Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
After surviving the severe acute respiratory syndrome epidemic of 2003, the H1N1 influenza pandemic of 2009 and the Middle Eastern respiratory syndrome scare of 2015, Hong Kong is now grappling with a renewed surge of the 2019 novel coronavirus disease (COVID-19). For emergency medicine physicians, nurses and allied health practitioners, it has been a roller coaster of anxiety, frustration, hope, relief and wariness since the first diagnosed cases in Hong Kong in January 2020. Over the past half year, the territory has undergone a series of tightening and loosening infection control actions, including compulsory quarantine measures, social distancing requirements and the shutdown of face-to-face teaching and learning for schools at all levels. Towards the end of May 2020, these measures looked successful – only to hit a third wave of infections in July 2020. In this report, we investigate the impact this disease has had on ED attendance in Hong Kong during the first 6 months (January 1 to June 30) of 2020. The 18 public hospital EDs of Hong Kong escalated their response level from ‘alert’ to ‘serious’ on January 4,1 followed by ‘emergency’ (the highest of the three tiers) after two cases of COVID-19 (high-speed train passengers from Wuhan) were confirmed on January 25.2 The memory of severe acute respiratory syndrome3 and H1N1 shaped institutional and personal responses to the new COVID-19 threat particularly for our medical facility, Prince of Wales Hospital, which is located in the Hong Kong New Territories and the closest tertiary care hospital to the border with mainland China.4 During the H1N1 outbreak of 2009, the ED was virtually overrun with patients seeking testing. ED staff across Hong Kong were naturally apprehensive about a surge of COVID-19 patients. The situation that materialised in Hong Kong was unexpected. Although we braced for an influx of patients and set up outdoor receiving tents, EDs across the territory saw patient attendance plummet instead of rise (see Table 1). ED attendance at Prince of Wales Hospital was down 24.4% for the 6 months from January 1 through June 30, year-on-year, and down 28.0% across the 18 public hospital EDs of Hong Kong. Patient attendance was even less if we look at the critical period covering the first and second surges (between the activation of the emergency alert on January 25 and the relaxation of social distancing measures and reopening of schools in May). Thirty-seven percent fewer patients (333 264 vs 528 764) presented to an ED in Hong Kong between February 1 and April 30. Even these numbers do not fully capture the decrease in overall ED crowding. The ‘emergency’ response level bans all hospital visitors. Since ED patients in Hong Kong are generally accompanied by one or more family members, ED crowding decreased exponentially. Other consulting services (e.g. physiotherapy) also cut back their in-person ED consultation services, and medical student clinical rotations were suspended. Not only were there nearly 40% fewer patients, but the overall number of people in the ED was far less. This does raise several public health questions. Is there a way to align patient flow more effectively with ED capacity in times of pandemic? A blanket emergency response level may not be nuanced enough. Were patients facing acute medical emergencies (cardiac arrest, stroke, falls, traffic crashes) able to access care? Were there significantly fewer medical emergencies? Or are up to 40% of our typical patients not emergency cases? What conditions warrant visits to the ED despite the pandemic? Further research is needed to understand the motivations and behaviour of the Hong Kong ED patient population and to align public needs more effectively with ED capacity in the future. The present study was approved by the Joint Chinese University of Hong Kong – New Territories East Cluster Clinical Research Ethics Committee (reference #2020.212). JHW conceived of the study and obtained ethics approval. AMYL and KKCH acquired the data. JHW, PS and CAG drafted the initial manuscript. All authors were involved in editing the final manuscript and have approved the submission. None declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Walline et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: