Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
One of the most puzzling terminologies for persons living outside of New York State (hereafter NYS) is the distinction betweel) Upstate and Downstate New York. Most current dictionaries follow Mathews' Dictionary of Americanisms (1966) in defining upstate as "a region in a state that is away from, and usu[ally] north of, some large city. Used esp [ecially] in the state of New York. " Certainly a natural assumption would be that "some large city" here means New York City, as it seems to in the 1949 quotation from the Southern Weekly, "This is the figure with complete returns from Greater New York and 19 up-State districts missing" (Mathews 1966: upstate). But Mencken (1963: 299-300) says that " Upstate designating New York State north and west of Albany is recorded from 1901, but is probably older' , (emphasis mine). Mathews does not list downstate, but Webster's New World Dictionary (1978) defines it vaguely as "that part of a State farther to the south." A survey of 151 college students from all over NYS reveals, however, that many more interpretations of Upstate and Downstate are in current use and that the definition for each depends strongly on the speaker's home locality.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Betty S. Phillips (1983) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: