiration, the ten-volume set (1894–95), edited by E. C. Stedman and G. E. Woodberry, and the seventeen-volume edition (1902), assembled by James A. Harrison and his co-editors, are, to many, merely attractive decorations for the bookshelf in the living room. Even the two-volume Library of America (1984) set might mostly go unread, and the detailed apparatus of the Mabbott (1969–1978) and Pollin (1985–1997) volumes would be like ponderous chains. For such readers, a good option might well be one of the many one-volume or other small collections, with judicious selections from an array of Poe's writings, sufficient notes to point out areas of confusion, and introductory material that gives the entries some proper sense of context. [End Page E8] There is a long history to more selective editions, sometimes mixing the poems and tales, sometimes focusing on one literary form, and sometimes going a little further afield to include a few items from Poe's broader range of writings. The British Tales of Mystery and Imagination and Humour, and Poems [London: Henry Vizetelly and Clark & Beeton] appeared in 1852, heavily illustrated with woodcut engravings, in two thin "series," which were also issued bound together. A second British selection from 1852 was Tales and Sketches: to which is added The Raven: A Poem [London: George Routledge & Co.]. A host of separate editions of just the poems began appearing in 1858, and two volumes of selections from the prose tales began to appear in 1867 (eventually adding a third volume). Widdleton, the successor to Redfield and the four-volume Griswold edition, issued a single volume "Household Edition" in 1880. Most of these editions had selections of Poe's works, and a memoir, but no further apparatus. These collections were also aimed at a general audience with no particular purpose beyond the simple pleasure of reading. With the passing of years, a second effort slowly began to emerge, books that sought not merely to entertain but also to educate. Providing more guidance, in the form of summary introductions and detailed notes, would become more and more important as the audience grew further and further from Poe's own contemporary context. A few of Poe's choicest bon-bons were included in the various literary "readers" as early as the end of the U.S. Civil War, mixed with an equally superficial sampling from the vast...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jeffrey A. Savoye (2022) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: