Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
www.PRSJournal.com 275 P surgeons expend great effort at improving the public’s knowledge of our specialty, as demonstrated by the #DoYourHomework campaign of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, which aims to correct misconceptions of the rigor of our training, the breadth and depth of our specialty, and the improved quality of our patients’ lives. Our own sterling, hard-won board certification is often confused with those of other boards not recognized by the American Board of Medical Specialties. Having an accurate understanding of what a board-certified plastic surgeon is and does can be crucial to a patient’s safety.1 To measure the public’s perception of plastic surgery in objective terms, Kalandar et al. turned to Twitter and analyzed a selection of tweets containing the keyword or hashtag #PlasticSurgery.2 The tweets were randomly chosen from August 1, 2014, to December 30, 2016. The authors categorized the public’s perceptions and attitudes toward plastic surgery by breaking down the tweets by author, specialty, topic, content, information accuracy, source, retweet rate, emotion, and tone.2 Citing the bias of surveys, including those demonstrating the public’s association of plastic surgery with cosmetic surgery, the authors turned to Twitter to study the public’s attitudes. Their study did not investigate other popular social media apps,3 although Facebook has over 2 billion users,4 Instagram has 800 million,5 and Twitter has just 330 million.6 As with any study, an analysis is only as good as its data, and, unfortunately, 15 percent of Twitter users are suspected of being bots and fake accounts.7,8 Through personal communication, I know of two fake accounts that fraudulently assumed the identities, photographs, and biographies of plastic surgeons, both in positions of leadership. Even Twitter’s retweet rate is unreliable, because bots can be programmed to automatically retweet any post a user tweets9 or any post that contains a particular keyword or hashtag, such as #PlasticSurgery.10 A single individual can open up and control multiple accounts under discrete names and hidden identities, allowing actions that appear to be from many users to actually be generated by only one. Because Twitter is so widely gamed,11–13 it is associated with misinformation and disinformation and is thus a treacherous medium to use for a scientific study.14,15 To rate its accuracy, the authors ranked a post’s information according to its source, with the “most accurate” rank assigned to peer-reviewed journals and medical societies and a “low accuracy” rank assigned to blogs and medical spas. Although this categorization may be generally reliable, it overlooks the inaccessibility of peer-reviewed journal articles to the nonsubscribing public and the many accurate blogs written by plastic surgeons to communicate procedure and patient safety information in lay language. The content of an article, rather than the type of source, would be the best indication of accuracy. The authors state that the public wants fewer posts about celebrity plastic surgery and more about education and patient safety by board-certified plastic surgeons, citing the article by Branford et al.16 However, that finding was based on Twitter polls that did not distinguish answers by plastic surgeons from answers by the lay public. The response rate, as defined by the number of responses received divided by the total number of times the poll was seen (“impressions”), was unknown, as was the proportion of plastic surgeons answering. In fact, a study that surveyed actual aesthetic plastic surgery patients3 found that articles about plastic surgery were the least popular types of social media posts, with 79 percent of respondents not interested in posts of scientific articles available for a fee (i.e., peer-reviewed journal articles). Moreover, scientific articles may be difficult for the lay person to understand.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Heather Furnas (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: