Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Nurses on the Move: Migration and the Global Health Care Economy Mireille, Kingma , 2005 ; Cornell University Press : Ithaca, New York, USA , as part of the Culture and Politics of Health Care Work series: 288 pages. Available in cloth (ISBN: 0-8014-4305-9 ) and in paper ( ISBN: 0-8014-7259-8 ). Have you ever done a web search using ’migration’ as your key word? When I was handed the file on health worker migration at the World Health Organization (WHO), now more than three years ago, that's what I did. Within 10 seconds I had more than a million hits, and this was my first glimpse into the complexities of human migration. Articles and information can be found from the fields of demography, geography, social sciences, economics, anthropology and now the health literature too. Add to this pile those newspaper and current affairs journal articles that express (usually) moral outrage at migration, for one reason or another. Now you are getting some idea of what Dr Kingma, a consultant on nursing and health policy for the International Council of Nurses (ICN), faced in compiling this comprehensive volume on nurse migration. The development of a global health workforce over the last decade has many simple explanations – none of which fully represent the reality or complexity of the situation. The truth of the matter is that the view of migration is different depending on where you are standing. Dr Kingma has succeeded in standing in many places to give us a rich picture of nurse migration, often drawing on the experiences of migrant nurses themselves to show that migration is a story about people– their choices, their work and their loyalties. Though Nurses on the Move: Migration and the Global Health Care Economy is centred around the experience of nurses, it certainly does not neglect the emerging evidence base on reasons for health worker migration, nor the political and economic landscape that surrounds it. Dr Kingma reminds us that migration is not new, but it is changing as the ‘global village’ expands. Now, one out of every 35 people is a migrant and half of those migrants are women. Nurses move for many reasons, some of which are to do with personal and professional development, and some with the economic framework within which their health system functions. Lack of fiscal space to expand the health sector, or even to keep it on an even keel, can result in unemployment among nurses, even when there are vacancies in the health workforce. The challenges of ensuring that there are enough nurses in the health system will only be met when issues of retention, including pay, are adequately addressed. Is it significant that nurses are almost all women, with jobs that are essential, but undervalued as invisible work? Paradoxically, this is an issue of as much relevance to recruiting countries as it is to those countries losing nurses – both need to address their recruitment and retention issues. The final chapter of the book leads us through some policy options for managing migration, whatever our perspective, and again reflects the difficult choices that sometimes have to be made. Nurse migration only mirrors other important issues: the chronic underinvestment in health systems and the health workforce that has led to a decline in working conditions and pay in so many places; the rights that people should have to move; the new choices that women have about the way they live their lives. And through it all, the role of the state in monitoring and guiding policies that are fair and support the weakest countries and people. As a global community we are found wanting. Nurse migration is a symptom that we should not ignore. It heralds a serious disorder that can only be treated with a new respect for the profession of nursing and for nurses who more often than not, set out on the migration road because they want to do a good job for a living wage. If you are interested in the migration of health workers, the labour market relating to nurses, in matters of trade, economic development and globalization, this book is for you. Barbara Stilwell is a Coordinator in the Department of Human Resources for Health at WHO in Geneva. She has worked in health systems development at WHO since 1998. She is a nurse practitioner, educated in the UK and USA, and has practised with isolated populations in Africa, Australia and the Caribbean. She has published widely on nursing and primary health care and more recently on issues relating to workforce development, especially migration. The book can be ordered on line in clicking on ‘Nurses on the move’ on the ICN website home page: http://www.icn.ch
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Barbara Stilwell (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: