Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We investigated the extent to which media affords emotional inferences. We first test media affordances for emotional inferences between text and graphic narratives and then test features of each medium to support the generation of emotional inferences. For graphic narratives, we investigated varying shot scales of panels to highlight characters’ facial expressions, and for text narratives, we investigated the explicit descriptions of characters’ facial expressions. We analyzed archival verbal protocol data from a study in which students at a university in the Southeastern United States thought aloud while reading text and non-linguistic graphic versions of narratives. Participants’ (N = 51) verbal protocols at the sentence and panel level were coded for the presence of an emotional inference. Participants were more likely to generate an emotional inference for the graphic narratives compared to the corresponding text narratives. For graphic narratives, participants were more likely to generate an emotional inference for panels that closely frame characters’ faces (i.e. extreme close-up, close-up, and medium close-up shots). For text narratives, participants were more likely to generate an emotional inference when a facial expression was explicitly described. Both text and graphic narratives can prompt readers’ activation of knowledge related to emotion by highlighting characters’ facial expressions through the features of that medium.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ness-Maddox et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: