Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Across American colleges and universities during the late antebellum period, young men associated outside the classroom in literary, social, and fraternal clubs, all-male spaces highly conducive to the formation of strong friendships. Strong male relationships developed in which such terms as “intimacy,” “fraternal love,” and the “after life” were fundamental tenets of a shared experience. Unlike the collective world found in the public sphere of adult men, the antebellum college setting differed precisely because the young men quite frequently lived and dined together in dormitories, boarding and rooming houses, and fraternities, often secretly organized, in the towns and cities in which their colleges were located. Their lives were marked by dynamic uncertainty: not yet fully independent adults, but no longer completely dependent for support on their families.1Since at least the 1970s, historians have debated the possibilities of same-sex intimacy among women, the terms of which have often centered on their timing and their prevalence in early American society.2 Only recently, however, have men as gendered subjects become an area for scholarly inquiry, with the so-called New Men's History.3 Historians have demonstrated numerous instances of same-sex intimacy among males, including among college students, though the challenge of finding concrete sources for such intimacy has made definitive assessment difficult in all cases.4 Some historians have concluded that college friendships were mostly platonic products of early manhood and highly dependent on the environment in which they were formed.5 Other scholars have argued persuasively that same-sex attractions and intimacies, and not simply intimate friendships, were also distinct possibilities for college men.6 This article argues that the students themselves defined the boundaries of intimate friendships in an uncertain period prior to full adulthood. In the antebellum college, for the first and perhaps only time in their lives, young men formed strong friendships in an individual, intimate, and perhaps homoerotic world, one unregulated by parents, kinsmen, or neighbors. Inherently a fragile and temporary world—rife with the tensions created by sectional conflict, the responsibilities of impending adulthood, and societal expectations to marry—young men grappled to make meaning of the fleeting nature of their intimate friendships formed with fellow classmates, even as they hoped to maintain them beyond college.Of all the institutions of higher learning in late antebellum America, the College of New Jersey (officially renamed Princeton University in 1896) was unique in its near equal mix of young white men, from North and South and from middling and elite backgrounds.7 While most young men initially sought friendships with those from similar cultural backgrounds, over time friendships formed that integrated competing ideas about manhood, northern and southern, into a new collegiate form. For southerners, a new kind of emotional language was made available to them, one not easily accessed at southern colleges. For northerners, further contact with others from their region, as well as those from farther afield, served to widen the scope and increase the variety of possibility in the construction of their young manhood. Much as in other contexts where the bonds of party trumped those of section, at the College of New Jersey the bonds formed by young northern and southern men seem to have overcome the anxieties and dichotomies of a fraught nation, forming what one historian has called “a distinctive social regime.”8 For these young men, their friendships reflected their conceptions of manhood, coalesced around the shared experiences of living and studying together, and aimed toward an elite national education and, by extension, future in the citizenry.9To understand male friendship, the possibilities of same-sex intimacy, and the composite nature of student culture at the College of New Jersey, this article proceeds along two different paths. The first section will consider how students constructed friendships with each other in fraternities, literary societies (notably the American Whig Society and the Cliosophic Society), and on campus more broadly, through an examination of their college autograph books. If the particularities of section and class had animated their lives before college, in the crucible of the college environment the intimate friendships formed with their classmates prevailed and often superseded their previously The section will the relationships to parents, and through that intimate friendships, along with the of college to the nature of their to at longer were these young men fully dependent on their for the emotional and bonds that had previously New friendships and experiences also conceptions of and, by extension, a of the lives and of them in the for the future were in their to one and the of those most numerous in the period In the of students at the College of New Jersey to with the of and that on the of also to to one that the of the of college such to a and a fellow of the Cliosophic Society in the class of have these these this to of one will with of the of the have together the two men not of one Princeton and to the of in a and a historian of the more one but at this in all that was in the one made uncertain by the impending by no one what the future for were in not yet and similar also the of to to a of reflected on the meaning of college and the had formed with one such young a Whig and a fellow of the class of have together for two by these together, from these the of In have and in a of which to make a a more a have the of college all over for The of college have but and sought from the in the For and served as an in the during the about and more them in their autograph that each of the class to and to a the autograph were or or over with of white or The of the reflected the and on the the of the to those the and to those the in constructed the autograph the construction of or The in autograph their Some of the for with and the autograph were the and the students of their autograph to not only the of classmates, but also of of or of shared during the autograph or with their to autograph were by no as they among autograph was an intimate in which the in the of a shared In their to each young men their into of their at an of shared and a public about the meaning of friendships at a in their students, the in autograph marked the intimate emotional in their lives to student in the class of and a of the New Jersey an in autograph in the before for their shared of autograph of Princeton University of and Princeton University no the of the of from and the of collegiate as a period of other in become a and at of with to emotional and in which have to which have in all their not only of a beyond but of such a nature that they to which language to even more those of and how college students found emotional intimacy with other men and formed different conceptions of manhood in the autograph the that the young men themselves the nature of their together and found the most of their In the of intimacy, to the to the of those shared This of language perhaps reflected the nature of homoerotic intimacy and, at the such a the and possibilities of relationships two construction of intimacy through shared experiences and was a of these young In the autograph on students found to the of the intimacy that they shared with each a to in the autograph of a intimate of New Jersey to fellow Whig and of the class of the in the of one to not In the of the to to or which will to in In the of the to the that into the with a or in were to social and the of intimacy of shared men hoped to such for to and men strong to Princeton in the were not only of intimate they were also to of the For New of the class of the impending of and fellow a North a and served as a in the was most because of the intimacy the two had shared as boarding at the of formed at first has into in its full called to also hoped to by the of to autograph a of by which to a as as a on of that not of the other autograph intimacy to two hoped to the intimacy of their friendship, only in the autograph of southern and fraternal were often associated and through formed social each other as in an students formed friendships that a of perhaps even more the of The bonds of also in to sectional a to of and with other in were more to fraternal bonds at The sectional was also the with literary Whig had a higher prevalence of its the Cliosophic though friendships were section and literary While and at literary societies and fraternities, as one historian has of each was to the college a of for friendship, and The of such often not on shared cultural students often of the “after to the future Princeton as were to the fellow over these of college on this to one of and one will with of with fellow and how at the of have and shared with of and made intimate In hoped that a from a to a for a of the college living autograph and those the of future and their fellow classmates the young men, the friendships formed at college and for such in the the and the of the and that to to the of If white and the of those will the through The of through the of those in the with fellow a homoerotic as the was the intimacy of and, in also a to their shared southern along with and hoped the not the of the were a of among college students, yet the autograph were of of In autograph to the of a Princeton all that have to of and of that a was an and of young at the of but most autograph have to about with women, or were not to to those students with had created the intimacy of their most students to women, they in a of a different at In their College as the in and the have their for the College which of classmates, one to the and in this a and for an on a to Princeton the has the of more the of all classmates, and of perhaps to how to a and the student from a of an all-male into a to the of the In the the of the college friendships them as a along the toward this and also as a kind of college and one that more In one to the each student as was with the student the of and with that of and The of of young men to their classmates, and into a a of and an of same-sex relationships for future even and of the was a for the as an of their lives, young men to the of fraternal the all-male college The was further by the of southern students to the College of New Jersey to in the and the sectional tensions were reflected in the autograph autograph to New on the of intimacy in their have intimate with had together no have New to have not have more which was perhaps that the two men not similar or literary While such as were more to from southerners, young men from shared a of over or through the of the of the also southern students a with in New a to in the class of and were college to in the and even though was not in the of to an autograph to In autograph to that the nature of their had quite for has into such a male and has quite on near a In a of was “a and the of from that to with those were and The bonds of formed at college and classmates to most intimate of on in of the of the was with and for a served as a also to about for no to around for that to the in of the of to all and no that no one a in was near in not yet Much fellow the most intimate of well have the formed in college with possibility of friendships beyond college was a one for In as a during the and become a the impending from even as hoped for future and had together at the and in New Jersey before where their even to in those bonds of fraternal which no a of the time for had from a but that their a time the of the strong of friendships but in with as bonds those of and on these that will of fraternal to for a one and the possibility that of hoped to their further had developed at in the of the the possibilities for intimate friendships not New and of the class of and had a that one such have classmates and strong have lived and together during this similar on a In autograph to the intimate shared with fellow were only time the of and and as that period of has in a associated with a fellow as all of have in a at The friendships of young men and to a on which a of and as they a of that the young men not for students of Princeton and that their friendships not have their in autograph to the about college experience. was a of and the Cliosophic not the strong that of classmates had While to this with and from which to and at make to to with not in the of friendships with have the a but with them, of them as the of early For the of contact with but not the of their emotional with a for for one that have together and one well to such a to in college and college In as a in the of and perhaps because of this from the not seem to have to the college that not the intimate language in autograph by young men such as and in the of In one their autograph were not The of their friendships, with their shared experiences together, and the at as a of an to autograph of the period of such in and college the were for young men in the antebellum period in distinct young men reflected on the of shared formed through their together, which had to their of the nature of male friendship, a that they had before their the of in the college environment a fleeting for the most to by more often by the bonds of The autograph to those future anxieties through the together in the language of autograph formed of a of intimate and perhaps homoerotic friendships, one that has among but was for While the of male friendships has only historians of the college have its in the lives of young an early Princeton the of the first was over had made friendships which not only during at Princeton but over ideas of during often those lived near with them While perhaps the college the nature of friendships formed and the of young men for their beyond to this the of as of the and of literary The possibility that male college students in the of the of scholars that in in The language by students marked the shared intimacy of found for the first time in their had become a time for students to on their experiences with one and to the had become with and such The of the first autograph the student that was not and with from those had In their construction and in their autograph were of the student of their lives, one in which intimate friendships and scholarly were the autograph among the most sources historians to understand the nature of the college from the student Princeton students the they even quite a about their lives The New Princeton class of autograph as the that had a have this one about at college, but full of and has a though Princeton and a in in in New Jersey, but to autograph that college classmates all Princeton also to autograph in in at the of the the of an had that a as one a of such a a new on the of autograph of by from on by a of and was in the of the and to autograph the one that with to In this of a in a of not only of autograph with but also in the of emotional The of classmates, as in the autograph of college in the of the the autograph as an to the of shared intimacy and even to them the college For students, they their autograph they with and a for future For of them, the intimacy of male friendships had and the to the of future and, had they their they more in a of the nature of college and their for the the autograph was a to the lives these antebellum college in its as for also the in gendered and in the and of their male and the and of boarding and as and for and of and the students had each which for the antebellum college a of and In this the bonds of fraternal and the young men, to their in they had students themselves how the college with its had of their by students to at often this new to an for their students at the of friendships formed at college, at a of intimacy with their classmates that those by friendships not a of the intimacy of the in college friendships one kind of intimacy, that of the for world of intimacy, that of college a variety of at not students and to the to support them through the of students to those from the that from were a of their students to with their students were that their new college and the at and and to one but with as a The in which students the of how the fraternal of college friendships them and them For the the was often in a and was often the one by In to full of their at The future of as to the College of New Jersey for in to its for was by the and the a boarding for had into the Cliosophic an that only was about to at as a for a the but a to the University of were about their though to on The and and their two Princeton and in For the time in the a of about to and the of to for a of and at among which and which no or The to at in the of and the in which was was of the at at the college, that the were and in the and as at and the only them that in the one they white and in the other other shared and about college with an on and the of first at the for more in In by to from the the of the In a the to from the of other college students and to how the of but with classmates in other not in the to the of of or a of these were While in a of that more for their though the more the all the students that a was the those of Princeton were to the of In during a period of students have by of to as during the these have these to the of the only to about with a for time to a young from of was by For the has during that time about or about the of and parents, the classmates, by or have formed but but that in of a and a a was one of the friendships which in The young men with formed friendships at Princeton were for though the toward intimacy was of the other students at the college, them to students at a the not in as they at but and not of or from students, such as a was one of the with have a in the a among with of the time for the more of in the period of an and in the of a young New responsibilities which of In the reflected on the nature of and the of them often in sources of this the autograph of classmates and, in from The that shared with fellow classmates were of a different from the had with during two at of was an of southern Princeton the was the of the of and future In at was of from that the from at often of future The young had to yet in the have in which for in a of in one to though the with in the The through in the such as a of and the class of also to and the that and had similar young men to with the of college to their at differed from in that the and campus in a college The to the different with men and in a variety of and The and of the and boarding houses, such as the one by where Princeton students and rooming houses, such as the one by where for at boarding yet have not a to no in the but an and the and the as to to an that boarding with to of and the of to a and for or were not only that was to as also were other about the of was how to as well as to for which the for but have well and on and all of were for the of While male the of male created at college not completely the of the of all the the in Princeton to for but and even among themselves to not in the to male to the for emotional In to that what college by this well and to more or to and the of the time to This well but not well only a each to a of with other young men, at the of further time in and a young to outside of the in which was for the and often of the for also the for the of even in for the by but that was were at to have new but independent fellow independent as not other toward to a of though unique in of of the Princeton class of of Princeton by Princeton was in of in a the to were more in one have more to The class of white make of the by the by on them in other was that had a to the those to and an autograph and in those of classmates, but the has not or not an autograph to Princeton in even as not to In at most from was to a was a and a class of from and had including one in they In from the of one and the of other by the relationships they had formed at a of from their The of as a of the of intimacy found in In the of the in to was during an on a their and them the with Some of and from While a at Princeton New While the with as a the also to a of the which have in with the and other which at the of hoped as an to to to on of national and In the to an and to and as as the of the of The also made to make a of to for future as a For the one of as a to to the of the before by the of a of young men from found to the of college, for the at Princeton the and the American Whig of made to that not college the of and the of and and though to make that they will in no of the the to and make In to and often at about an and a each the one to time with one has and had to and but but While hoped that the from and friendships was marked by but and was often in these was a at to on for emotional with the that the for a to for and them that not a that not of them and they the by from the In and of as all around the these with on and by at and yet with the that well and on was and or perhaps to a to the of found among The from to and were to the The however, the dynamic and This was an about the of to the of with the and to the the concluded with a of the of American this the of While was the not but the to the of the The which was found among the of the was by during a period of at and in of the on of and the of for the world to While no other that the was near at to a with as and the concluded on a the to from an sought on found in will increase the of to and an with in the of of men made in the of the a The to and the as a more an to also served to the and one that had during at and to the as the one of students and their and to strong their have also young men in the intimate friendships and new by the college of the new of them in their and at For the students the to a of and experiences in the a that students were in new and in a period of from or a of were a and of college also young men from their as new and different social in the crucible of the friendships to these new one of the young to the during their college Some students, the the of classmates the of time at such as not to fully The a of in of from and and of young American men for the first of their future an to the that had marked the lives of students at the College of New For the most the students to in the on to the the of class of class of in near and men was by fellow from but of was of the class of most was that among the northern and southern students in their college friendships and in of that friendships formed the even more and was with that these intimate were most students at the College of New Jersey, intimate male friendships had antebellum college but even before the their of college were not For the of a to the of as a For however, the college as in autograph and and as in among marked the of their these of the one a of the lives of students and more the meaning of and intimacy, the of the future in and and, in of a different kind of language of intimacy to and meaning to the friendships formed during college, the by students from and future and the of at the of in the language of intimacy, students such as and the they from their friendships into uncertain In young men to the meaning of the social bonds they had formed with each for intimacy with they and with emotional about the they for one and they shared as antebellum college such friendships in the language of fraternal often through shared living in students from all of a The college also the of dependent into independent adults, a in the nature of intimacy, first found in the at and in strong same-sex friendships. For those not the bonds of the in intimacy with with for those not to or perhaps those or even those men intimacy with their the college served as a of a in their lives in which fraternal had for the first
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thomas J. Balcerski (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: