Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Transtheoretical Model (TTM) has for some time now enjoyed fame (or even notoriety). Indeed, Health Education Research has been pleased to publish a number of articles over recent years. We were especially pleased to publish Adams and White's (Adams and White, 2004) interesting and arguably heretical paper which appears in this edition of the Journal (and was published in advance on our website). We felt this would be an excellent opportunity to repeat our recent venture in which we invited a Commentary Group of distinguished researchers to react to three articles on the European Smoking Prevention Framework Approach in Health Education Research, 18(6), 664–677 (2003). Accordingly, we invited six equally distinguished commentators to provide a critical review of the TTM. We are very grateful to these six colleagues for their efforts—and, of course, we thank Jean Adams and Martin White for not only agreeing to their paper being subjected to critical scrutiny, but actively encouraging debate on a subject that is partly technical and partly ideological! Keith Tones Executive Editor Johannes Brug, Department of Public Health, Erasmus University Medical Centre Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands Stef Kremers, Department of Health Education and Promotion, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands E-mail: j.brug@erasmusmc.nl Adams and White present three main reasons why stages of change may not be applicable to physical activity: the complexity of physical activity, the lack of validated staging algorithms and the possibility that the real determinants of activity change are not included in the Transtheoretical Model (TTM). Applying stages of change to complex health behaviors such as physical activity and diet is indeed beset by difficulties. Physical activity as such is not a single behavior, but a complex category of different specific actions, such as transport behaviors, work-related physical activities, home-making activities, gardening and other leisure-time activities, including sports. As Adams and White (Adams and White, 2004) argue, people may perceive very different pros, cons and hold different self-efficacy beliefs for something like going to work by bike in the morning than for working out at the gym at night. People may thus also be in different stages of change for the various specific behaviors that are often included in ‘physical activity’. Additionally, this multidimensionality of physical activity may also lead to misconceptions about one's own performance. Some of our own studies have shown that many people think of themselves as complying with recommendations for complex behaviors such as low fat intake, fruit and vegetable consumption [e.g. (Lechner et al., 1998; Bogers et al., 2004)], as well as physical activity (Ronda et al., 2001; Kremers and Brug, 2004), while their actual behavioral patterns are not in line with the recommendations. Since staging algorithms are usually based on self-assessment, these people are then regarded as being in the maintenance stage, while in fact their actions are not in line with recommended activity levels and they show no motivation to change. Such people should therefore be regarded as precontemplators (Greene et al., 1999). Lechner and colleagues have argued that it might therefore be useful to distinguish between aware precontemplators (people who know they are too inactive and do not intend to change) and unaware precontemplators (people who do not know that they are too inactive and therefore experience no need to change) (Lechner et al., 1998). Further distinctions within the precontemplation stage have also been proposed for other health behaviors such as smoking (Dijkstra et al., 1997; Norman et al., 2000; Kremers et al., 2001). Adams and White restrict their evaluation of stages of change in activity promotion to the TTM stages of change concept. Although this is the best-known and most widely applied stages of change construct, there are other stage models that may be more appropriate since they at least take the issue of optimism in self-assessed physical activity levels into account [such as the Precaution Adoption Process phases proposed by Weinstein (Weinstein et al., 1998)]. Various algorithms are used to allocate people to the TTM stages of change. Since there is no ‘gold standard’ with which to compare different staging algorithms, the validity of these measures has not been established, and many researchers seem to feel free to adapt and change existing algorithms when they are not comfortable with the original measure. Indeed, current staging algorithms may lack validity and reliability. Recently, we conducted two studies to investigate stage stability over time for dietary behaviors in people who were not exposed to a behavior change intervention. Both studies showed that stage transitions were common, especially among people in contemplation and preparation, even within as short a time interval as 3 days (de Nooijer et al., 2005b; de Vet et al., 2005). Such stage instabilities can of course reflect true stage transitions, but may also indicate low test–re-test reliability of the staging algorithm. A non-reliable staging tool and true stage instability will both result in mismatching of stage-based interventions. Most of the staging algorithms are solely based on self-assessed behavior and motivation: respondents are asked whether they think that they are complying with a recommended activity level (action) and, if so, whether they have done so for a longer period of time (maintenance). If not, they are asked whether they intend to change to a more active lifestyle in the longer run (contemplation) or in the short term (preparation). People who think they do not comply with the recommended level of activity and are not motivated to change are allocated to the precontemplation stage. One of the main problems with this approach is the aforementioned issue of misconception of personal levels of activity. Greene and colleagues, as well as others, have argued that for complex health behaviors a more objective assessment of behavior should be included in the algorithm (Greene et al., 1999; Ronda et al., 2001). Since measuring the usual physical activity patterns is difficult, as well as a potential burden on the respondents, including such more objective behavior assessments makes stage allocation much harder. The stages of change approach then loses much of its attractiveness as an easy way to distinguish different target groups for interventions. However, such a more objective and thus comprehensive measurement of behavior can and has been applied in individually tailored interventions (Kreuter and Skinner, 2000). There are new and promising developments in the field of adapting the staging algorithms that are currently in use. Godin et al. (Godin et al., 2004), for example, showed that a staging algorithm for physical activity, based on a 2 × 2 matrix of intention and recent past behavior, outperformed the TTM stages of change algorithm in terms of cross-sectional differences between stages in attitudes and perceived behavioral control. Adams and White restrict their view to the stages of change proposed in the TTM. This model posits that decisional balance, self-efficacy and of change are the most stage The for the of these is based on cross-sectional and more based on or is 2000; de Vet et al., 2005). interventions that are indeed about and stage determinants can be behavior change that is not solely based on determinants by the TTM. example, studies have that behavior in of personal behavior and a intention to change (de and Brug, 2000; et al., 2001; et al., in line with stages of change as proposed in the Precaution Adoption Process Model (Weinstein et al., 1998). and and proposed that different self-efficacy are for transitions to motivation (contemplation) and intention that specific may people to their into health 1999). and models of health behavior change that interventions may to motivation to but that for behavior are to people to 1999; et al., Adams and White their paper with a of they as the lack of for the of activity promotion interventions. main are that interventions are not to interventions in behavior change. However, they do that interventions to be more to behavior and to in motivation and other potential of change. for physical activity promotion to have a health the should be and most activity promotion interventions do not show activity promotion like most interventions are interventions and are to One such whether or interventions are to lead to Physical activity have been over a period of time and longer as well as more comprehensive interventions that as well as are to such more 1999; et al., However, behavior change that at least behavior change should be change is an not for change to if interventions are to behavior change than this is in of stage Adams and White that interventions may stage this is not by actual behavior change. Although stage may indeed not lead to a change in behavior, motivation or within the stages of it is an not for behavior change. showed that lack of intention to lack of behavior, while a intention is no for stage within stages of change is to the of in terms of the evaluation of health promotion stage within the stages of change can be as an of 1998). activity promotion interventions are more to in motivation as well as behavior change that interventions that to motivation and self-assessed behavior are to that do not take these into not the validity of stages of for example, more stages or a more lack of motivation to 2000). health interventions that stage which are to as tailored interventions (Kreuter and Skinner, may be to in complex behaviors than stage since such interventions provide people with and that their behavior, perceived and and self-efficacy beliefs et al., Adams and White are to that the validity of the TTM has not been for complex health behaviors and that the of the TTM stages of change in physical activity promotion with of There is no on the way to allocate people to stages of change and the for the determinants proposed by TTM is not very activity promotion interventions are more to in motivation as well as behavior This to the stages of change construct, to potential to and determinants (de Vet et al., 2004), and to and interventions that target these determinants (Weinstein et al., 1998). physical activity promotion interventions that may need to health change to for physical activity. of University of E-mail: One of the stage models was by and and in their TTM. model has been widely applied to the of change in a of including physical activity recent et al. et al., stages of preparation, and are to stage to maintenance of a new the of smoking it is argued that in the precontemplation stage the is unaware that behavior a and has no intention to the contemplation stage, the to think about behavior, but is not to to the stage, the has an intention to and to about to The stage is by active to and of the into the maintenance stage by to and to the There are a number of other to the such as the of but these are not on is that there are a number of other stage models and for a they have to be widely applied than the TTM. other stage models the Health Process Approach the Precaution Adoption Process Model and the Model of There are two to these stage they a with different stages of behavior change. the models different of they the a precontemplation stage a motivation stage to the and maintenance of The is that these models are in people stage to over these stage models that different are at different stages and so can for interventions and example, in the stages may be about the and of a behavior, while in the stages more on the of of to and the maintenance of a This is to with the of an intention and only when the level of motivation or intention a level is the to be to on to Some that the between a and stage is the of stage models and 2000). This the for a number of stage-based interventions which to behavior change in different stages with different interventions. models such as the TTM have been widely the in of stage models and the different stages distinguished is at present (Weinstein et al., 1998; et al., Such can take a of such as that of patterns the stages in change in to such as the of to interventions. behavioral the the TTM to as the and 2000; 2005). Adams and White (Adams and White, 2004) on evaluation of interventions for physical activity This is of the most for into the both it a of the model and it of the of the TTM that a will behavior interventions are as than (or interventions term by (Adams and White, This has been by and (Kreuter and Skinner, 2000). the interventions are regarded as that have been a that into account by the and Skinner, tailored interventions are to specific based on to that an and Skinner, This is while of the of interventions may have some in of such has or no to of tailored interventions. The by Adams and White (Adams and White, 2004) that stage-based interventions for physical activity were more than in between et al., and (Adams and White, of However, this to in the studies behavior change for of than (Adams and White, This only that interventions are more in physical activity change and even in to physical activity change. As such is also than a of and that appears to be in this The in to physical activity change appears to that in other to for the TTM. Adams and White (Adams and White, 2004) reasons why stage-based interventions to physical activity may not reasons are at a level and more specific reasons may to the of specific interventions [e.g. to change and A may be the validity of the stages in the TTM. Adams and White (Adams and White, 2004) the problems in into stages based on existing This may in be to the validity of the stages the TTM the stages are distinguished based on or to whether behavior has been and of time the behavior is The is used to distinguish and but is stage models distinguish different of stages or different Most models on the of whether behavior has been or and and that this is in a between and maintenance of a behavior is to distinguish the two an issue of debate 2000). The of into stage as by Adams and White (Adams and White, 2004) may be of a more of the validity of the stages in the TTM. Department of University of E-mail: their Adams and White There to that stage-based activity promotion which have been to are not more than in to activity The they that this may be but is this The stage-based interventions to physical activity that they to more active or working with on to physical activity into their think it is to be about we can interventions of this We are exposed to that to in Health promotion interventions are such health promotion like on over a single period of time to people as they would like People have to be and most of of why they should do think is for interventions may their of people to a new in physical activity into their However, as the active of the into the other may their and the an has A to change is not a on the of the as is also out by and Kremers in their it the need for to a of and to The of by Adams and White indicate that there are within our and which not to be individually based can be to the of these on most people for Adams and White that like stage-based change interventions be when they the stage-based interventions to physical activity that behavior is by not by the this as a for the model than as have that this the need to for if are TTM as of a comprehensive to physical activity. if we our in line with we can do interventions the TTM show on the by Adams and White's (Adams and White, they as most of the interventions they were in the of physical activity in the short The issue would like to take the between and One of the that Adams and White of the TTM is that model stage is a but this is not with behavior also that TTM that the that stage will lead to behavior change in the The between attitudes and their behavior is an issue that has and health promotion for many is the that a more a behavior not lead to its [e.g. and However, it is also the that behavior is a of their about themselves and the for of the of people who are active will have an that is to the maintenance of this or not it is for of interventions the TTM to and that these are of on a number of the model the that physical activity. whether there are of physical activity. whether or at least in to in the stages by the TTM. a of the TTM published in this Journal in et al. et al., a number of that there are problems with the TTM as a model of and behavior change. they to studies that the of stages and there is for the its the complex and of and that people and the that their activities, a model which to with a of that a behavior is going to be A model which also people a of stages to at these is going to be the TTM is when applied to physical activity as behavior is not is out by Adams and do if is something like smoking might be as or to show to or as a is that behaviors are as complex and as the that or not the TTM is so that it should be as a for physical activity interventions is very to Adams and White to it by an by which the validity of stage and the about to people stage to the be as have their review (Adams and White, that interventions can result in in physical activity. we should be more on to the TTM that is of to than whether it the the to in and then physical activity. Although it and when it to the there is something about it that at least for some people some of the Department of University of E-mail: possibility proposed by Adams and White the lack of an for to the appropriate this which is to of the model and its has also been by other commentators [e.g. et al., et al., et al., However, than the of the by Adams and White to why stage-based interventions to physical activity do not the more might why would we think that they should The TTM has been the subject of a of et al. out the of much of the for the model and about the among some to the of the model on et al., 2000). has also the lack of for the of the model and has that of the are not stages but on a is the that the model The two precontemplation and differences in while the stages reflect in the or of the these stages are based on than true differences and the model to the that between some stages and can be by the of time 1997; 2001). a of the out on the TTM has been cross-sectional in the stages of such as decisional and Although differences in these between stages have been such cross-sectional work not the of these in whether stages or whether there is an of the in this has at in terms of in the of many commentators the of interventions has not been with to the most and people in different stages different critical have been et al., while the to an of et al. out a recent review of the to the of the TTM to lifestyle behavior and that there was only for the of stage-based lifestyle interventions et al., behaviors such as physical activity and diet are the the TTM be to be behaviors such as the target of behavior change is very easy to when the behavior is or the is much more to and to on the of the change. as it may be to the in behavior the for the of interventions not seem to have been of the the TTM has over more than two many commentators would with that is too and to be into a University of E-mail: of these not a TTM working in a for in The model and useful to with been as The need for to with in the of of an provide the model to the as the current the model to within a level in behavior change and was by the it it to have an a review of the model on of the Health Education for by the and Education for that two published et al., 2000; et al., 2000). This work many of the physical activity specific by Adams and White, the of the of and the of in the of the As this a objective of and to the have with most of and White's However, feel that a issue is the of the paper Adams and White to a way out of their they is whether to have to and a then for a of the of the model stage specific is in the target this proposed way at the of are at this in time to the of the model and the of we is and as such do we and to its in a approach to evaluation based on the of a Adams and White to be a approach (and that is in to their critical that this is for both and based on the of the current there is to that going this will of the that Adams and White so the most of the TTM a of and is a it now to that we have an a working within specific groups and and critical with the model or about or a level TTM is not a true stage and it is and et evaluation of the that it no on smoking among et al., but these at a technical level on the that an was applied to people by in the smoking of and with and that it shown to the of the that the is more than they et al. et al., in their review for the Health for the of stage based but the within et review et al., in think that the with the model by many in the TTM field (and by Adams and then in the of to TTM is in that it that TTM is a TTM and can only be on the of a and However, there is to that such within TTM. be the of complexity of many to validity the of about the of and of the between stages and this in Commentary would we think that they based should has a the of is there can be a single true account of TTM which work can be if TTM is not a then is that than existing as a in TTM should be as a more in a and this the of and stages in TTM as a of are of our with the the current with and is a of that is by various in and 2001). the of has been and into various of of the that in stages is and in to many and and has even been in the most of our The when has only to a at be argued that TTM and the various other stage-based models that other have and is to or and behavioral in the of a or this the of and stages of change are or at potential of change. the of these it is that they should be As the and stage based of TTM can be However, their specific a is can to The is not The is that out of it we this of into specific TTM be as a of of an into a This to is to the and by the TTM be as and it should not be as the only of a of and behavioral Various other equally be as in of and and of or Health the of a Health the that both and as by and of and in and, the of change as a between two 1998). to TTM is not the of a or but the of a and or this a number of the and of the review of the model to do so with a a at a TTM the experience to and on to the terms and to and this to a and be in a not to to in with critical example, at a for the work in in the of and researchers were to some of the to to critical We would have and potential but such was the of the that we were with the that been was a than a TTM is actively as of a and for the of there are specific based health these are of the and levels of and with their is based on the need to change behavior, other have been in out this TTM has been shown to be and that this is in a of This has to a more active of the model as a for a of health problems and an with who the in the The 1999). The included an with on the model by a of a as well as an account of a smoking in a of of the of are with the of the of behavior and the and by in the who have TTM have the model within a smoking are to be health and are as a with this Adams and White's paper is in a number of the level of it other recent as a to have perceived as a or to actively TTM as the or more a a level it also the of TTM in the of the complexity of physical activity of Adams and White for these in a assessment of TTM with commentators the of other stage-based models or staging algorithms that are at stage by and is way of However, not of the of this would that we appears to to be the in the of the model and of whether TTM or not, and to in a more that the a more of the is that not only in but also an of the and that have to the of the of the an of the various by which the interventions are or including as and Kremers in their a of activity to other of a comprehensive and as has in a within a of on the of we can in of themselves interventions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Johannes Brug (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: