Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background/Objectives: With the development of new and better information and communication technologies, the importance of psychiatric case registers is expected to increase. A study of first-admitted patients to two psychiatric hospitals in northern Norway gave opportunity to check the validity of the routine diagnoses given by the clinicians. Methods: All new patients admitted to two psychiatric hospitals in northern Norway during one year were asked to participate. 480 patients were found eligible for participation and of these 271 gave their informed consent. 251 patients (52%) with hospital diagnoses comprised the study sample. Expert diagnoses were given on the basis of a structured diagnostic interview (Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview, MINI-PLUS) together with retrospective checking of the records. The routine diagnoses given by the treating clinician during the stay were collected from the case register of the hospitals. The agreement between the experts’ and the clinicians’ diagnoses was estimated using Cohen's kappa statistics. Results: The experts gave a mean of 3.4 diagnoses per patient, the clinicians’ gave 1.4. The agreement ranged from poor to good (schizophrenia). The most common diagnoses given by the experts were affective disorder (79%), with major depressive disorder comprising 55%. The agreement between expert and clinicians ranged from poor to good. Kappa was good only for schizophrenia and substance induced psychosis. Agreement concerning affective disorder (F30-F39) was moderate both concerning the whole spectrum, for major depression and for bipolar disorder. The agreement concerning anxiety disorder was poor (kappa=0.15), and for substance abuse it was fair (kappa=0.33). Among the diagnostic groups with the poorest agreement was bipolar disorder with Kappas ranging from 0.16 to 0.22. The largest group of the misdiagnosed bipolar patients (39%) had a diagnosis of unipolar depression (F32-F33). Discussion/Conclusions: The validity of diagnoses in psychiatric case registers seems dubious for research purposes and even for administrative and clinical purposes. This pertains especially to bipolar disorder. The diagnostic process in the clinic should be more structured. The ongoing revision of DSM-IV and ICD-10 should pay attention to this, and in some way distinguish between unipolar and bipolar depression to enhance the awareness of bipolarity in the clinic.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Øiesvold et al. (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: