Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
BOOK REVIEWS 2014 109 other regions.The book is quite simply beautiful; from the stunning photography to the detailed drawings and illustrations, it exceeds production values associated with award-winning coffee-table volumes. The hundreds of color and black-andwhite photographs and line drawings bring the subject matter to life. The editors have done a masterful job of creating consistency and readability without extinguishing the individual authors'voices. A minor critique is that the second half of the book, which focuses on the physical evidence, gets quite technical; a glossary would have been helpful for nonprofessional readers. The editors and authors are to be congratulated on an exemplary piece of scholarship. They have crafted a significant volume on the Chesapeake's built environment that will serve scholars for years to come. University of Maryland Donald W. Linebaugh Crossroads of Empire: The Middle Colonies in British North America. By Ned C. Landsman. (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2010. 254 pp. Illustrations , notes, bibliographic essay, index. Cloth, $45; paper, $25.) This concise overview of the middle colonies as a unified region of major importance to colonial British North America will be extremely useful to specialists and can also be effectively assigned in undergraduate courses. Ned Landsman, wielding a graceful pen,draws on a thorough understanding of the region 's scholarship to offer balanced judgments throughout this persuasive work of synthesis.The three opening chapters explore the native and non-English origins of the middle colonies and the proprietary circumstances of the Duke of York and Penn's regimes; the four remaining chapters present the region at the crossroads of commerce, religious and ethnic diversity, philosophy and faith, and politics. The author repeatedly employs comparisons and contrasts between individuals, groups, and movements—e.g., James Stuart and William Penn, Dutch and Scots settlers, evangelicalism and the Enlightenment, Benjamin Franklin and George Whitefield—to adroitly balance specific details and broad generalizations. Although the book is a short work on a subject that demands substantial geographic and chronological breadth, it gives serious attention to varied native nations, women, struggles over colonial colleges, and European influences. Landsman does not just address important seventeenth-century English political developments for the middle colonies but also provides rich insights about the Netherlands, Scotland, and Ulster. His careful writing, which eschews hyperbole, helps him to argue effectively for the significance of the region at the center of British North America and as a precursor for later major social developments. The book further makes an argument about the importance of chronology: "It was the emergence of the Middle Colonies as a commercial BOOK REVIEWS 110 January crossroads at the center of the imperial contest, more than the specific activities of mid-Atlantic residents during the Revolutionary era, that gave Philadelphia the national importance for which it is celebrated" (2). Landsman convincingly presents New York and Pennsylvania, each with its dominant city,as interconnected components of a single region that shared a common history.His core focus is on the territories that would become "English"New York, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey. In exploring this terrain, we learn a fair bit about the region's northern boundary and its conflict and overlap with New England (especially in East Jersey and Long Island) but little about its southern boundary, Delaware, or about how the middle colonies blended into—or confronted—regional norms in the Chesapeake. Pennsylvania Germans may also have merited more sustained attention.The chapters average just over eleven footnotes each, which is somewhat compensated for by a thoughtful ten-page historiographic essay. While largely a work of synthesis, Crossroads of Empire makes a number of original contributions, especially regarding cultural diversity (chapter 5) and the Great Awakening and Enlightenment (chapter 6). A nuanced exploration of the varied meanings of pluralism and the related development of toleration as a matter of policy—which did not necessarily include tolerance—is especially valuable. While opening and closing with Crèvecoeur's classic "What is the American?" assertion of pluralism, Landsman's attention to "continual struggles over identities and power" excavates the region's charged encounter with diversity (143). While Crèvecoeur described a "settler pluralism" (emphasizing improved land and silently excluding Africans and Indians) that...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Liam Riordan (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: