Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The essays in this volume contend with what communitarian civic life can and must look like in the twenty-first century, challenging readers to face a reckoning. They explore the possibilities for civic sociality in an increasingly fragmented world in which populism is on the rise globally, and Black, Indigenous, and people of color continue to die in the United States as a result of state-sanctioned violence. At the same time, the fragilities of the American electoral system have come into sharper focus, and the democratic experiment feels precarious. The first two essays in this volume set the philosophical stage with ethical considerations about the relationship of the individual to the community, private selves to public spaces, personal identity to group belonging: Shannon Dunn grapples with the promises of identity politics in light of philosophical and political critiques, and Caleb Murray redefines Jamesian (and American) individualism for the ethical collective. Next follow two case studies of identity and social justice: Akiko Ochiai excavates the history of Black monuments in the United States, and Akshaya Kumar analyzes the particularities of caste in Indian cinema. Each essay investigates the nature and meaning of justice through its particular disciplinary framework: philosophy, art history, film studies. Each invites the reader to join the democratic conversation with “not light, but fire,” as Matthew R. Kay, quoting Frederick Douglass, has characterized the space for difficult but necessary discussions of identity.The volume opens with an essay that lays the groundwork for understanding modern justice movements. Dunn offers a brief history of how, in the philosophical tradition of John Rawls and Mark Lilla, the notion of identity politics has sometimes assumed an anti-democratic or sectarian valence. Dunn then responds incisively to such anxieties through feminist philosophers Joan W. Scott, the Combahee River Collective, and Linda Martin Alcoff. Dunn concludes with a constructive view of identity politics as the bedrock for democratic life, defining identity as narrative and performative rather than deterministic; as necessarily contextual in relation to social justice; and as the “basis for ethical responsibility” in a properly robust form of “social solidarity.” Dunn’s essay offers readers a philosophical history of arguments about identity politics that deepens our understanding of contemporary political rhetoric around identity.The next essay explores the surprising possibilities for democratic solidarity and ethical communality through the individual. In theorizing the “sociality of despair,” Murray revisits scholarship on William James that has long held–and sometimes critiqued–this American intellectual icon as a paragon of American individualism and private interiority. Murray turns this notion on its head, arguing that we have mistaken “social service” for “solitary self-fashioning.” “The paradox of Jamesian individualism,” argues Murray, “is that the self is made by and for public-facing ethical activity,” constituting not, as might be feared, a pack of narcissistic, inward-looking individualists, but rather, a “society of selves.”Ochiai intervenes in the urgent debate about public monuments in America, detailing the history of public commemorative spaces from the boom in Confederate monument-building at the turn of the twentieth century (decades after the Civil War ended) to the subsequent demand, in the past six years, for the removal of Confederate symbols from public spaces, to the construction of African American monuments in the post-Civil Rights era. While the integration of African American monuments in public landscapes necessarily acknowledged the “historic centrality of race” to American memory, Ochiai observes that “their juxtaposition with former Confederate monuments ironically created a parallel ‘dual heritage’” that seemingly separated the two histories. Ochiai’s meticulous analysis and review of monument research proves what we have long suspected–that Confederate monuments are less a “neutral” document of America’s nineteenth-century history and more a political backlash to twentieth-century movements for equity, desegregation, and inclusion. Ochiai concludes by applying the concept of “dialogic-” and “anti-monumentality” to contemporary imperatives to racially desegregate the memorial landscape of U.S. public spaces, imagining new and revitalized forms of commemoration in the era of Black Lives Matter.In the fourth essay, Kumar invites readers to consider how global concepts of social justice have formed the “universally legible aesthetic” that sometimes misreads the “particularity of caste politics” in India. Kumar offers a detailed account of Indian cinema and film theory in relation to the history of caste critique. He focuses on the “ambiguous politics” of Nagraj Manjule’s Marathi film Sairat (2016) as a case study of how interpretations and remakes of the movie have obscured caste critique as class divide through an archetypal aesthetics of romantic melodrama. Kumar’s intricate analysis of Sairat unfolds against the backdrop of his broader understanding of the “structural aspects of industrial cinema, political aesthetics, and the historical geography of caste politics,” all of which take readers through carefully wrought theories of realism, melodrama, and caste in Indian cinema.The volume concludes with Christophe Irmscher’s review of Jeffrey B. Ferguson’s book, Race and the Rhetoric of Resistance (2021), which explores new forms of collective, liberatory action beyond traditional rhetorics of resistance, theorizing a revolutionary movement that not only “discusses” but also “embodies” Blackness.Taken together, the essays in this volume offer an honest, multi-faceted appraisal of the gains and losses of social justice movements in the contemporary world. The authors focus on the nexus of identity and justice in relation to race and gender in the U.S. and class and caste in India. Along the way, they invite us to acknowledge our blind spots and equip us with potentially corrective tools. The essays in this volume imagine in various forms that new liberatory act, the revolutionary form of “togetherness”—to quote Irmscher—that our contemporary world needs to take the collective next step into the future.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rachel Blumenthal (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: