Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Introduction: Representation MattersThe case for comics, along with graphic novels, as an academic intervention has been made, so now a task at hand for educators is to understand how comics might allow teachers and learners to think more deeply about issues of race and representation.Rather than engage in faux relevancy or tokenism, by which historically marginalized populations are "often treated as representations of their category, as symbols, rather than as individuals" (Kanter 209), I argue that educators wishing to engage students in emancipatory and generative forms of education can do so through careful and serious examination of comic books as critical texts by applying a Critical Race Theory (CRT) lens to their study.Comics as a medium has been defined in several ways.The most held definitions posit that comics are sequential art, or as Scott McCloud suggests, "Juxtaposed pictorial and other images in deliberate sequence, intended to convey information and/or to produce an aesthetic response in the viewer" (9).A comic is a single-issue, magazine-sized, oftentimes single chapter of a larger story, whereas a graphic novel is a collection of single comics in one volume, or a single story published all at once.Comic book superhero stories make up our "modern mythology" (Reynolds 42) and may be examined using CRT tenetsspecifically, counterstory, racism as normal, and whiteness as property (Harris).These explorations can afford students opportunities to fashion a sense of agentic critical literacy and praxis (Chute; Eisner; Morgan; Lankshear and McLaren), conceptualize positive selfworth, and reimagine what it means to challenge dominant cultures, understandings, and authority.When understood through a CRT lens, comic books can operate as counternarratives and reimaginings that invite students of color to "discover and play with the identification of [them]selves, where [they] are imagined, where [they] are represented" (Hall 470).When students have the critical tools, opportunity, and ability to reimagine themselves, they can Dando: Black Heroes Matter Research on Diversity in Youth Literature vol. 5, no. 1, 2023 2create for themselves emancipatory and transformative ways of thinking, knowing, and being.As David Buckingham notes, the goal of critical perspectives is to work with students so they may each become someone "who is never persuaded or fooled, who sees through the illusions the media provided" (146).Approaching comics as a means of critical literacy development through a CRT lens affords students the opportunity to engage in complex conceptions of self about race, gender, and class as well as others (Brown 41).These perspectives given theoretical and practical weight are rooted in resistance, determination, and an agentic humanity.What might a CRT reading of comics look like?This essay aims to offer a way of approaching comics education and literacy that pushes understanding beyond the borders of artistic criticism, aesthetic functionality, and simplistic academic content delivery, and into realms of social and cultural awareness through analysis of the hidden and explicit messages and metaphors found on the page.Katz), recognizing that literacy is linked to issues of culture and identity (Cummins; Moje; Yezbick et al.).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Michael Dando (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: