Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reviewed by: The Black Middle Ages: Race and the Construction of the Middle Ages by Matthew X. Vernon Jenna Mead Vernon, Matthew X., The Black Middle Ages: Race and the Construction of the Middle Ages (The New Middle Ages), Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan, 2018; hardback; pp. xiii, 266; R.R.P. US $74.99; ISBN 9783319910888. Matthew Vernon's book investigates the connexions between medievalism, racial identity, and the struggle of African American literature to articulate a sense of belonging that speaks to the lived experience and desires of its writers and readers. His book comprises a set of nuanced and ambitious arguments, derived from intense scholarly engagements; a short review in no way does justice to its scope or, especially, its stakes. Readers should not be deterred by the title with its big-ticket buzzwords and overweening reach. Vernon is an unflinching analyst and a judicious interlocutor. This is also a much bigger book than it appears to be and each chapter deserves a more spacious exposition. Vernon's study begins by pointing to the innovation it makes in drawing together medieval and African American studies. What can these two fields have to say to each other? In response, the book draws on traditional literary history, the political analysis of national formation, sociologies of reading, institutional histories, and theoretical meditation held together by forensic close reading. These critical modalities are mobilized for a heterogeneous set of written and experiential texts. The opening chapter excavates the genealogy of American claims to medieval heritage beginning with Thomas Jefferson's rapturous embrace of adventus Saxonum, through the politics of recovery after the Civil War to the development of American exceptionalism and, as Vernon argues, the necessary subjugation of 'the Negro' to establish white supremacy. Subverting this construction of the nation, Vernon positions the works of Frederick Douglass, W. E. B. Dubois, and a struggle over conceptualizing the past not as irretrievable but as a repository of medievalisms to contest the narratives of white hegemony through relationships of 'surrogated kinship' (p. 29). Chapter 2 surveys debates initiated by African American intellectuals, published in and circulated by The African-American Magazine (1859–62) and, later, the African Methodist Episcopal Church Review (AME Church Review). This lateral move into non-fictional texts, media discourse, and intellectual formations allows Vernon to explicate the cultural institutions that supported the project of building a powerful and public presence by making African American history and experience visible in the medievalism of the national narrative. Chapter 3 is a devastating account of the failure of the genre of romance to deliver as an historical form, as a social allegory, or as a visionary future. Reacting to the pernicious popularity of Walter Scott's Ivanhoe as a history of race, Vernon reads Mark Twain's conflicted desire to expose the vileness of racism against Twain's own failure of nerve to name its specificities, such as lynching in A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court. Charles Chesnutt's The House Behind the Cedars, also referencing Ivanhoe, emerges as a 'deviant romance' [End Page 294] (p. 132) and makes for hard reading: its narrative driver of miscegenation still provokes both pathos and shock. 'History, Genealogy, and Gerald of Wales: Medieval Theories of Ethnicity and their Afterlives' (Chapter 4) is another lateral move. Taking his lead from Paul Gilroy, Vernon develops a shrewd meditation on the category of ethnicity that is foundational in the history of race theory, again exposing conflicted anxieties clandestine in the text—this time Gerald of Wales on the history of the Irish—and thus dismantling rightful claims to racial subjugation. Chapter 5 returns to literary texts—Dryden, Dante, Chaucer, and Gloria Naylor—to elaborate an idea of the vernacular that has resonated through preceding chapters. Vernon immediately sees the potency of a vernacular allied with translation in Naylor's enlisting of Dante and Chaucer. He follows her determination 'to refute the dominant narrative of literary genealogy and to make the larger political argument about the existence of a pluralistic, polyvocal community' (p. 215). But he also calibrates Naylor's revolutionary translatio studii by putting it into dialogue with Henry Louis Gates Jr and Langston Hughes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
J Mead (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: