Why the study?
Does doctor-measured blood pressure differ from nurse-measured blood pressure?
Does doctor-measured blood pressure differ from nurse-measured blood pressure?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Doctor-measured blood pressure is systematically higher than nurse-measured blood pressure, likely due to a greater white coat effect, which has implications for hypertension management.
Blood pressure measured by a professional in clinic surroundings is systematically different from the same measurement undertaken in different settings and has worse prognostic accuracy for cardiovascular events.1 Current knowledge on the impact of setting, presence of a professional, accuracy of measurement devices, and technique could, if translated into practice transform the provision and potentially the effectiveness of blood pressure management, as illustrated by the findings of Clark and colleagues’ systematic review concerning nurse- and doctor-measured blood pressure.2 Several studies have reported a systematic difference between doctor- and nurse-obtained blood pressures, and Clark and colleagues have now provided an authoritative quantification of the effect.2 The authors drew on studies from 10 countries, across primary and secondary care, and all but one of 14 studies included found a difference, the pooled effect size being that nurse-measured blood pressure is 7/4 mmHg lower. It is assumed that these differences are due to doctors eliciting a greater ‘white coat effect’ — that is, an ‘alert reaction’ (similar to fight–flight response) on blood pressure measurement — than nurses. Interpretation of Clark and colleagues’ results requires careful checking of the methodology in the underlying studies; in particular, repeating measurement can have a large effect: an average 14 mmHg systolic drop on repeated measurement over 12 minutes in one recent study; hence if two people measure, the order in which this is done is important.3 Only one-third of included studies randomised the order of measurement, potentially biasing results. Similarly the population chosen can influence the white coat effect: it …
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A’Court et al. (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: