Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
It has been called a "monopoly," a "swamp," a "Leviathan," and even "the Bermuda Triangle."'The culprit: the Supreme Court's cert pool, the system of randomly assigning petitions for review to a single clerk for a recommendation regarding acceptance or denial of a case.Former Supreme Court clerk and solicitor general, Kenneth Starr, recently lamented that Supreme Court justices have abdicated their responsibility in screening cases for review and have ceded too much power to their clerks; cases worthy of the justices attention go into the cert pool, but they never come out.According to Starr, the cert pool "is at war with Justice Louis Brandeis' proud proclamation that the justices, unlike high government officials from the other branches, do their own work."Moreover, the cert pool "squander[ s] a precious national resource-the time and energy of the justices themselves."Others agree that the cert pool is a "very dangerous proposition." 2 In 1998, USA Today conducted a five month study on the "effect and growing influence of law clerks," with several stories devoted to the influence of the cert pool. 3 In ad-
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Barbara Palmer (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: