Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Since 1970, approximately 750 knee replacements of various types have been performed at The Hospital for Special Surgery. The designs used have included both condylar and hinge type prostheses. The results, while satisfactory, have not approached the consistency or general excellence of hip arthroplasty. In particular there are certain problem areas which continue to present difficulty. These include: Patellofemoral Joint. It has become apparent that unsatisfactory pain relief following knee arthroplasty is often due to the patellofemoral articulation. About 15 per cent of the patients with arthroplasties have severe and disabling pain from this source and many more have minor or intermittent symptoms. The problem is greater in osteoarthritis than rheumatoid arthritis. Patellectomy has not proved a solution. Fixation of the Tibial Component. A radiolucent line develops around the plastic tibial component with great frequency, often becoming more pronounced with time. While the significance of such radiolucencies is not fully determined, it is probable that they represent insecure fixation. Wilde has reported 10 per cent of clinical loosening of the tibial component requiring reoperation and our experience has been similar. The frequency of radiolucency is much greater for the tibial component than the femoral and this is consistent with the observed loosening of the component. Surgical Technique. Knee arthroplasty is a difficult technical procedure. Moreover, the problems of accurate placement increase with the degree of preoperative deformity and contracture making hinge type arthroplasty attractive in these circumstances. The disadvantages of hinges are well known and it is evidently desirable that a non-hinge prosthesis should have wide applicability without presenting insuperable difficulties during insertion. The Total Condylar Prosthesis (TCP) was developed as our solution to these problems. This paper presents the preliminary experience with particular emphasis on design feature and technique. DESCRIPTION OF TOTAL CONDYLAR PROSTHESIS A non hinged prosthesis with a cobalt chrome alloy femoral component and high density polyethylene tibial and patella components. The femoral component is anatomically shaped when viewed laterally in that the radius of curvature posteriorly is less than the anterior part. Thus, in extension there is conformity with the tibial component but as flexion progresses, rotary and anteroposterior sliding motions are permitted. The tibial articular surface is cupped to receive the femoral component and stability is further enhanced by a median intercondylar eminence. When articulated, the prosthesis requires a considerable “screw-out” motion to dislocate the components. With reference to the foregoing problem areas, the important features are: Patella Articulation. The femoral component has a grooved flange for the patella. There is an optional patella “dome,” the design considerations of which have been previously described. Tibial Fixation is enhanced by a stout central peg which is shaped to fit against the strong posterior cortex of the tibia. Experimentally, this peg greatly strengthens fixation, but cruciate ligament excision is required. However, we agree with Freeman that the absence of the cruciates does not compromise stability if the prosthesis is correctly designed and accurately inserted. METHOD In addition to improving tibial fixation, cruciate excision makes possible a more precise surgical technique. The principle of the operation is similar to that of Freeman. Stability is obtained by inserting the prosthesis so that the collateral ligaments are at proper length, both in full extension and 90° of flexion. The “cup” shaped articulation is such that anterior, posterior or rotary subluxation cannot occur without a “screw-out” motion which is resisted by increased tension of the collateral ligaments. Side to side subluxation is resisted by the medial eminence of the tibial component. Stability is further enhanced by weight-bearing by reason of the “cupping” which centers the prosthesis. Accuracy of insertion is therefore essential and the instrumentation must be followed exactly. The prosthesis cannot be positioned by “eye.” Three basic instruments accomplish the three essential steps of the procedure. The instruments guide the cutting tool (preferably an end cutting reciprocating saw) by means of slots which minimize error. The Tibial Cutter (No. 1 Instrument, Fig. 1) (figure not shown) is in the shape of a cross and is located by a stem which is inserted into the intramedullary canal of the femur. A centering hole is made between the femoral condyles at the anterior margin of the intercondylar notch: the insertion of the posterior cruciate ligament indicates the proper place. The knee is positioned at exactly 90° using the vertical arm of the instrument for reference. The horizontal arm in which there are two slots is positioned at right angles to the long axis of the tibia: this is best visualized by standing back and viewing from afar. A fixation pin is then driven into the tibia. The purpose of the instrument is to cut the upper tibia at right angles to the long axis of the bone in both the sagittal and coronal planes using the slot that removed the least bone. The tibial cut determines the fit of the prosthesis in flexion. The Femoral Shaper (No. 2 Instrument, Fig. 2) (figure not shown) is also located by an intramedullary stem. It is a block with lateral handles in which there are two slots. Its purpose is to resect the anterior and posterior condylar surfaces parallel to the long axis of the femur. The Femoral Cutter (No. 3 Instrument, Fig. 3) (figure not shown) has a plate which is fitted on the cut surface of the tibia and a handle at right angles through which traction is applied to the leg with the knee extended. There are two slots which indicate the amount of bone to be removed from the distal end of the femur. (The proximal slot is used when the tibia is cut for the thick tibial component and the distal slot when the tibia is cut for the thin component.) This step determines the fit in extension and corrects varus or valgus deformity as well as pre-existing flexion contracture. A spacer is used after Steps 2 and 3 to check that the appropriate amount of bone has been removed. The fit should be snug in both flexion and extension. In extension, the spacer is also used in conjunction with the longitudinal rod to check the overall alignment of the limb. MATERIAL The Total Condylar Prosthesis has been used at The Hospital for Special Surgery for two and one half years and approximately 300 replacements have been performed. The first 100 consecutive patients are under study. Sixteen are bilateral, giving a total of 116 prostheses. In 81, the patella dome was used, in 33, the patella was not replaced and two had a previous patellectomy. The preoperative diagnosis was osteoarthritis in 68, rheumatoid arthritis in 40, post-traumatic in three, osteonecrosis in one and failure of another prosthesis in four. ACCURACY OF COMPONENT PLACEMENT (Figs. 4A and B) (figures not shown) A variation of 5° is acceptable. We defined “ideal” placement of the TCP as follows: A) Tibial component—90° to the long axis of the tibial shaft in both the anteroposterior and lateral roentgenograms. Placement in the anteroposterior view was 99 per cent accurate and in the lateral view 92 per cent accurate. B) Femoral component—In the anteroposterior roentgenogram, the component should be positioned in 5° of valgus and in the lateral view at right angles to the long axis of the femoral shaft. The accuracy of placement in the anteroposterior view was 82 per cent and in the lateral view 73 per cent. C) Overall-alignment: 5° of valgus. The accuracy was 94 per cent and the error in alignment was in a varus direction in two knees and a valgus direction in five knees. RADIOLUCENCY AROUND THE COMPONENTS Radiolucent lines all incomplete were observed at the cement bone interface of the tibial component in 29 knees. In 21 knees (18%) this was present in the immediate postoperative films and probably represents a thin film of blood between the cement and bone: the radiolucency was non-progressive and thus of questionable significance. In 8 knees (7%) a radiolucency developed subsequently, but in none did it exceed I mm in thickness. Initial radiolucencies were observed around the patella component in 4 knees (3.5%). DISCUSSION It is not our purpose to dwell on the clinical evaluation of the Total Condylar Prosthesis which will be the subject of a further paper when the follow-up is longer. The preliminary results are encouraging, and at present, the proportion of good and excellent results exceeds that obtained with any other knee prosthesis that we have so far used. Pain relief has been more uniform and predictable and this we attribute to replacement of the patellofemoral articulation. Comparing knees in which the plastic patella dome was used with those in which it was not, the differences are not striking, but the knee seems to feel more “normal” to the patient when the patella component was used. This was particularly noticeable to patients with bilateral replacements, one with the patella and one without. We believe that more time must elapse before final judgment is made on this point because an addition of a third component obviously increases the risk of component loosening and failure. Loosening was not observed and the incidence of developing radiolucency has been less than 10 per cent for all three components. This compares favorably in our experience with other prostheses. Tibial radiolucencies were present after a similar follow-up period in 55 per cent of the Duocondylar, 65 per cent of the Unicondylar, and 85 per cent of the Geometric prostheses. We strongly believe positioning of a knee prosthesis is very important, and the long term survival of the implant will depend on accurate placement. Inaccuracies in technique result in abnormal stresses which will cause loosening, cold flow and accellerated wear. A major consideration in the design and instrumentation in the Total Condylar Prosthesis was to achieve this precision even in severely deformed knees. Placement of the tibial component was acceptably accurate, but there was some error in the placement in the femoral component: the most frequent mistake was positioning this component with too much valgus tilt. The series represents early cases during which the technique was evolved and greater accuracy is desirable. In the most recent 50 cases, all done by the technique described, only one error was found in the tibial component and one in the femoral component. Can the cruciate ligaments be removed without causing instability? Six knees were unstable postoperatively. Two knees had collateral ligament instability (both osteoarthritis and four knees cruciate instability (all rheumatoid arthritis). We believe all these cases of instability were caused by technical error and illustrate two pitfalls in the technique. Instability in extension may occur in osteoarthritic knees in which asymmetry of collateral ligament length develops from the stress of walking on a deformed knee. In the more common varus deformity, the medial ligament shortens and the lateral ligament stretches: unless corrected, this imbalance will persist after replacement. Fifteen degrees of fixed deformity can be corrected by asymmetric bone resection without fear of postoperative instability but greater deformities require either tightening of lateral ligament or lengthening of the medial ligament by release from the tibia. The “medial release” has proved more satisfactory and is achieved by raising a “flap” consisting of the deep portion of the medial ligament, the periosteum with the insertion of the pes tendons and the superficial medial ligament which is divided at the distal insertion into the tibia. When traction is then applied to the tibia, the medial “flap” slides proximally and has been found to rapidly adhere without the need for postoperative immobilization. A similar release of the lateral soft tissue structures for correction of fixed valgus deformities is not recommended because of the risk of peroneal palsy. Instability in flexion is due to removal of excessive bone from the upper tibia and is most likely to occur in rheumatoid arthritis in which the knee initially is often looser in flexion than in extension. In this situation distraction of the knee in Step I of the operation will insure that the tibia is cut at the proper level to obtain the required snug fit in flexion. A similar problem can arise if the Total Condylar Prosthesis is used to revise another prosthesis: the tibia may have been previously cut at too low a level. The Total Condylar Prosthesis has proved versatile and can be used for most knees requiring replacement. The exceptions are: (1) knees with more than 120° of flexion: the Duocondylar will give a greater range of motion; (2) knees with more than 15° of fixed valgus as well as grotesque or unusual deformities in which a stabilizing prosthesis is preferred. SUMMARY The Total Condylar Prosthesis is a nonhinged unit designed to: replace the patellofemoral articulation; improve fixation of the tibial component by means of a stout central peg; permit accurate and reproducible insertion. The cruciate ligaments are excised to obtain better tibial fixation. Instability has not been a problem except in a few cases of a technical error (removal of excessive bone from the tibia creates instability in flexion). The prosthesis cannot be positioned by “eye” and the instrumentation must be applied exactly.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Insall et al. (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: