Why the study?
Does preoperative echocardiography change management or delay time to surgery in patients undergoing emergency hip fracture surgery?
Does preoperative echocardiography change management or delay time to surgery in patients undergoing emergency hip fracture surgery?
Routine preoperative echocardiography for emergency hip fracture surgery significantly delays operative fixation without leading to major cardiac interventions, though it does prompt medication adjustments.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Preoperative echocardiography was associated with delayed hip fracture surgery and medication changes but no major interventions; leaves open net benefit and warrants prospective trials.
BACKGROUND: Given the well recognized imperative to treat hip fractures as expeditiously as possible there can arise uncertainty regarding the balance between pre-operative medical optimization and delay of surgery. Echocardiography is often felt to considerably delay surgery with limited change to patient management. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed forty-nine consecutive patients who had echocardiography prior to surgery for hip fracture and compared them to fifty-eight patients who did not have echocardiography. RESULTS: We found that those who had echocardiography were more likely to have medication changes (51.02% vs. 6.9%) but were unlikely to require angiography, bypass or valvular surgery prior to fracture fixation. Those undergoing echo had a longer time to surgery-3.30 days (SD=2.49) while those in the control group waited 1.5 days (SD=1.29), (p=0.005). Rates of spinal anaesthesia were similar in both groups. CONCLUSIONS: We feel that these results confirm the theory that echocardiography, as currently provided, significantly delays surgery for hip fracture and that this may negatively affect patient outcomes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
O’hEireamhoin et al. (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: