Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Before the advent of instrumental records, up to 20 observations a day were carried out at specific sites, by the same observer, following defined rules.Despite this plethora of data, many scientists are of the opinion that observations made before the instrumental period are "subjective" and less reliable than natural proxies.But these data were collected by very experienced scientists and observers.Once calibrated and verified in the present, the data are precise and have a spatiotemporal resolution unmatched by any other climate proxy data.They are probably the best data source for the reconstruction of climatic state parameters in continental areas for the period between 1500 and 1850.In addition, a world-wide data base of daily information is being put together for the worlds major oceanic areas from naval logbooks (project CLIWOC).Natural disasters are a major source of societal concern in the context of climatic change.However, the record of instrumental measurements is too short to explore natural patterns of disasters.This also holds for investigations into societal vulnerability.In this context, documentary evidence is invaluable.This issue of PAGES News mirrors the fact that investigations on documentary data are unevenly distributed on the globe.On one hand, this distribution is related to the abundance and availability of the data sources, which, in China go back for several thousand and in Europe for several hundred years.On the other hand, this kind of research has until recently been somewhat neglected in the Americas, where written sources begin with the European settlement.In Australia and in Africa records are almost absent.Curiously, hardly any research has been devoted to the Islamic world, despite its long standing tradition of keeping annals.Dealing with documentary data requires a historian's skills.Scientists tend to overlook the pitfalls inherent in this data and are usually not familiar with old languages, institutions and hand-writing.On the other hand scientists are needed for statistical analysis and climatological interpretation of the data.Worldwide, many thousand volumes with daily observations exist, but have not yet been analyzed for their climatic information.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pfister et al. (2002) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: