Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
QUESTION: I would appreciate guidance on using the AMA Guides, Sixth Edition, to rate a multilevel cervical fusion (C4-C7). Reported indications for the fusion were chronic cervical spine pain, severe degenerative disk disease, and transient improvement with a variety of spinal injections. The patient had no radicular complaints or findings. There was no pre-operative psychological assessment, but the patient has chronic depression. In addition to continued neck pain, she complains of headaches, the etiology of which is ill defined. While the cervical fusion meets the definition of alteration of motion segment integrity (AOMSI) per Table 17-2 (6th ed, 564), it appears that there is no ratable impairment since there are no radicular symptoms or signs. Should I rate the three-level fusion and resultant AOMSI as class 1, despite the lack of past radiculopathy or even nonverifiable radicular complaints, with a default of 6% whole person permanent impairment (WPI)? Or, should I rate her for nonspecific chronic or chronic recurrent neck pain as class 1, with a default of 2% WPI?ANSWER: The AMA Guides, Sixth Edition, approach to impairment evaluation is based on Section 17.2, Diagnosis-Based Impairment (6th ed, 560), and Section 17.2a, Cervical Spine (6th ed, 563). It can be challenging to rate an individual who has had a cervical fusion, particularly if the fusion is multilevel, when there have been no or questionable radicular symptoms or findings. Although patients sometimes undergo spinal surgery including fusion for primarily or exclusively axial neck or back pain, and there may be degenerative disease, it is often unclear whether this is the basis for their complaint. Surgical outcomes in these settings may be suboptimal.Table 17-2, Cervical Spine Regional Grid (6th ed, 564), provides ratings for spinal fusions in the category “Motion Segment Lesions” and diagnosis of “intervertebral disc herniation and/or AOMSI (alteration of motion segment integrity).” Not only do classes 2 through 4 require intervertebral disk herniation(s) or documented AOMSI, they also require radiculopathy at the time of examination. The rating is not affected by the performance of surgery.If there are “imaging findings of intervertebral disk herniation without a history of clinically correlating radicular symptoms,” the assignment is class 0. A class 1 rating for “intervertebral disc herniation(s) or documented AOMSI at a single level with medically documented findings; with or without surgery and for disk herniation(s) with documented resolved radiculopathy or non-verifiable radicular complaints at the clinically appropriate level(s) present at the time of examination” results in a default rating of 6% WPI.Footnote “a” in Table 17-2 refers the reader to page 571 where there is a requirement that consistent, objective findings of radiculopathy must be present either when most symptomatic (from medical records) or must be currently present when being rated. This footnote does not apply to AOMSI. Similarly, in the third column of this row (disk herniation and/or AOMSI), a rating of class 1 requires “for disk herniation(s)” either previously objectively documented radiculopathy that now has resolved or persisting non-verifiable radicular complaints at the time of evaluation. This requirement is again not stated for AOMSI.The definitions of AOMSI include spinal instability (pp. 577–579) and loss of motion (ankylosis), which is defined on page 563 (right column, second paragraph). This definition includes “fusion, regardless of cause.” In the far left row of Table 17-2, the definition of AOMSI includes “arthrodesis” (fusion). Thus, even though the failure to improve after surgery without identified complications suggests the fusion did not address the cause of the patient's pain, having had a three-level fusion would qualify for a class 1 rating given the AOMSI.A rating could be made using the row above titled “soft tissue and non-specific conditions” for the diagnosis of “non-specific chronic, or chronic recurrent neck pain” (also known as chronic sprain/strain, symptomatic degenerative disc disease, facet joint pain, chronic whiplash, etc.). With a “documented history of sprain/strain-type injury with continued complaints of axial and/or nonverifiable radicular complaints; similar findings documented on multiple occasion,” the placement is class 1 with a default of 2% WPI. However, principle 12 in Table 2-1 (p. 20) states, “If the Guides provides more than one method to rate a particular impairment or condition, the method producing the higher rating must be used.” Hence, this case should be rated based on the AOMSI and not the nonspecific neck pain.The rater would determine the functional history and the physical exam grade modifiers and use the net adjustment formula to derive the final class 1 rating. As noted on page 563, “If a diagnosis of AOMSI…is made, imaging studies should be excluded as a grade modifier.” Thus, the grade modifier clinical studies would be either inapplicable or based solely on needle electromyography (EMG) evidence of the presence or absence of radiculopathy.If rated using the AMA Guides, Fifth Edition, the range of motion method would be used since there is multilevel involvement. Per Table 15-7, Criteria for Rating Whole Person Impairment Percent Due to Specific Spine Disorders to be Used as Part of the ROM Method (5th ed, 404), your patient would receive per IIE, Surgically treated disk lesion with residual, medically documented pain and rigidity, 9% WPI with additional 2% WPI for the two additional levels, ie, 11% WPI. This would be combined with range of motion deficits. Per the AMA Guides, Fourth Edition, your patient would likely be assigned to Category II, Diagnosis Related Estimates Cervicothoracic, and be assigned 5% WPI.Chapter 13 in the AMA Guides, Sixth Edition, The Central and Peripheral Nervous System, Section 13.11, Criteria for Rating Impairments Related to Craniocephalic Pain, provides a basis for rating migraine headaches. However, to do so, “the physician should determine that migraine headaches have been diagnosed as accurately as possible using well-accepted criteria, that the patient has had a suitable therapeutic trial of appropriate treatment, and that the patient has reached a relative plateau in terms of migraine severity and frequency” (6th ed, 342). However “nonmigrainous headaches are not ratable using the AMA Guides.” Unless there is factual evidence to scientifically show that migraine headaches were due to the injury, the headaches would not be ratable.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Brigham et al. (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: