Why the study?
What is the utility of the traditional pre-participation examination for young athletes?
What is the utility of the traditional pre-participation examination for young athletes?
This review highlights the lack of rigorous evidence supporting many traditional components of the pre-participation physical examination for young athletes.
Should not change pre-participation exam practices; leaves open utility of newer orthopedic maneuvers pending validation.
Examination of published reports and expert recommendations about appropriate pre-participation examinations of young athletes reveals widespread disagreement about objectives, format, and content. This review and commentary examines current evidence and proposes a more modest routine athletic physical. Even without requiring evidence of careful science and methodologic rigor, few of the traditional parts of the physical for the athlete are found to have evidence of utility. Some newly suggested orthopedic maneuvers may ultimately prove useful. Definitive recommendations await evaluation, using appropriate and careful methodology.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Desmond K. Runyan (1983) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 4 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: