Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article explores how audio description (AD) actively contributes to storytelling by engaging with the material and sensory dimensions of audiovisual content. Building on the broader philosophical tensions between objectivity and subjectivity, it reconceptualizes AD as a co-creative and interpretive process that transcends the neutrality traditionally demanded by the audiovisual industry. Drawing on Hannah Thompson’s (2017) concept of “blindness gain” and Marco Caracciolo’s (2023) “spectrum of materiality”, the study highlights AD’s dynamic role in shaping narrative meaning. Thompson repositions blindness as a source of perceptual and creative insight, while Caracciolo (2023) emphasizes the relational and transformative potential of materiality in narrative engagement. By synthesizing these perspectives for the first time, this article frames AD as a relational practice deeply intertwined with the sensory and material properties of audiovisual source texts. Through a comparative analysis of two ADs for the Belgian-Israeli miniseries Rough Diamonds (Shamir et al., 2023; Shamir & Verheyden, 2023)—one by Netflix and the other by VRT, Flanders’ public broadcaster—the article highlights contrasting approaches to material engagement. The Netflix AD prioritizes clarity and spatial coherence, reflecting fixed and determinate materialities that subtly reinforce ocularcentric paradigms. In contrast, the VRT AD employs abstraction and nuance, aligning with vibrant materialities that enhance the narrative’s symbolic and emotional dimensions. These divergent strategies reveal the limitations of the current neutrality standard in AD, which often overlooks its interpretive and generative nature. By situating AD within a framework that integrates blindness gain and materiality, the study reimagines AD as a culturally resonant practice that enriches audiovisual storytelling through multisensory and culturally resonant engagement. Ultimately, this article positions AD as a dynamic medium for narrative negotiation, encouraging further interdisciplinary research into its co-creative material possibilities.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Alexandra J. Sánchez (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: