Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The agri-food sector is globally critical for tackling climate change and environmental decline, poverty and inequity, and hunger and nutrition. Achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) will require huge increases in investment in agrifood research and innovation (ARI) (Herrero et al., 2020). Innovation is needed in policy, social institutions, finance, technology, and management practices.This Research Topic (RT) was initiated by an international Commission on Sustainable Agriculture Intensification, CoSAI (CoSAI Secretariat, 2022), created to promote more and better innovation to support rapid sustainable and equitable transformation of agrifood systems in the Global South. This collection covers three main areas that are key to decision making by research/ innovation organizations and their funders (Figure 1): ARI gaps, needs and priorities; pathways, approaches and instruments; and assessment of ARI with a sustainability lens. It brings together eight articles generated from CoSAI working papers with four from an open call. The articles are rich and the findings are often surprising. Space only allows a few points: we urge readers to consult the full articles.Rosegrant et al. estimate the ARI investment gap for the Global South at around US$10.5 billion per year, and provide a useful comparison with related estimates from other models.Global South, including broader investments in innovation as well as R&D. Despite the importance of the agrifood sector for global goals, current levels of ARI investment as a proportion of output are estimated at only two thirds of those in the energy sector. When analyzed across five domains of sustainable agricultural intensification (productivity, economics, environment, social and human; Stewart et al. 2018), less than 7% of ARI investment had discernible environmental aims, and only 4.5% had both environmental and social or 'human' (e.g., nutrition) aims, which is extremely low.The serious neglect of social and human aspects of ARI investment is also highlighted by both Porciello et al, who used machine learning to extract information on 1.2 million ARI publications, and Brown et al., who reviewed a smaller sample of highly-cited agricultural modelling publications. Brown et al. propose a framework integrating social and demographic modelling with agricultural modelling to assess ARI investments.These findings support international calls to massively increase and reorient ARI for sustainable and equitable agrifood systems, increasing funding for social equity, human and environmental aspects of ARI.management, local seed systems and (peri-)urban agriculture.Prasad et al highlight several areas of underinvestment. Two stand out:• ARI in post-production issues receives <10% of the funding for production-related ARI, although post-production accounts for the majority of food costs (Reardon et al., 2019) and is critical for food waste and the environment (Chen et al., 2020). • Innovation in self-saved and local seed systems receives <0.5% of all seed innovation funding, although these are the main sources for most small-scale farmers in the Global South (Coomes et al., 2015), and a key mechanism of in-situ agrobiodiversity conservation (FAO, 2019).Prain et al. review ARI investment priorities for Urban and Peri-Urban Agriculture (UPA) in the Global South, e.g., city-region planning, water and waste recycling and controlled-environment agriculture. With 70-80% of global food production consumed in cities (FAO, 2019) and 40% of global cropland located within 20 km of urban areas (Thebo et al., 2014), investment is much needed to develop circular economies with strong rural-urban interactions.Fuglie et al., model the multidimensional impacts of agricultural productivity growth across 110 low-and middle-income countries (LMICs). Their thought-provoking findings include:• South Asia is the region where agricultural productivity growth gives by far the highest returns in income growth, hunger reduction, and reductions in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.• Increasing cereal productivity results in greater increases in diet micronutrient availability (zinc, iron and protein) than investments in other crops.• Productivity growth in livestock reduces GHG emissions per unit product, but conversely increases the risk of hunger and overall land use.Finally, Stads and Nin Pratt model factors affecting investment in ARI in different types of countries, especially highlighting the challenges faced by small LMICs. In a wide-ranging and thoughtful discussion, they suggest that small LMICs may benefit from investing in ARI capacity development and ruthless prioritization of research topics, along with stronger international linkages.Letty et al. review the main instruments that have been used to incentivize and support ARI in the Global South, such as innovation platforms and networks, grants, prizes, incubators and accelerators.They find that despite their potential, most of these instruments are still used in projects, and not at scale. More rigorous evaluations are needed, which should document important aspects such as social equity, financial and transaction costs.ARI success is often judged by the success of "scaling", or wide adoption by potential users. A variety of theories and tools for scaling success have been advanced (Dror and Wu, 2020), Table 1), and there is a global community of practice1 and at least one sourcebook (Cooley and Howard, 2019). Kohl contributes to this literature by assessing six common hypotheses on 'scaling success' factors against 15 case studies from seven countries. Among many interesting points are:-The importance of individual leadership. This has gained new importance with the need for leadership to attain sustainability/equity goals alongside scaling (Lukwago et al., 2022;Boeske, 2023). -The importance of a long-term portfolio approach, where a few big ARI successes more than compensate for many failures. Short-term project targets set by ARI funders can unintentionally undermine long-term portfolio success. (Mottet et al., 2020); the sustainable intensification assessment framework (Stewart et al., 2018) or sustainability indicators (e.g., the UN SDGs). Transparent global tracking of ARI is also important, in part to increase incentives and pressure on funders (Prasad et al, Compton et al., 2022;FAO, 2022). Modelling, which underpins many decisions, must be "transparent and humble" (Saltelli et al., 2020;Wiebe and Prager, 2021). Finally, the Research Topic highlights major evidence gaps that persist around social equity and human aspects of ARI, and around instruments for ARI, as above (CoSAI, 2021), Letty et al.).The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Compton et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: