Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
PROLOGUE: Canadians often react to their neighbors to the south with reluctant forbearance. They suffer, in equal measure, the constant bombardment of American popular culture and Americans' near-ignorance of (and apathy toward) the Canadian cultural and political landscape. Nonetheless, in matters of health policy, fruitful exchanges do occur. Much has been written about health care, Canadian-style (not all of it flattering), in the context of U.S. health system reform. In the area of mental health policy, however, it is the U.S. system that has had the greater influence. This paper traces the pathways of influence between the two nations, with some valuable lessons for cross-national interchange in general and mental health policy in particular. David Rochefort is professor of political science and public administration at Northeastern University in Boston. With grant support from the Canadian embassy and the province of Quebec, he has been working on a comparative study of Canadian mental health policy reform. He holds advanced degrees in political science and American civilization from Brown University. Paula Goering emigrated to Canada from the United States after receiving her master's degree in nursing from Yale University. She holds a doctorate in medical science from the University of Toronto and directs the Health Systems Research Unit at the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, Clarke Division, in Toronto. She also is a professor in the Department of Psychiatry and the Faculty of Nursing at the University of Toronto. ABSTRACT: The Canadian health care system has been frequently discussed but firmly rejected as a model for guiding the transformation of American medicine. In mental health care, however, one can find a growing convergence between the two systems. This convergence is largely coming about as a result of Canadian borrowing from American programs and strategies. In this paper we provide examples of planning, service, and policy elements in U.S. mental health care that Canadians have drawn upon. We analyze this phenomenon in terms of cross-national policy learning, identifying the factors and forces that facilitate this trend for Canada while impeding it for the United States.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rochefort et al. (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: