Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Highlights the ongoing debate regarding the macroscopic structure of the heart, particularly the myocardial band concept, and its relevance to surgical restoration.
The anatomy of the heart is certainly of major interest to all of us who are involved in its surgical repair. Over the years, various concepts have been introduced with regard to the structure of the heart, but some degree of controversy has always been around. As a matter of fact, the plates in the very famous De humanis corporis fabrica by A Vesalius from 1543 [1] show cross sections of the heart indicating its layered structure, whereas one can read in Heister's anatomy from 1753 [2], that the fibers of the heart are crossing in various fashions (Fig. 1). The 1778 edition of the Encyclopédie[3] mentions, that the dissection of the heart reveals a double layer of spiral fibers, the outer layer forming some sort of screw between the base and apex. More recently, Torrent-Guasp has reviewed the macroscopic structure of the heart and introduced the concept of the myocardial band [4], a dissection of the three dimensional, four chambered heart, resulting in one single strip of muscle (the myocardial band). There can be no doubt that this type of dissection can be realized in reproducible fashion. Likewise, during surgery, e.g. pulmonary auto-graft harvesting for the Ross procedure, a plane can sometimes be developed within the inter-ventricular septum (personal experience), which greatly facilitates this crucial step. Torrent-Guasp and colleagues have also developed new concepts about the functional impact of the myocardial band [5]. The latter have triggered an extremely intriguing discussion [6], which is ongoing in this issue with papers by Lunkenheimer [7], Torrent Guasp [8], and Buckberg [9]. It has to be added here, that new knowledge is gathered permanently in many fields that interfere with the discussion mentioned above. At the embryologic level, it is traditionally accepted that the heart forms out of bilateral cardiac mesoderm, which migrates from the lateral region of the embryo to the ventral midline, where it fuses. The fact, that a recent study [10] looking into cardiac morphogenesis showed that highly differentiated four-chambered mammalian hearts can be formed in each bilateral heart forming region of Foxp4 mutant mice, makes clear, that during evolution, various concepts can emerge and it seems that some may even coexist. Considering the current developments in the field of restoration of the heart at the cellular level, this finding adds also further evidence that pluripotent cells are present at multiple locations of the body. Obviously not everything is carved in stone, and some degree of flexibility appears to be necessary for improved understanding of the structure of both, the normal and the pathological heart, which in turn is of prime importance for surgical restoration of its form and function. Reproduction from Heister's anatomy (1753) plate 2, Fig. 8 showing that the fibers of the heart are crossing in various fashions as mentioned in his text.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ludwig K. von Segesser (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: