Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Corn ( Zea mays L.) and soybean [ Glycine max (L.) Merr.] growth and yields, and production costs were evaluated for three tillage systems on a 432‐acre site in southeast Iowa from 1980 to 1987. The three tillage systems were: no‐till (NT), slot planting into the previous year's crop residue; reduced tillage (RT), disking and/or field cultivating for primary and secondary tillage; and conventional tillage (CT), fall moldboard plowing with disking/field cultivating as secondary tillage. Averaged over the rotation, the percentage residue cover remaining after planting was 72, 26, and 3% for NT, RT, and CT, respectively. Date of crop emergence and date of 75% silking for corn were similar among tillage systems, but corn plant densities were generally lower for NT. Eight‐year average corn yields for NT (138 bu/acre) were lower (α = 0.01) than for RT (146 bu/acre) or CT (144 bu/acre). Eight‐year average soybean yields were not significantly affected by tillage. With the elimination of primary and secondary tillage, NT required fewer machine operations than RT or CT. Averaged over the rotation, NT had 5.4 operations/year compared with 7.3 operations/year for RT and 8.2 operations/year for CT. NT had lower fuel, labor, and machine costs, but higher pesticide costs than RT or CT. The RT system had the lowest annual production cost ($120.60/acre for corn and $102.77/acre for soybeans). The CT system had the highest annual corn production cost ($132.32/acre) due to greater machine costs, and the NT system had the highest annual soybean production cost ($111.67/acre) due to higher pesticide costs. The combined incentives of greater profitability for the RT system and compliance with the 1985 Food Security Act may favor reduction of tillage in the future.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Brown et al. (1989) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: