Why the study?
How accurate and variable are clinicians' estimates of pre-test probability for common clinical scenarios compared to validated clinical decision rules?
How accurate and variable are clinicians' estimates of pre-test probability for common clinical scenarios compared to validated clinical decision rules?
Experienced clinicians show wide variability and often poor accuracy in estimating pre-test probabilities, highlighting the need for clinical decision rules to support decision making.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Clinicians' pre-test probability estimates show low accuracy and wide variability; supports decision rule evaluation but leaves open effects on outcomes.
OBJECTIVE: To assess the accuracy and variability of clinicians' estimates of pre-test probability for three common clinical scenarios. DESIGN: Postal questionnaire survey conducted between April and October 2001 eliciting pre-test probability estimates from scenarios for risk of ischaemic heart disease (IHD), deep vein thrombosis (DVT), and stroke. PARTICIPANTS AND SETTING: Physicians and general practitioners randomly drawn from College membership lists for New South Wales and north-west England. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Agreement with the "correct" estimate (being within 10, 20, 30, or > 30 percentage points of the "correct" estimate derived from validated clinical-decision rules); variability in estimates (median and interquartile ranges of estimates); and association of demographic, practice, or educational factors with accuracy (using linear regression analysis). RESULTS: 819 doctors participated: 310 GPs and 288 physicians in Australia, and 106 GPs and 115 physicians in the UK. Accuracy varied from about 55% of respondents being within 20% of the "correct" risk estimate for the IHD and stroke scenarios to 6.7% for the DVT scenario. Although median estimates varied between the UK and Australian participants, both were similar in accuracy and showed a similarly wide spread of estimates. No demographic, practice, or educational variables substantially predicted accuracy. CONCLUSIONS: Experienced clinicians, in response to the same clinical scenarios, gave a wide range of estimates for pre-test probability. The development and dissemination of clinical decision rules is needed to support decision making by practising clinicians.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Attia et al. (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: