Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The articles collected in this themed issue present varied methodological approaches to the identification of oral traces in written texts situated widely both in space, from northern Europe to East Asia, and in time, from the eighteenth century BC to the seventeenth century AD.Several of the articles are explicitly comparative in approach, whilst others offer insights into prevalent modes of thinking about orality in different specialisms, which may be applied fruitfully to other cultures and text corpora.Working from their diverse perspectives, the contributions challenge a tenacious separation in scholarship between orality and literacy.The authors highlight that oral and literary phases of composition, transmission, and reception of literary texts were to a considerable extent intertwined in many cultures that developed largely independently of one another.This themed issue situates itself beyond overly simplistic, rigid, and essentialist divides between orality and literacy.To various extents, a conceptual dichotomy between 'oral' and 'written' dimensions continues to permeate the research discourse about several premodern literary cultures, despite mounting evidence and growing theoretical awareness to the contrary: that these domains coexisted and interacted in many, often systematic ways becomes ever clearer.The divides that have shaped past discourse are underpinned by largely undeclared axiologies.Writing, particularly in alphabetic scripts, has often
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ballesteros et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: